Online Reviews, Trust and Landing Page Conversion
A local business can claim dependability, but a real customer review gives a prospective buyer something more concrete to evaluate.
This page reviews a dated consumer survey that compared landing pages with and without customer reviews, then turns the findings into a practical checklist for local businesses.
What the research tested
The study was run in Q4 2016 with 6,283 consumers in North America: 72% from the United States and 28% from Canada. Participants were asked to imagine searching for a local plumber, florist or realtor.
They were shown two landing pages for each industry. One page featured a real customer photograph and an actual five-star review. The other page used a business-authored message describing the company as dependable, without any user-generated review.
The panel was split so that 30% formed a control group and saw landing pages with no ratings or reviews. The remaining 70% were divided into test groups and shown different landing pages, some with reviews and some without.
The researchers tracked which businesses consumers chose and collected feedback on the factors that shaped their opinions.
Trust findings
When asked how trustworthy they found the business, 83% of participants considered the business with the user-generated review on its landing page trustworthy. In addition, 15% said they did not find the business without reviews trustworthy.
The result suggests that a page carrying a real customer review created a stronger trust impression than a page relying only on a self-description. The survey measured perception, not a guaranteed conversion lift.
Contact findings
Participants were then asked how likely they would be to reach out to each business. For businesses with reviews on their landing pages, 74% said they would contact the business. For businesses without reviews, 62% said they would contact the business.
The gap is useful as directional evidence: reviews were associated with both a higher trust rating and a greater stated willingness to make contact. It does not prove that every review placement will produce the same result in a live campaign.
Broader review context
Reviews also matter earlier in the buying journey. In a separate local consumer review study, positive reviews made 91% of consumers more likely to use a business. The average consumer read 10 reviews before feeling able to trust a local business. After reading positive reviews, 32% visited a company website and 16% visited the business itself.
On the search side, two ranking-factor studies from 2017 and 2016 found that online reviews can help a website rank in the Google Local 3-Pack and in organic local search results. Those studies are dated references; current ranking behaviour should be checked against more recent evidence.
Practical checklist for using reviews on a landing page
Before adding reviews to a local landing page, use this checklist:
- Choose a review that names the service or situation the page is about, not a generic compliment.
- Show the reviewer's first name and, where appropriate, a real photo or verified source label.
- Keep the review visible near the main call to action rather than buried below the fold.
- Pair the review with a clear next step, such as a call button or quote form.
- Avoid inventing, editing or selectively quoting a review in a way that changes its meaning.
- Treat the 83% trust and 74% contact figures as 2016 survey evidence, not as a forecast for your own page.
- Measure your own results with a simple before-and-after or A/B test rather than assuming the survey percentages will transfer.
How to read the numbers
The survey reports stated perceptions and stated contact likelihood, not observed purchases. A participant saying they would contact a business is different from that person actually calling or submitting a form.
The control group and test groups were shown different page treatments, so the comparison is useful for understanding direction. It is not a substitute for testing your own audience, offer and page design.
Because the data was collected in Q4 2016, consumer expectations and review platforms have changed since then. Use the findings as a starting hypothesis and verify current conditions before making claims about present-day performance.
Frequently asked questions
Does displaying reviews guarantee more landing page conversions?
No. The survey found a higher stated willingness to contact businesses whose pages showed reviews, but it measured perceptions rather than completed conversions. Test the placement and wording on your own page.
What kind of review works best on a local landing page?
A review that is specific to the service being advertised and clearly attributable to a real customer is more useful than a generic claim. The study used an actual five-star customer review with a customer photo.
Are the survey percentages still current?
The figures come from a Q4 2016 survey of 6,283 North American consumers. They are dated evidence, not a live benchmark. Check more recent research before treating them as current performance expectations.