Online Sources of Clicks & Calls for Local Businesses
Local businesses rarely have a clean, consolidated view of which online channels actually produce calls, site visits and usable leads.
Analytics gaps, missing call-tracking data and offline conversions make channel comparison difficult. This survey asked local-search practitioners to rate the channels they use for effort, return on investment, lead quality, website traffic and phone calls. The findings below are a dated reference from the original survey period and should be read as a hierarchy of channel performance rather than as current market data.
Five findings that frame the channel comparison
The survey condensed its results into five headline observations. Local SEO, Google Places and traditional SEO absorbed the most practitioner time. Organic search was rated the strongest channel for both ROI and lead quality. Google Places delivered substantially more traffic than Bing Local and Yahoo Local. Organic search and Google Places produced the most calls. Social channels, particularly Twitter, were not rated as strong sources of ROI or new leads. These findings are approximations from a practitioner survey, not audited analytics.
Who took part and what the sample covers
There were 288 respondents who reported optimising more than 7,100 locations in the previous 12 months. Most worked as consultants or agencies (73%) and handled multiple clients; the average respondent worked on 24 locations in that period, with some reporting over 100. The survey did not ask which industries those locations belonged to, so the results describe a practitioner view of local search rather than an industry-by-industry breakdown.
Which channels practitioners actually used
Usage was broad: over 94% of respondents had used Google Places, social optimisation, and local and traditional SEO in the previous 12 months. Display advertising was the least-used channel at 43%. Facebook and Twitter were grouped together as social optimisation for this chart. The narrow gap among the top four channels suggests that local practitioners tend to favour durable, long-term tactics over paid display and short-term campaign channels.
Where the time went
Respondents allocated the most weekly time and effort to local SEO, Google Places and traditional SEO. Mobile marketing, email marketing and display advertising received the least. Because the panel was rooted in local search, that concentration is expected. Email marketing may still be handled in-house by the business rather than reported by an agency, so its low ranking here reflects who answered the survey as much as channel value.
Return on effort and money
Organic search was rated the best channel for ROI, with Google Places and local second. Social channels, especially Twitter, were not considered good value. The pattern suggests that effort spent on local and organic search tasks was viewed as time well spent, while social activity was more associated with staying informed and communicating with existing customers than with winning new converting customers.
Which channels produced quality leads
Organic search, direct traffic and Google Places/local were rated highest for lead quality. Facebook, display advertising and Twitter were rated lower. Google AdWords was seen as a strong lead generator even though respondents spent less time on paid traffic than on social tasks. That gap between perceived lead quality and allocated effort is one of the more useful tensions in the survey.
Website traffic hierarchy
Organic search generated more site traffic than any other channel. Google Places/local delivered nearly three times the traffic of Bing Local and Yahoo Local, and Google AdWords delivered about 2.5 times the traffic of Bing Ads. The percentages in the original charts are approximations because not every respondent used every channel and some over- or under-estimated. The more reliable signal is the order of the channels, not the exact share.
Phone-call hierarchy
Call results closely mirrored website traffic. Organic search and Google Places/local produced the most calls, while Twitter, Bing Ads and display advertising performed worst. Paid search did not stand out for call generation in the way its lead-quality rating might suggest; Google AdWords and Bing Ads were rated on a par with average-performing social networks for calls. As with traffic, treat the percentages as approximations and focus on the ranking.
A practical checklist for using these findings
Use the survey as a structured starting point rather than a prescription. First, separate popularity from effectiveness: a channel can be widely used without being the strongest source of ROI or calls. Second, check your own analytics and call records against the hierarchy before shifting budget. Third, keep organic search and Google Places as core candidates if your business depends on local discovery, because they ranked highly across traffic, calls, lead quality and ROI. Fourth, treat social channels as retention and communication tools unless your own data shows they generate converting leads. Fifth, remember that the survey is dated and that channel performance changes; re-test the hierarchy for your market before committing spend.
Worked example: reading the hierarchy for one business
Suppose a local service business finds that organic search is its largest source of site visits and phone calls. The survey hierarchy supports keeping local SEO and Google Places as core channels, because those channels ranked highly for traffic, calls, lead quality and ROI. If the same business also spends heavily on social media but sees few converting leads from it, the survey suggests treating social as a supporting channel for existing-customer communication rather than as a primary acquisition channel. The exact percentages should not be copied into a plan; the value is in the relative order and in the prompt to verify against the business's own call and conversion data.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between channel popularity and channel effectiveness in this survey?
Popularity is how many respondents used a channel in the previous 12 months. Effectiveness is how those respondents rated the channel for ROI, lead quality, traffic and calls. A channel can be widely used, such as social optimisation, yet still be rated poorly for ROI or new-lead generation. The survey reports both, and the two should not be conflated when deciding where to spend effort.
Why are the traffic and call percentages described as approximations?
Not every respondent used every channel, and some over- or under-estimated the share of traffic or calls generated across channels. The survey therefore advises reading the percentages as approximations and paying more attention to the hierarchy: which channel wins out against another. The ranking is the more durable finding.
Does the survey prove that organic search is the best channel for every local business?
No. The findings reflect a practitioner panel with strong roots in local search, so the effort and ROI ratings are shaped by that audience. The survey is a dated reference and should be checked against a business's own analytics, call records and conversion data before budget decisions are made.