Phone Calls and Search Ranking Topped a 2015 Local Search KPI Poll
When a local campaign reports its progress, the choice of metric shapes the story.
A 2015 poll of 589 users of a local SEO platform put phone calls first and search rankings second, ahead of website traffic, reviews, citations and revenue impact. The figures are a dated snapshot from an SEO-skewed audience, not a current benchmark. They are still useful as a starting map: each metric proves something different, and a balanced report needs more than one of them.
What the poll measured and who answered
The poll ran for one week in August 2015 and collected responses from 589 users and readers of the platform. Most respondents were based in the US (73%), followed by the UK (13%), Canada (6%), Australia (3%) and the rest of the world (5%). Participants were asked which metrics they paid most attention to, either for their own local business or for local business clients. Because the audience was SEO-focused, the results reflect a marketer's view rather than a pure business-owner view. Treat the percentages as a historical reference point and check current conditions before using them to set targets.
The metric order at a glance
The ranking table below preserves every figure from the original poll. Read it as a single dated snapshot: the order shows what this particular audience prioritised, not what every local business should track. The gap between phone calls and search rankings is small, while the gap between the top two and revenue impact is wide. That pattern is the main thing to notice before building a reporting plan.
Why phone calls ranked first
A phone call is a lead a small business can hear and judge for itself. It does not need a dashboard to become real, and the person answering can assess whether the enquiry is serious. That directness helps explain why calls led the poll. Call tracking can extend the picture by showing which campaigns produced calls and by recording them for quality review. The caution is practical: if tracking numbers are inserted carelessly, they can create inconsistent name, address and phone data across listings, which works against local visibility. Plan the tracking setup before adding numbers to public profiles.
Why search ranking came second
Rankings are an early-stage signal. They do not guarantee sales, but without visibility a local business struggles to earn clicks and conversions from organic or local search. The poll put rankings at 46%, ahead of website traffic at 35%, which suggests this audience preferred to measure the input that drives traffic rather than traffic alone. The original commentary also noted that Google's local results had recently changed from a seven-result pack to a three-result pack, making first-page placement harder. That observation belongs to 2015 and should not be read as a description of today's results layout.
Traffic, reviews, enquiries and citations
Website traffic and online reviews tied at 35%. Traffic is tangible but sits downstream of ranking, while reviews help convert visitors without being an end conversion themselves. Website enquiries drew 27%, lower than calls because they are less immediate, though they still create leads worth following up. Citations reached 25%. They are a foundation for local search rather than a closing conversion, and their effect is harder to show a client than calls or rankings. The original article cited a separate expert survey in which 55% called accurate citations critical to local ranking; that figure comes from a different study and should be checked at its own source.
Revenue impact and the patience problem
Only 22% selected revenue impact, and Google My Business insights came last at 8%. The low revenue figure is best read in context: the audience was SEO-focused, and a poll of business owners might have weighted revenue more heavily. Local search work also takes time to affect the bottom line. Judging a campaign solely on early revenue can stop promising work before it has had time to show results. The practical answer is a staged set of metrics: visibility first, contact and conversion signals next, revenue over a longer horizon.
A checklist for choosing your own KPI set
Use the poll as a prompt, not a prescription. Work through these questions before fixing a reporting plan.
- Which metric proves visibility? A ranking measure tied to the search terms that matter to the business.
- Which metric proves contact? Calls, with a tracking method that does not damage name, address and phone consistency.
- Which metric proves intent? Website enquiries and form submissions, reviewed for lead quality rather than volume alone.
- Which metric proves trust? Review volume and rating, treated as a conversion aid rather than a final result.
- Which metric proves foundation? Citation accuracy and consistency, reported as a data-quality measure.
- Which metric proves outcome? Revenue or booked jobs, measured over a long enough window to reflect the work.
- Who is the report for? An SEO audience and a business owner will weight these differently, so explain the stages rather than presenting one number as the whole story.
Worked example: reading a mixed report
Imagine a local service business that reports a 46% ranking position, a 48% call share and a 22% revenue share in the same period. Read alone, the revenue figure looks weak. Read alongside the other two, it shows a campaign that is winning visibility and contact but has not yet converted that into booked revenue. The correct response is not to abandon the work; it is to check whether calls are being answered, whether enquiries are followed up and whether the measurement window is long enough. The percentages here are illustrative uses of the poll figures, not a forecast for any business.
What this poll does not tell you
The poll describes what a self-selected group of platform users said they watched in 2015. It does not measure campaign performance, prove that one metric causes another, or establish current industry norms. The audience was skewed toward SEO practitioners, and the sample was drawn from one platform's users. Use the figures to structure a conversation about measurement, then validate any target against your own account data and the current search landscape.
| Metric | Share of respondents |
|---|---|
| Phone Calls | 48% |
| Search Ranking | 46% |
| Website Traffic | 35% |
| Online Reviews | 35% |
| Website Enquiries | 27% |
| Citations | 25% |
| Revenue Impact | 22% |
| Google My Business (GMB) insights | 8% |
Dated snapshot from a one-week poll of 589 platform users and readers in August 2015. The audience was SEO-focused and self-selected. Figures are historical and should not be treated as current benchmarks.
Frequently asked questions
Which local search metric was most important in the 2015 poll?
Phone calls led with 48%, followed by search ranking at 46%. Website traffic and online reviews tied at 35%, website enquiries reached 27%, citations 25%, revenue impact 22% and Google My Business insights 8%. These are historical figures from a self-selected SEO audience.
Why did revenue impact score so low?
The poll audience was SEO-focused rather than made up of business owners, so the answers reflect a marketer's priorities. The original commentary also argued that local search takes time to affect revenue, and that judging a campaign only on early revenue can end promising work too soon.
What is the risk of using call tracking numbers?
If tracking numbers are added without care, they can create inconsistent name, address and phone data across listings. That inconsistency can work against local visibility. Plan where tracking numbers appear so that core listing data stays consistent.
Should I track only one KPI?
No single metric covers the whole journey. Visibility, contact, enquiry, trust and revenue each prove a different stage. A staged set of metrics gives a clearer picture and helps explain progress to a client or business owner.