Skip to content

How Star Ratings Change Search Clicks: A Review of the Evidence

When a search result shows stars, searchers get a quick signal about quality before they click.

This guide walks through a consumer-panel study run in late 2016 that tested how star ratings and review counts changed click choices in Google Local Pack and organic search results. The figures are a historical reference, not a current ranking guarantee. Use them to understand the direction of the effect and to shape review-generation priorities.

What the study tested

The research was designed to answer two practical questions: what impact do reviews and ratings have on click-through from Local Pack results, and what impact do they have on click-through from organic search results. Testing live search results directly was ruled out because manipulating real listings would be considered spam and could harm the businesses involved. Instead, the team built mock-ups of Google search engine result pages and showed different versions to a consumer panel.

The panel included 6,283 participants based in North America: 72% from the USA and 28% from Canada. The mock-ups covered three local business types — plumbers, florists and realtors — and varied both star rating and review count. In total, 18 variations were used. A control group of 30% saw results with no ratings or review counts displayed. The remaining 70% were split into test groups and shown star ratings from one to five stars. Participants were asked to imagine they were searching for that type of business and to click the listing they would be most inclined to choose.

The tests ran in October and November 2016. Treat the percentages below as a dated snapshot of consumer behaviour at that time, and check current conditions before making forecasts.

Local Pack results: more stars, more clicks

In the Local Pack tests, listings with five stars earned 69% of clicks. Four-star listings earned 59%, and three-star listings earned 44%. Listings with one or two stars earned fewer clicks than listings with no stars at all.

The pattern was consistent across the business types and page variations tested. A positive rating of three stars or more was associated with a higher click-through rate, and the higher the rating, the more clicks the listing received. Moving from three stars to five stars was linked to 25% more clicks.

A second view of the same data compared each rating with having no rating. A five-star rating earned 28% more clicks than no rating. A one-star rating reduced clicks by 11% compared with no rating. The gap between a one-star and a five-star listing was 39%.

These results point to a simple priority: if a business already has a rating below three stars, improving that rating may matter more than adding more reviews at the same low score. If the rating is already positive, moving from three to five stars is the larger click opportunity.

Why searchers picked a Local Pack listing

After participants clicked a result, they were asked why they chose it. Positive star ratings or reviews were the reason given by 56% of participants. The business name appealed to 10%, and 9% picked the top listing.

When no listings showed ratings, searchers had less information to work with and fell back on more arbitrary cues. That makes reviews useful not just as a ranking input but as a decision aid: they help a searcher compare businesses and choose one that looks like a safer bet.

Organic results: a smaller but real effect

The organic search tests used the same industries and varied star ratings and position on the page. The control group saw no stars, while test groups saw star ratings.

In organic results, five-star listings earned 19% of clicks, four-star listings earned 16%, and three-star listings earned 11%. Listings with one to three stars earned fewer clicks than listings with no stars.

The uplift was smaller than in the Local Pack. Four- and five-star results earned more clicks than no stars, but the increase was only 4% and 7% respectively, compared with 18% and 28% in the Local Pack. The organic page had ten results rather than three, which diluted the share each result could earn, and stars are visually less prominent in organic listings.

Position mattered a lot: across all organic pages tested, 52% of users clicked one of the top three results. Results with stars that appeared lower down the page received far fewer clicks than higher-ranked results. The swing in click-through between one star and five stars in organic results was 16%, compared with 39% in the Local Pack.

A practical checklist for review priorities

Use the study's direction of effect to decide where to spend effort, while treating the exact percentages as dated evidence.

  1. Check the current star rating in the Local Pack. If it is below three stars, focus first on resolving the causes of negative reviews and responding to them. The study found that one- and two-star listings earned fewer clicks than listings with no stars.
  2. If the rating is three stars or higher, aim to move it toward four or five. The study linked a move from three to five stars with 25% more clicks in the Local Pack.
  3. Ask for reviews consistently. The study's consumer panel was shown ratings, not review text, but the earlier consumer research cited in the study found that most consumers read reviews and that many will leave one when asked.
  4. Separate Local Pack work from organic rich-snippet work. Local Pack stars depend on profile reviews; organic stars depend on Schema.org AggregateRating markup for products and services.
  5. Do not assume the same uplift in every market or year. The tests used mock-ups and a North American panel in late 2016. Re-test or monitor your own click-through data before committing to a forecast.

Worked example: from three stars to five

Suppose a plumber's Local Pack listing currently shows three stars. In the study, three-star listings earned 44% of clicks and five-star listings earned 69%. The reported uplift from moving from three to five stars was 25%.

That does not mean every three-star business will gain exactly 25% more clicks by improving its rating. It means the direction of the effect was clear in the test: higher positive ratings attracted more clicks, and low ratings attracted fewer clicks than showing no rating at all. For planning, the useful question is whether the business can move from a negative or neutral rating into the four- or five-star range, and whether the review process is consistent enough to sustain it.

What this means for trust and rankings

The study's conclusion was that negative ratings reduce clicks and positive ratings increase clicks. A positive reputation can help a business stand out in search results and encourage more consumers to contact it. Beyond search, reputation supports trust in the business, which can affect conversion on the website and through other marketing channels.

The study also referenced earlier research by Moz (2017) and Local SEO Guide (2016) showing that online reviews influence where a business appears in Google's Local 3-Pack and in localised organic results. Those findings are part of the background, not a guarantee that reviews alone will improve rankings. Google continues to improve its ability to detect review spam and fake reviews, so the quality and authenticity of reviews matter.

Frequently asked questions

Do star ratings affect clicks in both Local Pack and organic results?

Yes, but by different amounts in the study. Five-star Local Pack listings earned 69% of clicks, while five-star organic listings earned 19%. The uplift from four or five stars versus no stars was larger in the Local Pack (18% and 28%) than in organic results (4% and 7%).

Is a low star rating worse than showing no rating at all?

In the Local Pack tests, listings with one or two stars earned fewer clicks than listings with no stars. A one-star rating reduced clicks by 11% compared with no rating. In organic results, listings with one to three stars also earned fewer clicks than listings with no stars.

How do I get stars to appear in organic search results?

Organic stars are not linked to Google My Business. They require Schema.org AggregateRating markup on the business website, and the reviews and ratings should relate to specific products and services rather than only the business as a whole.

How old is this study and can I rely on the percentages today?

The consumer-panel tests ran in October and November 2016. The percentages are a dated reference for the direction of the effect, not a current forecast. Search result layouts and consumer behaviour change, so check current conditions and your own click-through data before relying on the exact figures.