Skip to content

Local Consumer Review Survey 2014

This page summarises a North American consumer survey run in May–June 2014 on how people read and act on online reviews when choosing a local business.

The figures are a historical benchmark, not a current reading of consumer behaviour. Use them to understand the direction of travel and to compare against newer research.

About the survey

The 2014 edition was the fourth annual run of the local consumer review survey. Two questions were added and three removed compared with 2013. A panel of just under 5,000 individual consumers was contacted; 2,104 responses were collected, with 90% from the United States and 10% from Canada. Fieldwork ran over six weeks in May and June 2014. The focus was reviews and purchases of local business services, not wider product reviews.

How often people searched for local businesses

More than half of respondents (57%) had searched online for a local business more than six times in the previous year, roughly every other month, up slightly from 56% in 2013. The sharpest change was habitual use: the share searching multiple times each week rose from 7% to 15%. Around 39% searched at least monthly and 15% searched almost daily. The survey authors linked the rise to more comfortable PC and mobile searching and to better, more accurate local data.

Which business types people searched for

Restaurants and cafés remained the most-searched category at 58%, although that was down from 67% in 2013. Doctors and dentists reached 38% (up from 35%), general shops 36% (up from 35%) and clothes shops 34% (up from 28%). Across almost all categories, more people searched for more types of business than a year earlier. The authors read the restaurant dip as likely reflecting the respondent mix rather than a loss of interest, and noted that lifestyle businesses attract the most searches because people visit them often.

Reading reviews to judge a local business

Eighty-eight per cent of respondents had read reviews to judge the quality of a local business, up from 85% in 2013. Thirty-nine per cent read reviews regularly, up from 32%, and only 12% did not read reviews at all, down from 15%. In practical terms, almost nine in ten consumers had consulted reviews in the previous year, and four in ten did so as a routine habit. The authors argued this made review management a priority across sectors, not just hospitality.

How many reviews people read before trusting a business

Sixty-seven per cent of respondents said they read up to six reviews before feeling able to trust a business, down from 77% in 2013. Eighty-five per cent read up to ten, down from 92%. The share reading 20 or more reviews rose from 2% to 7%. The authors treated ten as a useful working benchmark: enough recent, positive reviews to satisfy most readers, with attention to the most recent ones because negative recent sentiment can stop people reading further.

Star-rating thresholds and the 2-to-3 star gap

This question was new in 2014. Ninety-two per cent of respondents would use a local business with a 4-star rating, 72% with 3 stars, 27% with 2 stars and 13% with 1 star. The largest single gap is between 2 and 3 stars: 45 percentage points separate the two. The step from 3 to 4 stars adds a further 20 points. Read as a threshold rather than a guarantee, the data suggest that moving a business from 2 to 3 stars changes how many people will even consider it, while moving from 3 to 4 stars widens the pool further.

How reviews shape opinion

Seventy-two per cent said positive reviews made them trust a local business more, essentially unchanged from 73% in 2013. Ten per cent said they took no notice of online reviews, down from 12%. The authors placed review reading late in the purchase path: by the time people read reviews they have usually identified a need and a shortlist, and are looking for positive signals to choose between options.

Reviews versus personal recommendations

Eighty-eight per cent said they trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations, up from 79% in 2013. Thirteen per cent said they did not, down from 21%. Within the trust group, 32% said they would trust a review as much as a recommendation provided there were multiple reviews to read, a 7-point rise on 2013, and a further 30% said they would do so if they believed the review was authentic. Authenticity and quantity therefore mattered alongside each other.

Where reputation matters most

Doctors and dentists topped the reputation-importance list at 47% (down from 54%), followed by restaurants and cafés at 46% (down from 51%), hotels and B&Bs at 30% (up from 28%) and garages and car dealers at 30% (down from 31%). The authors grouped the top categories as services affecting health, wellbeing, safety or comfort, with leisure services ranking lower.

Which reputation traits matter

Reliability was the single most important reputation trait for 27% of respondents (down from 28%), followed by expertise at 21% and professionalism at 18%. The authors contrasted this with the friendliness often highlighted in reviews: pleasant, but less decisive than dependability and competence. They also suggested that accreditation badges carry less weight than reviews or testimonials that demonstrate reliability, expertise and professionalism, and that these traits should be reflected consistently across marketing channels.

How people recommend local businesses

Word of mouth remained the leading recommendation channel at 61%, down from 72% in 2013. On social media, 37% had used Facebook, 12% Twitter and 10% Google+ to recommend a local business. The authors read this as a preference for informal, personal channels over formal review sites when recommending to people you know, and noted that Google+ Local had high visibility among search marketers but low adoption among general users.

What makes someone more likely to recommend

Sixty-eight per cent said reliability and professionalism would make them more likely to recommend a local business, unchanged from 2013. Forty-four per cent cited friendliness and a welcoming manner, down from 46%, and 9% said they would recommend if simply asked, down from 12%. The authors noted that asking for a review is discouraged by some review platforms, but that a direct request still moves a measurable minority of customers.

Frequently asked questions

When was the 2014 local consumer review survey carried out?

Fieldwork ran over six weeks in May and June 2014. The panel was drawn from North America, with 90% of the 2,104 respondents from the United States and 10% from Canada.

How many reviews should a local business aim for?

In the 2014 data, 85% of respondents read up to ten reviews before feeling able to trust a business, and 67% read up to six. Ten recent reviews was a practical working benchmark at the time. Treat this as a historical reference and check newer research before setting a current target.

What is the difference between a 'too low' star rating and a 'would use' star rating?

The survey asked what average star rating would be too low to consider a business. The reported figures describe the share of respondents willing to use a business at each rating: 92% at 4 stars, 72% at 3 stars, 27% at 2 stars and 13% at 1 star. The 2-to-3 star step is the largest single gap in the dataset.

Did consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations in 2014?

Eighty-eight per cent said they did, up from 79% in 2013. Of those, 32% said multiple reviews were needed and 30% said authenticity was the deciding factor.

Which recommendation channel did consumers prefer in 2014?

Word of mouth led at 61%, down from 72% in 2013. On social media, 37% had used Facebook, 12% Twitter and 10% Google+.