Skip to content

Local Consumer Review Survey 2022

This page walks through the findings of a survey of 1,124 US-based consumers, fielded in November 2021 and published in January 2022.

It covers how often people look for local businesses online, which platforms they use to judge them, what they read and write, the star ratings and recency they tolerate, how they react to owner responses and review requests, and how far fake reviews have eroded trust. All figures below are dated reference points from that fieldwork period, not a current reading of the market.

How the survey was run

The study used an independent consumer panel of 1,124 US-based consumers, surveyed in November 2021, with age breakdowns matched to the US population. Respondents who said they do not read online reviews were not asked the follow-up questions about review behaviour, so percentages describing review readers apply to that subset rather than the whole sample. Findings focus on local business reviews across sites such as Google, Facebook, Tripadvisor and Yelp. Treat every number here as a snapshot of late 2021 opinion.

Search habits and which platforms people judge businesses on

Almost everyone in the sample had used the internet to research a local business in the previous year (99%), and 78% did so more than once a week, up from 69% in 2020 — a 9% year-on-year increase in that more-than-weekly group. Daily searching fell from 34% to 21%, so the pattern is more frequent overall use spread across more people rather than a smaller group searching constantly.

When asked which sites or apps they had used to evaluate businesses in the last 12 months, Google led at 81% (up from 63%), Yelp rose to 53% (from 32%), Facebook slipped to 48% (from 54%), and Apple Maps sat at 13%. The practical reading is that Google deserves the most attention but is not the only place a local decision gets made; a growing share of buyers also check Yelp.

How often people read reviews

Reading is close to universal: 98% read local business reviews at least occasionally, and 77% said they always or regularly do so when browsing, up from 60% in 2020. The share who never read reviews fell from 13% in 2020 to 2% in 2021, a 16-point drop from 18% in 2019. For a business, the implication is that a thin or stale review profile is now seen by nearly everyone who considers you.

Which sectors buyers scrutinise most

Reviews carry the most weight where the decision is high-risk or infrequent. Service businesses and tradespersons topped the list, with 84% saying reviews were important or very important to their decision, followed by care services at 83% and healthcare at 82%. Restaurants and bars sit lower because a personal recommendation often suffices. If you run a trade or a care service, your review profile is doing more persuasive work than it would for a leisure venue.

What makes someone more likely to leave a review

Going above and beyond was the strongest trigger, with 88% likely or highly likely to review after an exceptional experience. A negative experience turned around came next at 80%, then knowing the business was fairly new at 77%, believing a low star rating was undeserved at 73%, and knowing the business was family-owned at 74% — against only 43% for a large chain. The family-owned versus chain gap is the widest structural difference in the dataset and is worth reflecting in how you present the business.

What readers actually value in a review

Asked which factors would make them feel positive about a business, 75% chose a written review describing a positive experience, 58% a high star rating, and 55% an owner response. At least 25% said they don't care about the review describing a positive experience, and at least 42% don't care about a high star rating. That ordering matters: the narrative carries more weight than the number, and an owner response is valued almost as much as a high rating. If you have been hesitating over whether to reply to reviews, the evidence here says replying is close to as persuasive as the score itself.

Star-rating thresholds

Expectations tightened at the bottom and loosened at the top. Only 4% would insist on a perfect five-star average, down from 12% in 2020, while just 3% would consider a business averaging two stars or fewer, down from 14%. Put the other way, 97% would only consider businesses with over two stars. In other words, near-perfection is no longer required, but a very low average is now close to disqualifying. A profile in the low threes is read very differently from one in the high fours.

How recent reviews need to be

The tolerance for older reviews widened sharply. In 2020, 50% said only reviews from the previous two weeks affected their decision; in 2021 that fell to 22%, with more people willing to weigh reviews up to a year old. A small group of 7% said recency made no difference at all. The practical consequence cuts both ways: an old bad patch can still be read as current, and a steady trickle of new reviews matters less than it once did for sheer freshness, but still signals an active business.

How owner responses change decisions

89% said they would be fairly or highly likely to use a business that responds to all reviews, positive and negative, while 57% said they would be not very or not at all likely to use one that never responds — and 22% said they would be 'not likely at all' to use a business that doesn't respond to any reviews. Consumers were warmer towards profiles that answer negative reviews than towards those that only reply to praise. Responding to criticism reads as accountability; ignoring it reads as indifference.

Asking for reviews, and how

Only 17% said no business had prompted them for a review in the past year. 12% said they left a review every time they were asked, 35% did so at least half the time, and 23% did so more than half the time. The methods that grew year on year were SMS (a 7% increase), receipts or invoices (a 5% increase), and in-person requests (a 1% increase). Email, receipts and in-person asks remained the most common channels. SMS growth is notable given the consent steps it requires.

Incentives businesses offer

Recalled incentives shifted: 17% remembered being offered a discount for a review (up from 12%), 15% a gift or free service (up from 8%), and 6% cash (down from 9%). Cash incentives are declining but discounts and gifts are rising. Note that platform rules differ and cash-for-reviews is illegal in some jurisdictions, so any incentive programme needs checking against each platform's guidelines before it runs.

Trust in reviews compared with other sources

49% trust consumer reviews as much as recommendations from friends and family, and 28% as much as expert-written articles. 21% chose 'none of the above' — the source reads this as not trusting consumer reviews as much as friends, family, social media personalities or topic experts. The comparison set was widened this year, which partly explains the lower figures against the 79% recorded in 2020 for the friends-and-family comparison alone.

How widespread fake reviews appear to be

62% believed they had seen a fake review for a local business in the past year, and only 9% were confident they had seen none. Asked where, 52% named Amazon, 50% Google and 37% Facebook. The prevalence is highest on the highest-volume platforms, which is consistent with the volume of content there rather than proof of any single platform's moderation quality.

Suspicion varies by platform

Suspicion and experience diverge. 93% of Facebook users were at least a little suspicious of fake reviews there, with 37% very suspicious, and 70% were fairly or very suspicious of Facebook reviews. 90% of Google users were at least a little suspicious, but only 10% very suspicious, and 45% were fairly or very suspicious of Google reviews. The Better Business Bureau was the most trusted, with just 29% of its users fairly or very suspicious. A platform can host plenty of suspected fakes and still be trusted, or host fewer and still attract broad wariness.

The knock-on effect on trust in reviews generally

67% agreed that the existence of fake reviews and fake reviewers makes them distrustful of online reviews in general. That is the survey's most consequential finding for anyone relying on reviews as a sales channel: the problem is no longer confined to individual suspect posts but colours how the whole category is read.

Turning the findings into a review-management checklist

Use this as a working checklist rather than a scorecard:

  1. Confirm your Google profile is complete and current, then check whether Yelp matters for your category and region.
  2. Aim for a genuine average in the high fours rather than chasing a perfect five; a flawless run can read as implausible.
  3. Keep a steady flow of new reviews, but do not panic about week-by-week freshness; a year-old review can still count.
  4. Reply to every review, and especially to negative ones; the response is part of the evidence a buyer weighs.
  5. Ask every satisfied customer, in person and on receipts, and consider SMS only where consent is properly captured.
  6. Avoid cash incentives and check each platform's rules before offering discounts or gifts.
  7. Report suspected fakes through platform channels rather than relying on a public rebuttal.
  8. Keep review language specific and varied; generic praise and near-identical wording are what readers flag as suspicious.

What the 2022 survey adds up to

The 2021 fieldwork shows a market where nearly everyone reads reviews, Google dominates discovery but Yelp is gaining, buyers tolerate imperfect averages but not very low ones, and owner responses are treated as a meaningful signal. Against that, fake reviews are widely suspected and have damaged trust in the category as a whole. The practical priorities are a credible average, consistent replies, a steady request habit and a clean, specific review voice.

Review profile elements and how much they mattered
ElementShare who rated it important or very important (2021)Comparison
Overall average star rating85%—
Higher average than competitors76%—
Recency of latest reviews73%—
Total number of reviews39%Source also reports 79% in 2020 falling to 69% in 2021 for this factor
Range of review sites34%72% in 2020; source also reports 79% in 2020 falling to 69% in 2021 for this factor

Figures are from November 2021 fieldwork and describe stated importance, not observed behaviour. The source contains two conflicting pairs of figures for total review count and range of review sites (39%/34% vs 69%/79%); both are shown rather than one being presented as uncontested.

Sites used to evaluate local businesses in the last 12 months
Platform20212020
Google81%63%
Yelp53%32%
Facebook48%54%
Apple Maps13%—

Shares are of the 1,124 US respondents surveyed in November 2021; the Apple Maps figure was reported for 2021 only.

Frequently asked questions

Does this survey reflect current consumer behaviour?

No. The fieldwork took place in November 2021 and the report was published in January 2022. The figures are a dated snapshot of US consumer opinion at that point and should be checked against more recent research before being used as a current benchmark.

What is the difference between 'having seen a fake review' and 'being suspicious of reviews'?

The survey measured them separately. Having seen a fake review is a claim about experience: 62% believed they had seen one in the past year. Being suspicious is a claim about attitude: 93% of Facebook users were at least a little suspicious of reviews there, even though fewer had seen a fake one. A platform can be distrusted without its users reporting many suspected fakes, and vice versa.

Should a business reply to positive reviews as well as negative ones?

The survey points that way. 89% said they would be fairly or highly likely to use a business that responds to all reviews, and consumers were warmer towards profiles that answer negative reviews than towards those that only reply to praise. A reply to a positive review also signals an active, attentive business.

Is it worth offering an incentive for a review?

The survey recorded rising recall of discounts and gifts and falling recall of cash, but platform rules differ and cash-for-reviews is illegal in some jurisdictions. Check each platform's guidelines before running any incentive, and never condition a reward on the review being positive.