Skip to content

Local Search vs Other Marketing Channels: A Dated Practitioner Survey

This page summarises a practitioner survey of local business owners and local search marketers, run in 2015 and reported by its original publisher.

It compares local search with organic search, Google AdWords, Bing Ads, social media, email, mobile marketing, display advertising, direct traffic and referrals on five measures: time and effort, return on effort or money, lead quality, share of phone calls and share of website traffic. The figures are a historical reference point. Search results, ad products and consumer behaviour have changed substantially since 2015, so treat the numbers as a snapshot of practitioner opinion at that time and check current conditions before budgeting.

What the survey measured and who answered

The survey set out to fill a gap: analytics platforms rarely capture the full picture of which channel produced a local enquiry, call tracking is fragmented, and many local customers convert offline. The organisers wanted a practitioner view of where leads actually come from.

477 respondents took part, reporting work on more than 8,200 locations in the preceding 12 months. Their roles broke down as follows:

  • 38% search agencies
  • 28% small business owners
  • 26% search consultants
  • 8% web designers (a category added that year)

The headline claim was that 64% of participants were professional search marketers. That composition matters when reading the results: this is largely a sample of people who sell or practise search marketing, not a representative sample of all local businesses.

Five questions drove the findings:

  1. How much time and effort goes to each channel in a typical week?
  2. How effective is each channel at returning value for effort or money?
  3. How effective is each channel at producing high-quality leads?
  4. What share of phone calls does each channel generate?
  5. What share of website traffic does each channel generate?

A final question asked respondents to pick a single channel if they could keep only one.

Where practitioners spent their time

Local SEO and organic SEO took the largest share of weekly time and effort. Email marketing, mobile marketing and display advertising took the least. The largest year-on-year drop in time spent was on mobile marketing.

The survey's own commentary offered two explanations for the mobile drop. One was that a widely publicised mobile-friendly update had passed without the disruption many expected, so attention moved on. The other was a classification issue: mobile optimisation work may have been recorded under organic SEO rather than mobile marketing, which would move the hours without changing the underlying activity.

That second explanation is the more useful lesson for anyone reading channel surveys. Self-reported time allocation depends on how respondents categorise their work, so a fall in one channel's hours can be a labelling effect rather than a real shift in effort.

Return on effort and lead quality

Local search and organic search were rated the strongest channels for return on effort or money spent. Social media, display advertising and Bing Ads were rated lowest on the same measure.

On lead quality the ranking was similar: organic search and local search produced the highest-quality leads, while mobile marketing, social media and display advertising produced the lowest. Google AdWords was also rated a strong source of high-quality leads, and was seen as marginally more effective than in the previous year even though less time was spent on it.

The survey's interpretation was that local, organic and paid search all reach people while they are actively looking for a service. Social channels were read differently: not as a lead-generation engine, but as a longer-term tool for engaging existing and new customers and staying in mind until a need arises.

That distinction is worth keeping. A low lead-quality rating for social does not mean social has no role; it means social is being judged on a measure it was not designed to win.

Share of phone calls and website traffic

Respondents attributed the largest share of phone calls to local search, followed by organic search, then Google AdWords, with Bing Ads well behind. The same pattern held for website traffic: local search led, organic search followed, and Twitter and Facebook combined accounted for a small fraction.

The survey noted that local results are not shown for every query and are often limited to a small set of listings, so organic results offer more total opportunities. Even so, a business that ranks well in the local results can capture a large share of attention because there is less competition for the searcher's eye at that point.

One caveat from the original analysis is worth preserving: the authors expected local search's share of calls to fall if search engines continued to obscure phone numbers and push searchers deeper into result pages. That is a reminder that channel share depends on the interface as much as on marketer effort.

How to use these findings without over-reading them

The survey is a snapshot of practitioner opinion from 2015, not a controlled measurement of channel performance. Several limits follow from that:

  • The sample was skewed towards search professionals, so the results reflect the views of people invested in search.
  • Time allocation and ROI were self-reported, and categorisation varies between respondents.
  • Call and traffic shares were estimates, not tracked counts.
  • Search products, ad formats and consumer behaviour have changed since the survey was fielded.

A practical way to apply the findings is as a set of questions rather than a set of targets:

  1. Which channels reach people at the moment they are looking for what you sell? Those are the high-intent channels the survey ranks highly.
  2. Which channels are you using for retention or brand rather than acquisition? Judge those on retention measures, not lead quality.
  3. Are you counting mobile optimisation work under the right channel, or is it hidden inside organic?
  4. Do your own call and traffic figures match the pattern, or does your category behave differently?
  5. If you had to keep one channel, would it be the one with the best ROI, or the one you can most reliably influence?

Worked example using the survey's call-share figures: if a business receives 400 calls in a period and the survey's shares held, local search would account for about 104 calls (26%), organic search about 60 (15%), Google AdWords about 48 (12%) and Bing Ads about 16 (4%). The point of the calculation is not to predict your numbers but to show how a share-of-calls estimate converts into a volume you can compare with your own call tracking.

Frequently asked questions

Is local search really the best channel for a local business?

In this 2015 survey, local search was rated highest for return on effort, tied with organic search for lead quality, and led both the share-of-calls and share-of-traffic questions. It was also the most common single-channel choice. Those are practitioner opinions from that year, not a guarantee for any particular business. The right channel mix depends on your category, your competition and how your customers search.

Why did social media score so badly?

Respondents rated social media low for lead quality and ROI, and rarely chose it as their only channel. The survey's own reading was that social is better suited to engaging existing customers and staying in mind over time than to generating immediate enquiries. Judged as a retention and brand tool rather than a lead source, the low lead-quality score is less damning.

How many people took part in the survey?

477 respondents took part, reporting work on more than 8,200 locations in the previous 12 months. Most were search agencies, small business owners or search consultants, with a smaller group of web designers.

Can I use these percentages as benchmarks for my own business?

Use them as a historical reference point, not a target. The figures are self-reported estimates from 2015, and search products and consumer behaviour have changed since then. Compare your own call and traffic data with the pattern to see whether your category behaves similarly, and check current conditions before setting budgets.