Local Consumer Review Survey 2013: How Reviews Shaped Local Choices
This page summarises a 2013 North American survey of 2,100 consumers about searching for local services, reading reviews, forming trust and recommending businesses.
It focuses on local services rather than wider product purchases, and the figures below are dated 2013 evidence rather than current behaviour.
About the 2013 survey
The survey was narrowed to 14 questions and focused on North America, with 90% of respondents from the US and 10% from Canada. Fieldwork ran for six weeks in January and February 2013 and produced 2,100 responses. Compared with earlier waves, it found stronger use of reviews during pre-purchase research and greater trust in them, while concern about perceived authenticity also grew. Use the findings as a historical baseline: they show how review behaviour was changing in 2013, not how consumers behave today.
Finding local businesses online
Almost everyone had used the internet to find a local business in the previous year: only 5% had not, down from 15% in 2012. Monthly searching rose to 37% from 34%. The clearest shift was among occasional users moving from never or one-off searching to two to five searches a year, suggesting that early positive experiences could turn occasional searchers into repeat users. Restaurants were the most searched category at 67%, followed by doctors or dentists and general shops at 35% each. Hotels, B&Bs and guest houses were 30%, and clothes shops 28%. Doctors and dentists stood out because they are chosen less frequently than restaurants or shops, yet the consequences of choosing poorly are high.
Reading reviews before choosing
85% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses, up from 76% in 2012, and only 15% said they did not. Review reading tracked searching closely: restaurants led at 61%, doctors and dentists at 32%, hotels and similar accommodation at 27%, general shops at 18% and hair or beauty salons at 17%. The buying-cycle point matters for local businesses: by the time someone is reading reviews, they have already identified a need and are choosing which provider to use. That shortens the distance between a convincing reputation and a purchase, and makes an unmanaged profile a direct risk to enquiries.
Trust, opinion and choice
Consumers were deciding faster. 67% read six or fewer reviews before trusting a business, up from 52%, while 22% read more than ten, down from 35%. The practical implication is that the most recent reviews carry disproportionate weight, so businesses need a steady flow of fresh positive reviews rather than relying on an old total. Volume still matters as context: a four-star average from 190 reviews is stronger evidence than the same average from five. Positive reviews increased trust for 73% of consumers, up from 58%, and only 12% said they ignored reviews, down from 17%. 65% were more likely to use a business with positive reviews, up from 52%.
Reviews compared with personal recommendations
79% trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations, up from 72%, leaving 21% who did not. That parity came with a warning: as people became more familiar with reviews, they paid more attention to whether a review seemed genuine. A business therefore needs both volume and credibility. Responding promptly and constructively to complaints and praise also matters, because consumers judge how a business behaves when something goes wrong, not only whether mistakes occur.
Where reputation matters and what it means
Reputation mattered most for restaurants at 51%, tradesmen at 33%, garages and car dealers at 31%, hotels and similar accommodation at 28%, and builders or roofers at 27%. It tended to matter where buyers knew little about the service, the cost was significant, a poor choice had serious consequences, or the purchase could not easily be undone. Among reputation traits, reliability led at 71%, followed by good value at 45%. Friendliness, courtesy and localness were each below 10%. For messaging and review requests, the evidence points to emphasising reliability, professionalism, expertise and value rather than relying mainly on warmth or local identity.
How people recommended local businesses
Word of mouth remained the leading recommendation method at 72%, although it fell from 78%. Facebook rose to 37% from 32%, while online directories fell to 8% from 11%. Reliability and professionalism were the strongest recommendation factors at 78%; friendliness and being welcoming mattered to 46%; only 12% would recommend simply because they were asked. A good-value offer or discount made 54% definitely more likely to recommend, and 84% would do so or consider it, but the offer needed good service behind it. Personal benefit was more tentative: 30% would recommend for a direct benefit and 45% would consider it, giving 75% who would consider or act. The lesson is to earn advocacy through dependable service first, then use offers or incentives as a prompt rather than a substitute.
A practical checklist for local businesses
Checklist for applying the 2013 findings: keep recent reviews positive and current; build enough review volume for the average rating to be credible; answer complaints visibly and quickly; foreground reliability, professionalism and value in listings, website copy and review requests; and treat discounts or personal incentives as support for genuine advocacy, not as a replacement for good service. Re-check current consumer behaviour before using these percentages for present-day planning.
| Measure | 2013 | 2012 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Read online reviews for local businesses | 85% | 76% | +9 points |
| Read 6 or fewer reviews before trusting a business* | 67% | 52% | +15 points |
| Positive reviews increase trust | 73% | 58% | +15 points |
| More likely to use a business with positive reviews | 65% | 52% | +13 points |
| Trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations | 79% | 72% | +7 points |
| Had not used internet to find a local business in last 12 months | 5% | 15% | -10 points |
Dated 2013 survey evidence; percentages as reported in the source.
| Business type | Searched online | Read reviews for |
|---|---|---|
| Restaurants | 67% | 61% |
| Doctors / dentists | 35% | 32% |
| General shop | 35% | 18% |
| Hotel / B&B / guest house | 30% | 27% |
| Clothes shop | 28% | Not in top five |
| Hair / beauty salon | Not in top five | 17% |
Dated 2013 survey evidence; review-reading figures are the top five reported.
Frequently asked questions
What share of consumers read reviews for local businesses?
In the 2013 survey, 85% said they read online reviews for local businesses, up from 76% in 2012. Only 15% said they did not read them.
How many reviews did consumers read before trusting a business?
67% read six or fewer reviews before trusting a business, excluding those who answered zero. That was up from 52% in 2012, while reading more than ten fell to 22% from 35%.
Did consumers trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations?
79% trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations, up from 72%. At the same time, concern about whether reviews were genuine was becoming more important.
Which reputation traits mattered most when choosing a local business?
Reliability was the leading reputation trait at 71%, followed by good value at 45%. Friendliness, courtesy and localness were each selected by fewer than 10%.
How did consumers recommend local businesses to people they knew?
Word of mouth was used by 72% and Facebook by 37% in the previous 12 months. Online directories were used by 8%, down from 11%.