Local Consumer Review Survey 2010, Part 2
This is a dated reference summary of the second part of a 2010 survey on how consumers in the US and UK used online reviews when researching local businesses.
The fieldwork took the form of an online poll run in September 2010, drawing responses from 2,012 local consumers on both sides of the Atlantic. It covered five question areas: which business types people searched for, which they read reviews for, where reputation mattered most, how many reviews were needed to trust a business, and which reputation traits were most important. The figures below are historical captured evidence from that period and should be checked against current conditions before being used for planning.
Background and scope
The survey examined the role that online consumer reviews play in the research and purchase of local business services. Part 2 focused on five questions about consumer behaviour across specific types of local business. The objective was to understand which local businesses consumers searched for online, how review consumption differed by business type, how important online reputation was for each type, what minimum or optimum number of reviews a business needed, and which reputation traits mattered most. The findings were originally published alongside Part 1 and Part 3 of the same survey.
Key takeaways from the 2010 survey
The headline findings were: 51% of consumers cited reliability as the most important trait when selecting a local business; reputation mattered most for dentists and doctors, tradesmen and hotels; reputation was also very important for restaurants, builders and garages; local consumers read the most online reviews for restaurants, hotels and pubs or bars; restaurants and cafes were the most searched-for type of local business; male consumers searched for more practical services such as tradesmen, garages and builders; and younger consumers were more concerned with friendliness while older consumers looked for expertise and accreditations.
Recap of Part 1 findings
Part 1 reported that 70% of local consumers had used the internet to find a local business in the last 12 months; younger consumers used the internet more frequently for this than older consumers; 67% had consulted online customer reviews of local businesses; younger consumers were more influenced by positive online reviews than older consumers; female consumers were more likely to select a local business with positive customer reviews; and 69% of local consumers trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations.
Question 1: Which business types did consumers search for?
Consumers were asked to select, from a list, the business types they had searched for via the internet in the last 12 months. Restaurants, clothes shops and general shops such as supermarkets were the most searched for, followed by hotels and B&Bs. Female consumers drove searches for clothes shops and general shops; twice as many women as men had looked online for a clothes shop. More men searched for practical services such as tradesmen, garages and builders. By age, younger consumers aged 16-34 appeared more interested in fun, lifestyle businesses such as bars, hairdressers, clothes shops and gyms, while older people aged 55+ were more practical, seeking out accountants, tradesmen, builders and car hire or taxi firms.
Question 2: Which business types did consumers read reviews for?
Consumers were asked which local business types they had read online customer reviews for in the last 12 months. The main types were restaurants and cafes, hotels and B&Bs, and pubs and bars. People also read reviews for all types of businesses, including supermarkets, accountants, estate agents and yoga instructors. Driving instructors had the least reviews read, which is likely to be demand-led because not everyone is in the market for a driving instructor. The study also highlighted cultural differences between the US and UK: in the US, two to three times as many web users consulted reviews for doctors and dentists and alternative therapies than in the UK, while in the UK twice as many users were interested in reviews for pubs and bars. US diners appeared more discerning, with double the number of people reading restaurant reviews than UK web users. By age, younger consumers aged 16-34 were more interested in fun, lifestyle businesses such as bars, hairdressers and gyms, while 33% of those aged 55+ had read reviews for restaurants and hotels.
Question 3: Where did reputation matter most?
Consumers were asked for which local business types reputation mattered most when choosing a business. Reputation mattered most for dentists and doctors, mainly in the US, as well as hotels and restaurants. Reputation for tradesmen, builders and garages was also very important. In general, female consumers were more concerned with reputation than men: significantly more women consulted online reviews for doctors and dentists, hairdressers and hotels, while men were more concerned with the reputation of garages, specialist shops such as bike shops, and pubs. By age, older web users were more concerned with reputation than younger users, particularly for services they searched for online such as accountants, tradesmen, doctors and dentists, and builders. Younger people were more concerned with pubs, gyms and cleaners.
Question 4: How many reviews were needed to trust a business?
Consumers were asked how many online reviews and ratings they needed to read before feeling they could trust a business. The minimum number for a local business was between 6 and 10 reviews. However, the more reviews a business had, the more trust a web user could place in its reputation: businesses with 50 or more reviews earned the trust of 29% more consumers than a business with 6-10 reviews, but a business with 6-10 reviews had the trust of 71% of consumers. 9% of consumers either did not need reviews to trust a business or dismissed online customer reviews entirely. Younger consumers were more trusting of businesses without reviews and potentially more willing to form their own opinions rather than following others. Older consumers appeared happy to trust a business after reading just two or three reviews, although 12% of consumers aged 55+ needed to read more than 50 reviews before they could really trust a local business.
Question 5: Which reputation traits mattered most?
Consumers were asked which reputation trait was most important when selecting a local business. 51% believed reliability was the most important trait. Good value (40%), expertise (33%) and professionalism (32%) were the other most important traits. Courtesy, accreditations and localness (independent, non-chain businesses) were the least important traits. By age, twice as many younger consumers (19%) believed friendliness was a key trait, and also that localness was important in the businesses they chose. Older consumers appeared more pragmatic, citing reliability and expertise as the most important traits. 22% of older consumers aged 55+ looked for accreditations as a pointer to positive reputation, twice as many as younger consumers aged 16-34.
How to use these findings as a reader checklist
Use this checklist to turn the dated survey into a practical review of your own local business presence. First, identify which business type you operate in and compare it with the most-searched and most-reviewed categories in the survey. Second, check whether your review volume sits below the 6-10 minimum, within it, or above the 50-review threshold that earned more trust in 2010. Third, review the reputation traits your customers mention most often and compare them with reliability, good value, expertise and professionalism. Fourth, consider whether your audience skews younger or older and whether friendliness, localness, expertise or accreditations should be more prominent in your messaging. Finally, treat every figure here as a historical reference point and check current conditions before making changes.
Worked example: review volume and trust
Suppose a local business has 8 reviews. In the 2010 survey, a business with 6-10 reviews had the trust of 71% of consumers. If the same business grew to 50 or more reviews, it would earn the trust of 29% more consumers than a business with 6-10 reviews. That does not mean every additional review adds the same amount of trust, but it shows why moving beyond the minimum threshold was associated with a meaningful trust gain in the 2010 data. The survey also found that 9% of consumers either did not need reviews to trust a business or dismissed online reviews entirely, so review volume is not the only factor.
Search demand versus review-reading demand
The survey distinguishes between what consumers searched for and what they read reviews for. Restaurants, clothes shops and general shops were the most searched-for business types, while restaurants and cafes, hotels and B&Bs, and pubs and bars were the main types people read reviews for. A business type can be frequently searched for without being frequently reviewed, and the reverse can also happen. Driving instructors, for example, had the least reviews read, which the survey linked to demand rather than a lack of interest in reviews. This distinction matters when deciding whether to prioritise review generation or search visibility for a particular business type.
Survey question map
The five question areas can be mapped as follows. Question 1 asked which business types consumers had searched for via the internet in the last 12 months, with results broken down by gender and age. Question 2 asked which local business types consumers had read online customer reviews for in the last 12 months, again broken down by gender and age. Question 3 asked for which local business types reputation mattered most when choosing a business, broken down by gender and age. Question 4 asked how many online reviews and ratings consumers needed to read before feeling they could trust a business, broken down by gender and age. Question 5 asked which reputation trait was most important when selecting a local business, broken down by gender and age.
Frequently asked questions
Are these 2010 survey figures still current?
No. The figures come from fieldwork carried out in September 2010, when an online poll gathered responses from 2,012 local consumers in the US and UK. They are a dated historical reference and should be checked against current conditions before being used for planning.
What was the minimum number of reviews consumers needed to trust a business?
In the 2010 survey, the minimum number of online reviews for a local business was between 6 and 10 reviews. A business with 6-10 reviews had the trust of 71% of consumers, while businesses with 50 or more reviews earned the trust of 29% more consumers than a business with 6-10 reviews.
Which reputation traits mattered most to consumers?
51% of local consumers believed reliability was the most important reputation trait. Good value (40%), expertise (33%) and professionalism (32%) were the other most important traits. Courtesy, accreditations and localness were the least important traits overall, although 22% of older consumers aged 55+ looked for accreditations.
Which local business types did consumers read reviews for most?
The main business types people read reviews for were restaurants and cafes, hotels and B&Bs, and pubs and bars. People also read reviews for all types of businesses, including supermarkets, accountants, estate agents and yoga instructors.
How did review behaviour differ by gender?
Female consumers drove searches for clothes shops and general shops, and were generally more concerned with reputation than men, particularly for doctors and dentists, hairdressers and hotels. Men searched more for practical services such as tradesmen, garages and builders, and were more concerned with the reputation of garages, specialist shops and pubs.
How did review behaviour differ by age?
Younger consumers aged 16-34 were more interested in fun, lifestyle businesses such as bars, hairdressers, clothes shops and gyms, and were more trusting of businesses without reviews. Older consumers aged 55+ were more practical, seeking out accountants, tradesmen, builders and car hire or taxi firms, and were more concerned with reputation, reliability and expertise. 12% of consumers aged 55+ needed to read more than 50 reviews before trusting a local business.