Do listing errors damage trust? What 1,025 consumers said
A wrong phone number, address or opening time is not a minor tidy-up task.
In a March 2018 survey of 1,025 US consumers, incorrect local listings were linked to frustration, wasted journeys and lost custom. This page summarises the findings, explains why consistency matters for both search visibility and customer experience, and gives a practical audit checklist.
What a local citation is
A local citation is an online mention of a business's name, address and phone number — often shortened to NAP. Those details appear in directories, business listings and other websites. When they match, they support discoverability and help people contact or visit the business. When they differ, the same mentions can send callers to a wrong number, drivers to a wrong address, or customers away altogether.
Why consistency matters
Consistency matters in two ways. First, search engines consider citations when assessing local authority, so errors and inconsistencies can weaken local SEO. Second, people judge reliability from what they find: a business whose details conflict across sites looks harder to reach and less dependable. Checking only the business website is not enough, because a customer may first encounter the business through a directory.
Errors change how people judge a business
Trust is fragile. 80% of respondents lost trust when they saw incorrect or inconsistent contact details or business names, and 70% lost trust over incorrect or inconsistent contact details alone. Opening hours also mattered: 51% lost trust over incorrect hours. Poor or outdated photos affected 50%. By contrast, only 10% said incorrect or outdated information would not reduce their trust.
Wrong details create real-world friction
The consequences were practical, not just attitudinal. In the previous year, 36% had called a wrong number, 24% had arrived too early or late because of hours, and 22% had visited the wrong location. Younger respondents were especially affected: 33% of 18–34-year-olds had gone to the wrong location. When people could not find a business because the address was wrong, 43% would call, 40% would give up and 30% would go to a competitor.
People check details — and call to recover
Before a first visit, 90% looked for business details. Most looked them up before travelling (54%), while 24% called first. Phone contact therefore remains a recovery route when directions fail. Keep lines staffed where possible; if calls cannot be answered, a voicemail message should give the correct address, directions and an alternative way to make contact.
A practical citation audit checklist
Use this sequence to audit the details customers are most likely to act on: 1) Confirm one canonical name, address and phone number. 2) Check that name, address, phone number, opening hours and photos match across your website and major directories. 3) Test the phone number and address from a customer's point of view. 4) Review holiday and special opening hours separately. 5) Replace stale or poor-quality photos with recent, clear images. 6) Re-check after any move, rebrand, number change or hours change, because those events create new inconsistencies.
Methodology and limits
The survey used a representative sample of 1,025 US-based consumers and was conducted in March 2018 with an independent consumer panel. Some results excluded a small number of respondents who were unsure or undecided. Age groups were 18–34, 35–54 and 55+, and some findings were split by gender. Treat the percentages as dated evidence from that study, not as a current benchmark.
| Finding | Share of respondents | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Lost trust over incorrect or inconsistent contact details or business names | 80% | Q1 |
| Lost trust over incorrect or inconsistent contact details | 70% | Q1 |
| Lost trust over incorrect opening hours | 51% | Q1 |
| Lost trust over poor-quality or out-of-date photos | 50% | Q1 |
| Would not lose trust over incorrect or outdated information | 10% | Q1 |
| Had a negative experience from incorrect local information in the last 12 months | 71% | Q2 |
| Called a wrong number in the last year | 36% | Q2 |
| Arrived too early or late because hours were incorrect | 24% | Q2 |
| Visited the wrong location because the address was incorrect | 22% | Q2 |
| Blamed the local business for incorrect listings | 31% | Q3 |
| Blamed the directory for incorrect listings | 18% | Q3 |
| Would stop using a business after finding incorrect directory information | 68% | Q6 |
| Frustrated by incorrect information in online directories | 93% | Q7 |
March 2018 survey of 1,025 US consumers; multiple responses were allowed for Q1 and Q2, so figures can overlap.
Frequently asked questions
What listing errors most damage consumer trust?
In this 2018 survey of 1,025 US consumers, 80% said incorrect or inconsistent contact details or business names would reduce their trust, and 70% pointed specifically to wrong contact details. Only 10% said they would not lose trust because of incorrect or outdated information.
How common were problems caused by incorrect local information?
71% reported a negative experience in the previous 12 months. That included 36% calling a wrong number, 30% seeing incorrect or incomplete listing information, 24% arriving at the wrong time because of opening hours, and 22% going to the wrong location.
Do consumers blame the business or the directory for wrong listings?
Consumers blamed the business more often than the directory: 31% blamed the local business and 18% blamed the directory. In practical terms, the business is held responsible even when a third-party site displays the error.
What happens when a customer cannot find a business because its online address is wrong?
40% would give up, 30% would go to a competitor, and 43% would call the business. Those responses were multiple-choice, so they can overlap and should not be added together.
Would incorrect information stop people using a business?
68% said incorrect directory information would stop them using a business, and 93% said it frustrates them. Men were more likely than women to say they would stop using the business: 78% compared with 62%.