Skip to content

Local Business Discovery and Trust: What Consumers Check Before They Choose

Consumers rarely see the word citation, but they feel the consequences when a listing is wrong.

This guide turns the 2023 Local Business Discovery and Trust survey of 1,138 US consumers into a practical audit of the information, reviews, social profiles and photos that shape whether someone chooses a local business.

Where consumers look, and what they trust

The survey asked consumers which platforms they trust when researching local businesses. Google led at 66%, Google Maps followed at 45%, and a business's own website came third at 36%. Facebook and Yelp shared fourth place. The pattern matters for listing work: consumers often start on a platform that aggregates business information, then move to the business's own site when they want detail.

Google's lead is consistent with its reach: as of July 2023, Google's worldwide market share as a search engine was 83.49%. That figure is a dated external reference point, not a measure of local trust.

Device preference adds a useful nuance. 49% of consumers said they prefer to search for business information using Apple devices (37% iPhone and 12% MacOS laptops or desktops). Of these users, 59% still named Google Maps as their preferred maps app. A business therefore cannot assume that one platform covers every searcher, even when the device ecosystem is different.

Use this as a priority order for accuracy checks, not as a reason to ignore smaller directories. The platforms consumers trust most are the ones where a wrong phone number or opening time does the most damage.

The cost of incorrect business information

In 2023, 62% of consumers said they would avoid using a business if they found incorrect information online, compared with 63% in 2021. The figure is almost unchanged, which suggests that listing accuracy remains a durable trust signal rather than a passing concern.

The first reaction to a wrong address is also revealing. 36% said they would call the business to confirm the correct address, down from 41% in 2021. 28% would look for an alternative business, down from 33%. 7% would abandon the search entirely, up from 3%. Taken together, 65% said they would take some action, either by contacting the business or researching elsewhere to confirm the details.

That is a useful distinction for anyone managing listings. Most consumers are willing to give a business a second chance, but a meaningful minority will simply leave. The practical lesson is to treat every field as a potential exit point, especially address, phone and opening hours.

Reviews, ratings and the trust threshold

When asked what would make them lose trust, 63% of consumers named mostly negative written reviews in the key findings. The report's body text puts the same issue at 66%, so the two figures should be read as a range rather than a single settled number. Incorrect addresses caused 46% to lose trust, down from 60% in 2021, and incorrect phone numbers caused 45% to lose trust, down from 66%. A low average rating was enough for 44% to lose trust.

The survey also points to a useful benchmark: 87% of consumers said they would not consider a business with an average rating below 3 stars. That does not mean every business needs a perfect score, but it does show that a rating floor can affect consideration before a consumer reads a single review.

External research adds a caution about how reviews are consumed. Near Media's David Mihm, Greg Sterling and Mike Blumenthal presented findings at a local SEO conference suggesting only about 33% of users were actually reading reviews. If that holds, consumers may be skim-reading for red flags and themes rather than studying every comment, which makes the overall rating and recurring complaints especially important.

How often consumers encounter problems

Only 13% of consumers said they had never encountered incorrect business information online. 35% encountered it at least monthly, and 56% at least once every few months. 23% came across fake business listings at least once a month. 28% contacted a business on social media and received no response at least once a month. 8% called the wrong number at least once a week.

Opening hours are a frequent source of friction: 26% of consumers visited a business too early or too late because of incorrect opening hours at least monthly. Search frequency reinforces the point. 40% searched for opening hours several times a month, 36% clicked through to a website from a URL on a business information site several times a month, and 39% searched for attributes such as child-friendly, dog-friendly or wheelchair accessibility every month.

These figures make a useful case for scheduled checks rather than one-off clean-ups. The fields consumers use most often are also the fields most likely to drift out of date.

Fake listings are a separate problem from wrong details

Incorrect information and fake listings are not the same failure. Incorrect information usually belongs to a real business and can be corrected. A fake listing represents a business that does not exist, or a deceptive profile designed to capture searches. The survey treats them separately, and so should an audit.

Consumers can help with the first category. Almost half said they had suggested edits to business profiles where information was incorrect. For fake listings, the usual route is to report the profile through the platform's own edit or complaint process. Google, Bing, Tripadvisor and the Better Business Bureau all provide a way to flag a listing.

The practical distinction is this: a wrong address is a data-quality task, while a fake listing is an integrity and reporting task. Both affect trust, but they need different owners and different follow-up.

Social media and photos in the discovery journey

Social platforms are part of the discovery mix. 30% of consumers used Facebook to find local business information at least weekly, followed by YouTube at 27% more than once a week. TikTok usage is moving quickly: the Local Consumer Review Survey found 20% of consumers using it for local business discovery as of January 2023, while this survey shows 31% using it at least monthly.

Trust is more mixed. Facebook and TikTok were the least trusted platforms, with 43% saying they did not trust the information or found it somewhat untrustworthy. YouTube was seen as somewhat or strongly trustworthy by 42%. Threads drew the most ambivalence, with 41% having no strong opinion.

Photos carry a different kind of trust. Customer photos mattered most in hotels at 32%, food and drink at 29%, and beauty and wellbeing at 26%. Business-supplied photos were more important in entertainment at 24%, retail at 21%, healthcare at 16%, and financial and legal at 15%. Staff photos mattered to 17% of consumers in healthcare and 15% in financial and legal.

The pattern is consistent with the nature of the purchase. Where the experience is the product, customers want to see what other customers saw. Where the location or facility is the product, official photos help confirm what is on offer. Where personal trust is central, staff photos put a face to the service.

A practical listing-audit checklist

Use the survey findings to decide what to check first, then repeat the check on a schedule.

  1. Confirm name, address and phone number on the platforms consumers trust most: Google, Google Maps and the business's own website.
  2. Check opening hours, including holiday and temporary changes, because 40% of consumers search for them several times a month.
  3. Review the rating floor. If the average is below 3 stars, treat it as a consideration risk rather than a cosmetic issue.
  4. Read recent written reviews for recurring themes, not just the star score.
  5. Add attributes such as child-friendly, dog-friendly and wheelchair accessibility, since 39% of consumers search for these monthly.
  6. Check social profiles for response times and consistent contact details.
  7. Add customer photos where the experience is the product, and official or staff photos where location or personal trust matters.
  8. Report suspected fake listings through the platform's own process rather than editing them as if they were ordinary inaccuracies.

How the research was conducted

The Local Business Discovery and Trust Survey used a representative sample of 1,138 US-based consumers in September 2023. The survey was distributed through an independent consumer panel via SurveyMonkey, with age group and gender breakdowns balanced. The panel only considered participants who identified as male or female, and no consumers under 18 took part.

The findings are a dated reference point. Consumer behaviour and platform features change, so check current conditions before treating any single percentage as a present-day benchmark. Where the survey compares 2023 with 2021, the comparison is between those two survey waves.

Frequently asked questions

How many consumers would avoid a business after finding incorrect information online?

In the 2023 survey, 62% said they would avoid using a business if they found incorrect information online, compared with 63% in 2021.

What is the difference between incorrect business information and a fake business listing?

Incorrect information usually belongs to a real business and can be corrected through a profile edit. A fake listing represents a business that does not exist or a deceptive profile, and is usually reported through the platform's complaint or edit process.

Which social platform do consumers trust most for business information?

In the 2023 survey, YouTube had the strongest trust result, with 42% of consumers saying they found the information somewhat or strongly trustworthy. Facebook and TikTok were the least trusted, at 43% saying they did not trust the information or found it somewhat untrustworthy.

Do customer photos matter more than business photos?

It depends on the industry. Customer photos mattered most for hotels at 32%, food and drink at 29%, and beauty and wellbeing at 26%. Business-supplied photos were more important in entertainment at 24%, retail at 21%, healthcare at 16%, and financial and legal at 15%.

What average rating do consumers consider too low?

The 2023 survey found that 87% of consumers would not consider a business with an average rating below 3 stars. A low average rating was enough for 44% to lose trust.