Skip to content

Business Listings Trust: How Consumers Use Directories and What Errors Cost You

Consumers rely on business information sites long before they call or visit.

This guide summarises a 2021 US consumer survey on business listings trust, explains which errors matter most, and gives local businesses a practical accuracy checklist.

What the research measured

The Business Listings Trust Report 2021 surveyed 1,141 US-based consumers in August 2021 using SurveyMonkey's consumer panel, with a sample representative of US age and gender breakdowns. It explored how people use business information sites when searching for a local business.

'Business information sites' covers search engines such as Google and Bing, maps providers such as Waze and Google Maps, social networks such as Facebook and Instagram, voice assistants such as Siri and Amazon Alexa, and online directories such as Yelp, Tripadvisor and the Better Business Bureau.

The figures below are a dated reference from that survey. Consumer behaviour and platform features change, so treat them as a historical benchmark rather than a current measurement.

Attribution: the 2021 Business Listings Trust Report data is reproduced under the original publisher's reuse terms. {{OWNER_RESEARCH_ATTRIBUTION_TEXT}}

Why consumers open a business listing

Almost every respondent had used a business information site in the previous year: 94% had used one to find information about a local business. People were not only researching unfamiliar companies. In the survey, 66% used listings to find new businesses, 66% to learn about businesses they knew of but had not used, and 48% to check businesses they had used before.

That last group matters for retention. A returning customer may be confirming an address, a phone number, stock availability, safety measures or a current deal. If the listing is stale, the business creates friction for someone who already intended to buy.

Which listing sites consumers used

Respondents chose from more than 20 business information sites and were asked which they recalled using in the previous 12 months. Google was dominant: 89% used one of Google's search functions, including Google Maps and the Local Finder. Facebook followed at 48%, with Yelp and Instagram each at 32%.

The survey also showed indirect reach. Siri (18%), Google Home (15%) and Waze (11%) draw on other data sources, so the effective reach of Google's search engine was estimated at 91%. Bing was recalled by 15%, but because it also powers Cortana and Amazon Alexa, the report estimated that 28% of consumers used Bing for local business information in the past year, whether they knew it or not.

Low usage does not automatically mean a listing can be ignored. If a site appears for your key local searches or competitors are already listed there, securing an accurate entry is worthwhile. Once live, most of these listings need only periodic accuracy checks.

Where consumers expect accurate information

Consumers were most likely to trust a business's own website, followed by its social media profiles and online directories. Voice assistants were trusted less for accurate local business information.

That hierarchy is useful when prioritising fixes. Start with the sources customers already treat as authoritative, then extend to directories and voice-assistant data that may inherit errors from elsewhere.

What a wrong address actually costs

If contact details online were wrong, 42% of consumers said they would call the business, and 20% would check the address elsewhere online. But 39% would either switch to an alternative business or abandon the search.

A worked example makes the risk concrete. Imagine 100 high-intent customers who find an outdated address. Based on the survey split, about 42 might still call, about 20 might verify elsewhere, and roughly 39 might go to a competitor or give up. The exact outcome will vary by business type: someone seeking a nearby coffee shop may switch easily, while a specialist service may justify a longer journey. The point is that a data error can remove a customer before any conversation happens.

Opening hours and missed connections

Opening hours are one of the most-used listing features: 93% of consumers used a business information site to check hours in the previous 12 months. Yet 76% had arrived too early or too late because the hours online were wrong.

Hours can change by location, season or holiday. A listing that is accurate most of the year can still fail at the moment a customer relies on it. The same principle applies to contact routes: a broken website link, an unmonitored inbox or a phone number that rings out turns a ready buyer into a missed connection.

It helps to separate two failure types. A data failure is a wrong field: name, address, phone, website, hours or photos. A response failure is a correct field that nobody answers. Both lose customers, but they need different fixes.

The pandemic effect on listings

The survey period covered an unusual year. 74% of consumers checked a business's listings for Covid-19 measures, and 81% visited a business that said online it was open but was actually closed because of the pandemic.

That finding is a reminder that listings are operational tools, not just marketing pages. Temporary closures, changed hours and safety measures need to be updated as conditions change, then reverted when normal service resumes.

A practical listing accuracy checklist

Use this checklist across the sites your customers actually use, starting with the most visible ones. If you use a citation-tracking or citation-building service, {{OWNER_CITATION_SERVICE_NAME}} can help; otherwise track the fields manually. {{OWNER_CITATION_TRACKER_URL}} {{OWNER_CITATION_BUILDER_URL}}

  1. Name, address and phone number: confirm the exact business name, street address and phone number on every core listing. Check for old addresses, mistyped postcodes and inconsistent formats.
  2. Website link: click through from each listing to confirm the link resolves to the right page.
  3. Opening hours: review regular hours, holiday hours and any location-specific variations.
  4. Contact channels: test the phone line, contact form and social inboxes to confirm enquiries reach someone.
  5. Photos and services: remove outdated images and correct any product or service claims that are no longer true.
  6. Secondary and niche sites: check listings that appear for your key local searches or where competitors are present, even if usage is lower.
  7. Change triggers: update listings immediately after a move, rebrand, phone change or temporary closure.
  8. Review cadence: schedule regular checks, because directories and members of the public can alter information without telling you.

Share of consumers who used each business information site in the previous 12 months
SiteShare of consumers
Google (including Maps and Local Finder)89%
Facebook48%
Yelp32%
Instagram32%
Siri18%
Yahoo!18%
Twitter17%
Tripadvisor17%
Apple Maps17%
Amazon Alexa16%
Bing15%
Google Assistant15%
Mapquest12%
Better Business Bureau11%
Waze11%
Yellow Pages7%
Angi5%
Cortana4%
Foursquare3%
TomTom2%

Dated survey reference: 1,141 US consumers, August 2021. Figures are recalled usage, not current market share.

Frequently asked questions

What is a business listing?

A business listing is a profile of a local business on a search engine, map, social network, directory or voice assistant. It typically includes name, address, phone number, website, opening hours and photos.

Which listing errors matter most?

In the 2021 survey, wrong or inconsistent phone numbers (66%) and addresses (60%) were most likely to reduce consumer trust, ahead of poor-quality photos (45%).

How often should I check my business listings?

Check core listings regularly and after any change to your name, address, phone number, website, hours or services. Also check secondary and niche sites periodically, because directories and public edits can introduce errors without your knowledge.

Do low-usage directories still matter?

Sometimes. If a directory appears for your key local searches or competitors are already listed there, an accurate entry is worth securing. Once live, it usually needs only occasional accuracy checks.

Google (including Maps and Local Finder)89%
Facebook48%
Yelp32%
Instagram32%
Siri18%
Yahoo!18%
Twitter17%
Tripadvisor17%
Apple Maps17%
Amazon Alexa16%
Bing15%
Google Assistant15%
Mapquest12%
Better Business Bureau11%
Waze11%
Yellow Pages7%
Angi5%
Cortana4%
Foursquare3%
TomTom2%