What 20 Local Search Experts Said About Review Strategy
In 2014, a survey asked 20 local search practitioners about reviews and reputation management.
The findings are a historical reference, not a current ranking study. They are useful for understanding how experienced consultants thought about review generation, service packaging, and the relative weight of review signals at that time.
Survey context and participants
The survey gathered responses from 20 named local search experts. The participant table lists each contributor and their company or website. The questions covered whether review management was offered as a service, how it was packaged, how important it was to their work, how much time went to different tasks, and how they rated review sites and reputation signals.
The survey was published in April 2014. Any figures below should be read as a snapshot from that period. Review platforms, ranking systems, and consumer behaviour have changed since then, so check current conditions before applying the numbers directly.
Who took part
The participant list is preserved in the accompanying participant table. It includes practitioners from agencies and consultancies such as GoInFlow, Blumenthals, DAC Group, Expand2Web, Imprezzio Marketing, SearchCommander, Powered by Search, Improved Results, Ethical SEO Consulting, Local Oxygen, Glacial, Nifty Marketing, Local Visibility System, Whitespark, Local SEO Guide, Argent Media, Real Strategic, and Spyder Trap.
The table is a factual record of who was named in the survey. It is not an endorsement of any current service.
Was review management offered as a service?
90% of respondents said they offered review management. The survey used this question to establish that most participants were actively working in the area. A small number did not offer reputation services but were included because of their local search expertise, training work, or public writing.
For a consultant or agency today, the practical question is not whether every expert offers the service, but whether review work is part of your scope and how you will explain that scope to clients.
Standalone service or bundled with other marketing?
The survey found three common arrangements: 44% bundled reputation management with other services, 33% offered it as a standalone service, and 22% offered both. There was no single right answer.
A bundled approach can support a higher overall fee and a joined-up marketing programme, but it may push clients into services they do not need. A standalone approach is more flexible and lets clients choose only what they want, though revenue per customer may be lower. Offering both can suit agencies with different client types.
Decision checklist:
- Does the client need review work as part of a wider local campaign, or as a focused project?
- Can the client commit to the operational steps of asking for reviews?
- Will the client’s team respond to reviews, or will that sit with the agency?
- Is the pricing clear about what is included and what is optional?
- Can the arrangement be reviewed after the first few months?
How important was review management to their services?
35% described reviews and reputation management as the most important service in their offering, while 65% said it was either the most or very important. Only 5% said it was not important.
The survey commentary linked positive reviews to both local ranking and conversion. It also noted that reviews are harder to spam than some other signals because they represent consumer votes. That was the view in 2014; current ranking systems and review policies should be checked separately.
Change in review work compared with two years earlier
45% said they provided a lot more reputation management than two years earlier, and 80% said they offered more overall. The survey commentary treated this as evidence that review services were gaining importance in the local space.
For a reader using this as a historical reference, the useful point is the direction of travel at the time: review work was becoming a more visible part of local marketing. It does not establish what demand looks like now.
How time was split across reputation tasks
More than half of reputation-management time went to actively seeking new reviews. Only 11% went to responding to bad reviews. The survey commentary explained that many local businesses had relatively few reviews, so there was more headroom to generate new ones than to fight existing negative ones.
This is a useful distinction for process design: generating reviews and handling negative reviews are different jobs with different time demands. A plan that only reacts to bad reviews is not the same as a plan that builds a steady flow of new ones.
Worked example using the captured evidence: if a team has ten hours a month for reputation work and follows the survey’s broad split, more than five hours would go to asking for and supporting new reviews, while roughly one hour would go to responding to negative reviews. The rest would cover other tasks. This is an illustration of the reported split, not a recommended allocation for every business.
Citations, links, and reviews compared
Experts scored citations, links, and reviews from 1 to 10 for importance in their optimization work. The headline findings were that all three received similar weight, citations were considered more important than reviews, and links were considered least important.
The survey commentary argued that citations matter because inaccurate business data causes real-world problems and confuses search engines. Reviews were described as consumer votes that help search engines judge quality and help customers choose. Links were described as diminishing in influence because of over-optimization and spam.
These are 2014 opinions, not a current ranking-factor study. Treat the comparison as a dated reference and check current guidance before reprioritizing work.
Did experts use a repeatable review strategy?
83% said they used a similar strategy each time, while 17% devised a new strategy for each client. The survey commentary noted that a reusable strategy can be operationally efficient, but it still needs adapting to the client.
Common elements listed in the survey included targets, preferred review sites, education for the client and employees, communication about when to ask, and incentives for employees. When applying the strategy to a new client, the survey suggested adjusting targets based on local competitors, choosing relevant sites, tailoring training for service-area versus fixed-location businesses, asking soon after service, and varying incentives by business type.
How critical is a tried and tested review strategy?
55% said a review strategy was critical to effective local optimization, and 70% said it was critical or very important. None of the experts said reviews were not important.
The survey commentary concluded that reviews were extremely important to local search optimization and that an effective strategy was key to generating reviews for clients. One respondent warned that a strategy should not be too aggressive or reviews may be filtered.
For a reader today, the practical takeaway is to have a documented process, but to keep it within platform rules and to avoid sudden bursts that look unnatural.
Monthly review targets
40% targeted 2–3 new reviews per month, 60% targeted 2–5, and only 10% targeted more than 5. The survey commentary described these as conservative targets and offered three reasons: quality matters more than volume, reviews should build naturally month on month, and clients should not be overwhelmed.
The commentary also noted that targets vary by industry. Restaurants and hotels may expect higher volume, while some other industries may see only a couple of reviews a year as normal.
A simple way to use this as a historical reference is to set a baseline from the client’s current review flow and local competitors, then adjust for industry. Do not copy the 2–5 range as a universal rule.
Which review sites mattered most
Experts scored review sites from 1 to 10. Google+ Local was rated highest at 9.95/10, Yelp second at 8.95/10, and Yahoo Local third at 8.15/10. The survey commentary linked Google’s top position to its direct influence on local ranking and traffic. Yelp was noted for audience size and syndication to Yahoo Local and Apple Maps. Yahoo Local was noted for traffic volume.
TripAdvisor was described as a powerhouse in travel and restaurants. Other sites such as Yellow Pages, CitySearch, InsiderPages, and Angie’s List received similar importance weightings. The survey also noted that Bing Places did not have a review facility at that time.
These site names and scores are from 2014. Platform features and relative importance have changed, so check current conditions before choosing where to focus.
Social and reputation signals for local ranking
Experts scored signals from 1 to 10. Reviews on Google+ were rated most powerful at 8.8/10, reviews on third-party sites second at 7.15/10, and Pinterest and LinkedIn least valuable at 3.7 and 3.35/10. The survey commentary noted that third-party reviews were closer to Google+ than expected.
Within social signals, +1s and Foursquare were described as the top two, with Facebook and Twitter behind them. The commentary cautioned that Foursquare is not relevant for every business, especially service-area businesses and some professional services.
This is a dated snapshot. Social platforms and ranking signals change, so use it to understand the historical view rather than as a current priority list.
When a client cannot or will not get reviews
The survey asked experts how they handle clients who cannot or will not get reviews. Answers varied. Some shifted focus to responding to existing reviews, making spontaneous reviews easier, increasing social activity, and collecting on-site testimonials. Others focused on business listings, links, content, awards, accreditations, trust seals, or private customer feedback. One respondent said they would not work with a client who would not take responsibility for the review process.
The practical distinction is between a client who cannot get reviews and a client who will not participate. The first may need alternative trust signals and a slower plan. The second is a scope and expectation problem that should be resolved before work begins.
| Participant | Company or website |
|---|---|
| Mike Belasco | goinflow.com |
| Laura Betterly | laurabetterly.com |
| Mike Blumenthal | blumenthals.com |
| Phil Britton | dacgroup.com |
| Don Campbell | expand2web.com |
| Joy Hawkins | imprezzziomarketing.com |
| Scott Hendison | searchcommander.com |
| Matthew Hunt | poweredbysearch.com |
| Jon Keel | improvedresults.com |
| Casey Meraz | ethicalseoconsulting.com |
| Chris Ormiston | localoxygen.com |
| Darryl Quinlan | glacial.com |
| Mike Ramsey | niftymarketing.com |
| Phil Rozek | localvisibilitysystem.com |
| Darren Shaw | whitespark.ca |
| Andrew Shotland | localseoguide.com |
| Chris Silver Smith | argentmedia.com |
| David Sprague | realstrategic.com |
| Aaron Weiche | spydertrap.com |
| Nyagoslav Zhekov | whitespark.ca |
Names and company/website details are preserved from the 2014 survey participant table. They are not current endorsements.
Frequently asked questions
What did the 2014 survey find about review strategy?
55% of the 20 experts said a tried and tested review strategy was critical to effective local optimization, and 70% said it was critical or very important. None said reviews were not important. These are historical opinions from 2014.
How many new reviews per month did the experts target?
40% targeted 2–3 new reviews per month, 60% targeted 2–5, and only 10% targeted more than 5. The survey noted that targets vary by industry and that quality and consistency matter more than sheer volume.
Which review sites were rated most important?
Google+ Local was rated highest at 9.95/10, followed by Yelp at 8.95/10 and Yahoo Local at 8.15/10. These scores are from 2014 and should not be treated as current rankings.
What should a consultant do if a client cannot get reviews?
The survey answers varied. Options included responding to existing reviews, making spontaneous reviews easier, increasing social activity, collecting on-site testimonials, focusing on listings and links, and highlighting awards or trust seals. If the client will not participate at all, that is a scope issue to resolve before work begins.