Young Consumers and Online Reviews: Reading the 2019 Survey
The 2019 Local Consumer Review Survey found a striking split among 18-34 year-olds.
Fewer said they used the internet to find local businesses, yet those who did read reviews read more of them and spent longer doing so than the average consumer. This guide explains what the survey measured, where the signals conflict, and how a local business can use the findings without over-reading a single year.
What the survey measured
The survey asked a representative group the same questions year on year. For this analysis, the 18-34 group is treated as one block, although the results suggest at least two different behaviours inside it. The questions covered how often people used the internet to find local businesses, whether they read reviews for local businesses, how much they trusted those reviews, whether they believed they had seen a fake review in the past year, and how many reviews and how much time they spent before trusting a business. Because the questions were repeated, year-on-year movement is meaningful as a signal, but it is not proof of a permanent shift.
Local search frequency: the 'never' group grew
In 2019, 15% of 18-34 year-olds said they never used the internet to find local businesses, up from 3% the previous year. Mid-range frequencies fell, but responses did not move to the more frequent end. Across all age groups, the 'never' share rose from 8% to 10%, while daily local searches rose from 27% to 33%. The young-adult pattern therefore differs from the overall trend. The survey cannot say why. Possible explanations include social recommendations replacing original search, a narrower idea of what counts as a local business, or different meanings attached to 'using the internet'. These remain hypotheses, not findings.
Reading reviews and trusting them
Among 18-34 year-olds, more said they always read reviews for local businesses, rising from 50% to 52%. At the same time, more said they never read them. Trust showed a similar split: those who trusted reviews completely rose from 39% to 41%, while the share saying they did not trust online reviews at all jumped by 13 percentage points. The survey also asked whether respondents believed they had read a fake review in the past year. More young people said they were confident in spotting fake reviews and saw them regularly. That is a perception measure, not a count of fake reviews on any platform.
Engagement intensity: fewer readers, but deeper reading
The readers in this group were not casual. Young people who read reviews for local businesses read 30% more reviews than the average consumer before trusting a business, and spent 35% more time reading them. So the survey shows both disengagement and deeper engagement in the same age band. A local business should not treat 'young people read fewer reviews' as a complete description. The more accurate statement is that the group is splitting: some avoid reviews, while others examine them more closely than average.
A decision checklist for local businesses
Use the checklist to separate the two signals before changing a marketing plan.
- Is the problem discovery or evaluation? If local searches are falling, review volume is not the first lever. If searches are steady but review reading is falling, review presentation and trust signals matter more.
- Are you measuring the right group? The 18-34 band contains both review avoiders and heavy review readers. Segment by behaviour, not only by age.
- Does your review profile answer a sceptical reader? The survey suggests some young readers look at more reviews and spend longer doing so. Recent, specific and varied reviews are more useful than a single polished testimonial.
- Are you visible where recommendations happen? The survey raises the possibility that social recommendations replace some original search, but it does not prove it. Test social and list-based discovery alongside review profiles.
- Are you treating 2019 as a permanent trend? It is one survey year. Track later results before making a long-term budget shift.
Worked example: reading the numbers together
Imagine a local restaurant reviewing its 2020 plan using the 2019 figures. It sees that 15% of 18-34 year-olds said they never search online for local businesses, which suggests discovery may happen elsewhere for part of the audience. It also sees that 52% of the same group always read reviews, and that readers in the group read 30% more reviews and spend 35% more time than average. The practical conclusion is not 'stop asking for reviews'. It is to keep the review profile strong for the readers who do use it, while testing discovery channels such as local lists and social media for the part of the audience that may not begin with a search. The survey supports the test, not a guaranteed outcome.
Practical responses suggested by the findings
The survey's own suggestions for local businesses were to seek inclusion in local 'top' lists where younger audiences look, to become more active on social media with Instagram advertising where a strong image or short video can sell the product, and to use in-store tactics such as a hashtag, a social competition or a photo-friendly wall. These are reasonable tests, not proven fixes. The survey also notes that 2019 may have been an unusual year, so later data should be checked before treating any single movement as permanent.
Frequently asked questions
Did the survey show that young people read fewer reviews?
It showed both directions. More 18-34 year-olds said they never read reviews for local businesses, while slightly more said they always did. Among those who read reviews, the group read 30% more reviews and spent 35% more time than the average consumer before trusting a business.
What does 'never used the internet to find local businesses' mean?
It is the survey's own wording for a self-reported answer. The survey does not establish whether respondents excluded apps, social platforms or particular kinds of local business. The rise from 3% to 15% among 18-34 year-olds is a signal worth tracking, not a settled explanation.
Does the survey prove that fake reviews caused lower trust?
No. It records that more young respondents said they were confident in spotting fake reviews and saw them regularly, and that more said they did not trust reviews at all. The survey does not isolate fake reviews as the cause of the trust shift.
Should a local business stop asking for reviews because of these findings?
The findings do not support that conclusion. A meaningful share of 18-34 year-olds still read reviews, and the readers in that group engage more deeply than average. The survey points toward combining a strong review profile with tests of local lists and social discovery.