What Local Consumers Want from Local Business Websites
A local business website is often the first place a potential customer checks before making contact.
A 2014 survey of 811 consumers in the US and Canada asked what they notice, what they need, and what puts them off. The findings are a dated reference point, not a current benchmark, but they still offer a practical way to prioritize the basics on a local business homepage.
What the survey asked
The survey covered four areas: how a website affects the decision to use a local business, which information matters most, which factors make a business appealing, and which factors cause consumers to stop considering it. The original publisher reports 811 responses from its local consumer panel, all based in the US and Canada, with a near-even gender split (46% men, 54% women) and a range of age groups. The results below are from February 2014 and should be treated as historical evidence; local search behaviour and consumer expectations have changed since then.
Credibility comes from clarity, not polish alone
A clear and smart website gave a local business more credibility according to 36% of respondents. Overall, 68% said having a website, ideally well designed, was a key factor in their opinion of a business and influenced their decision to use it. Only 27% said they were not bothered whether a local business had a website. An ugly or bad website was cited by just 5% as a reason to avoid a business, which suggests that basic clarity matters more than visual perfection. Older consumers (55+) gave more credibility to a clean, smart site, while younger consumers were more design-oriented and more likely to judge a clunky site. Consumers aged 18–34 were twice as likely as those aged 55+ to contact a local business if it had a website.
The four P's of local business website content
When asked what information is most important, respondents prioritized product, price, place, and phone number — the four P's. Customers want the basic facts they need to decide whether a business fits their needs. Least important were customer testimonials, website speed, accreditations, and mobile sites. The survey notes that these factors may still help SEO, but they were not the main decision drivers for initial evaluation. Older customers were more interested in products, prices, and physical location, while younger consumers were more led by convenience such as opening hours and by website style.
What makes consumers choose a local business
Closeness or localness was the most important factor when deciding whether to use a local business. Clear contact details and company information were also key, each cited by 16% of respondents. Softer factors such as testimonials, website style, and photos also had an impact on final decision-making. Older customers placed more weight on proximity and facts, while younger consumers were more swayed by website style and attractive design. Men were more attracted by a freephone number, 24-hour service, and a fast website; women were more interested in clear contact details and customer testimonials.
What stops consumers from using a local business
Having no phone number, no price list, and poor content were the major turnoffs. Being truly local to the customer was also a big factor, but one a business cannot easily change. Consumers were less likely to be put off by a lack of reviews or poor-quality photos, which were more easily forgiven. All age groups put 'No Phone Number' as their biggest reason for not using a business. Younger consumers (18–34) paid the most attention to photo quality. Women were more likely to judge a business on customer reviews and image quality, and were more likely to want an email contact option. Men were more likely to be deterred by unclear pricing.
A practical homepage checklist
Use the survey findings as a starting point, then check current conditions. A local business homepage should make the following easy to find without hunting: what you sell or do, your prices or price range, your address and service area, your phone number, your opening hours, and a clear way to email or message you. Company information and contact details deserve prominent placement. Design should support clarity rather than replace it. Testimonials, photos, accreditations, and blog content can add depth later in the decision process, but they should not crowd out the basics. Because the survey is from 2014, treat these priorities as a historical reference and review them against your own current audience and analytics.
Frequently asked questions
What information do local consumers consider most important on a business website?
In the 2014 survey, the most important information was product, price, place, and phone number — the four P's. Customers wanted the basic facts needed to decide whether a business fits their needs. Testimonials, website speed, accreditations, and mobile sites were considered less important for initial evaluation.
Does a bad website design stop consumers from using a local business?
Only 5% of respondents said a bad or ugly website would put them off using a local business. A clear and smart website gave 36% more credibility, but basic information and contact details mattered more than visual polish. Younger consumers were more design-oriented than older ones.
What is the biggest turnoff on a local business website?
Having no phone number was the biggest turnoff across all age groups. No price list and poor content were also major reasons consumers would stop considering a business. Lack of reviews and poor-quality photos were more easily forgiven.
Do men and women look for different things on a local business website?
The survey found some differences: men were more focused on website aesthetics and performance, and were more attracted by a freephone number, 24-hour service, and a fast website. Women were more pragmatic, more interested in clear contact details and customer testimonials, and more likely to want an email contact option. These are historical findings and may not reflect current behaviour.