SMB Internet Marketing in 2014: Budgets, Attitudes and Agency Use
The 2014 SMB Internet Marketing Survey, conducted in partnership with ChamberOfCommerce.com, gathered responses from 736 small and medium-sized businesses between October and November 2014.
Most respondents were based in North America and operated with very small teams. The findings below summarise spending patterns, perceived effectiveness of online channels, and the relationship between SMBs and marketing consultants. All figures are dated to that survey period and should be read as a historical benchmark rather than a current market snapshot.
Survey background and respondent profile
The survey defined SMBs as businesses with 0–50 employees. Among respondents, 58% had between 0 and 3 employees, and 16% had between 11 and 50 employees. The vast majority (97%) fell within the SMB bracket. Geographically, 95% were located in North America, 4% in Europe and 1% in the rest of the world. The research was split into two parts: engagement and opinions, and marketing support. This structure allowed the survey to explore both day-to-day marketing behaviour and attitudes toward external agencies.
Marketing budgets and online share
Monthly marketing budgets were modest. 70% of SMBs spent less than $500 per month on marketing, and 83% spent less than $1,000. Only 16% exceeded $1,000 per month. These proportions were almost identical to 2013 figures, suggesting little year-on-year change in overall marketing outlay. When asked what share of that budget went to internet or mobile marketing, 34% allocated less than 10% to online channels, while 50% allocated less than 30%. At the other end, 29% allocated more than 70% to online. Combining these answers, the survey estimated that 50% of SMBs spent less than $300 per month on internet marketing. The data also showed a correlation between company size and budget, though exceptions existed in both directions.
Plans to increase internet marketing spend
37% of respondents planned to increase their internet marketing spend over the next 12 months, up from 21% in the prior year. A further 47% were unsure whether they would change their spending level, and 16% had no plans to increase. The rise in positive spending intent was the first clear attitudinal shift from 2013 and was interpreted as a favourable signal for local search and marketing businesses. The large unsure group suggested that actual spending could rise further if business conditions improved.
Perceived effectiveness and channel performance
32% of SMBs rated internet marketing as ‘very effective’ at attracting new customers, and 75% considered it either ‘effective’ or ‘very effective’. Only 4% said they did not do any internet marketing, down from 8% in 2013. When asked which channels brought the most new leads and customers, word of mouth was the single most cited at 28%, followed by SEO at 20%. Online channels collectively were named most effective by 51% of respondents. The survey treated word of mouth as an offline channel. Among the top four channels, three were online: SEO, online local directories and email marketing. These four accounted for 73% of total responses. The perceived effectiveness of SEO rose slightly year on year, while faith in PPC dipped marginally.
Success metrics that matter to SMBs
Respondents selected two options from five success metrics. Phone calls were the most valued metric at 31%, followed by website traffic and search engine rankings, each at 20%. The survey noted that different business types prioritise different KPIs; an ecommerce business might focus on online metrics while a local bakery might care more about footfall. For many SMBs, a phone call represented a more committed lead because it required more effort than completing an online form. The continued focus on search rankings was seen as a signal that business owners still value visibility in search results, even as some consultants push for more concrete outcome metrics. This question was not asked in 2013, so no year-on-year comparison is available.
Mobile readiness and attitudes to Google My Business
66% of SMBs reported having a mobile-ready or mobile-optimised website, up from 59% in 2013. 19% did not, down from 26%. The survey linked this improvement to Google’s introduction of a mobile-friendly label in mobile search results in November 2014, which could confer a ranking boost. On Google+ Local / Google My Business, 41% found it clear and easy to use, 20% knew it was important but did not understand it, and 17% were frustrated by the amount of changes. The survey noted a decrease in SMBs thinking Google+ Local / GMB was unimportant or that Google did not understand small businesses.
Use of marketing consultants and agencies
64% of SMBs handled their internet marketing in-house, down from 68% in 2013. 18% used a consultant or agency, up from 15%. Despite the slight shift toward outsourcing, most small businesses still kept marketing in-house. The survey suggested this was more likely due to smaller budgets than mistrust of agencies. Among those who did use an agency or consultant, 39% loved the work, and 76% were positive about performance. However, the proportion of positive ratings fell from 85% in 2013. The survey raised the question of whether agencies needed to improve how they demonstrated expertise to potential clients.
Agency outreach and selection priorities
35% of SMBs were contacted every day by a consultant or SEO agency, and 90% were contacted at least once a month. Both figures rose slightly from 2013. When choosing an agency, low cost was the most important factor for 18% of respondents, followed by performance guarantees at 14% and good reputation at 13%. Relevant industry experience was important to 12%, and a willingness to listen and learn about client needs to 9%. The survey observed a tension: SMBs with limited budgets prioritise low cost, but quality agencies must cover their own costs. Performance guarantees were also popular, yet the survey questioned how many reputable SEOs would promise top positions without serious qualifiers.
Attitudes toward internet marketing and outlook
29% of SMBs understood internet marketing and did it all themselves, down from 40% in 2013. 28% were learning about it and wanted to do it themselves, up from 22%. In total, 84% wanted to or did handle their own internet marketing, unchanged from the previous year. 16% had no interest in doing it themselves. The survey noted an 11% decrease in those who felt they fully understood and managed internet marketing, which may reflect the growing complexity of the field. Cost was a barrier: 17% of SMBs were put off by the price of doing online marketing in-house. The report concluded that 2015 could be a turning point, with more SMBs planning to increase online spend and most agencies delivering high-quality services.
Checklist for benchmarking your own marketing approach
Use the following questions to compare your situation with the 2014 survey findings. Remember that the data is historical and should be supplemented with current market research.
- Does your monthly marketing budget fall below the $500 or $1,000 thresholds that characterised most SMBs in 2014?
- What proportion of your marketing budget goes to online channels, and does it align with the 30% and 70% bands reported?
- If you handle marketing in-house, do you have the time and skills to keep up with platform changes, or would a consultant help?
- Which success metrics matter most to your business—phone calls, website traffic, rankings, or something else?
- Is your website mobile-friendly, and have you claimed and optimised your Google Business Profile?
- When evaluating agencies, do you prioritise low cost, guarantees, reputation, or industry experience, and are your expectations realistic?
Frequently asked questions
What was the sample size and geography of the 2014 SMB Internet Marketing Survey?
The survey collected responses from 736 SMBs. 95% were located in North America, 4% in Europe, and 1% in the rest of the world. The survey was conducted in October and November 2014.
How did SMBs rate the effectiveness of internet marketing?
32% rated internet marketing as ‘very effective’ at attracting new customers, and 75% considered it ‘effective’ or ‘very effective’. Only 4% said they did not do any internet marketing.
What percentage of SMBs used a marketing consultant or agency?
18% of surveyed SMBs used a consultant or agency, up from 15% in 2013. The majority, 64%, handled their internet marketing in-house.
What was the most valued success metric for SMBs?
Phone calls were the most valued success metric, selected by 31% of respondents. Website traffic and search engine rankings were each selected by 20%.
How many SMBs had a mobile-ready website?
66% of SMBs reported having a mobile-ready or mobile-optimised website, up from 59% in 2013. 19% did not have one.