Skip to content

Why Are Fake Reviews a Problem?

A review can be faked in either direction, and both directions cost someone money.

A bought five-star rating can send a buyer to a product or venue that has not earned it; an invented one-star rating can send the same buyer away from a business that has done nothing wrong. The wider damage is to the review system itself: when buyers suspect that ratings can be purchased, the honest reviews sitting beside the fake ones carry less weight. This guide sets out what the available evidence shows, where it is uncertain, and how to handle a review that looks suspicious without treating every unhappy customer as a fraudster.

The short answer

A fake review is a false signal in a decision people make quickly. It can steer a shopper towards a product or venue that has not earned its rating, or away from a business that has done nothing wrong. The harm does not stop at the individual purchase: once buyers learn that ratings can be bought, every honest review on the same page loses some of its persuasive power. For a local business, the reviews you worked to earn end up competing against reviews someone simply paid for. This guide separates what the evidence actually shows from what it does not, then sets out a practical response you can apply to your own profile.

How common are fake reviews?

The figures below are drawn from external research and reporting, not from an independent audit carried out for this page. The cited material includes a consumer review survey, the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), Which?, The Washington Post and Bazaarvoice. Because the evidence is dated and the underlying material contains some internal inconsistencies, treat each figure as a reference point rather than a current measurement, and check the latest platform or regulator data before relying on any single number. Where the cited material gives two different values for the same measure, both are noted so the discrepancy is visible rather than hidden. The survey cited in the source material is the basis for the share of consumers who had read a fake review in the last year: the source headline gives 74%, while its body text cites 82% from the same survey, so these should be read as related but not identical measures. The same survey is cited for age breakdowns: the source headline gives 92% of 18-34-year-olds who had read a fake review online in the last year, while the body text gives 89% for that group, 74% for 35-54-year-olds and 59% for consumers over 54. The CMA estimated that fake reviews potentially influence around £23bn of UK customer spending each year. A Which? investigation concluded that up to one in seven TripAdvisor reviews could be fake. A Washington Post analysis found that 61% of electronics reviews on Amazon were fake. Bazaarvoice research found that 54% of consumers would not buy a product if they suspected it had fake reviews.

Why fake reviews hurt consumers

A fake positive review can push a shopper towards a product or venue that has not earned its rating. A fake negative review can push them away from a business that has done nothing wrong. Either way, the consumer makes a choice on false information. The CMA's concern is not only that people are misled, but that money moves as a result: spending that would have gone to an honest business can be diverted to one using fake reviews. The CMA also notes that cherry-picking or suppressing negative reviews can mislead consumers in the same way.

Why fake reviews hurt honest businesses

If a competitor buys five-star reviews, they can climb rankings and win enquiries that should have gone elsewhere. The CMA findings single out small hospitality businesses as particularly exposed. On Amazon, the Washington Post analysis found that fake reviews made it very difficult for rule-following sellers to compete; one small business owner described the effect as devastating because it made selling on the platform impossible if you played by the rules. The same logic applies locally: a business that refuses to buy reviews can lose visibility to one that does.

What the law says in the UK

The source material refers to the 2008 Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations, which forbid the practice of paying for fake reviews or misrepresenting a trader as a consumer. The CMA has run a programme of work on fake reviews after an investigation into their effect on UK spending. The regulation is not a complete answer to every fake review, but it establishes that buying or inventing reviews is a banned practice, not just a marketing grey area.

How to tell a fake review from a genuine negative one

This is the distinction that matters most in practice. A negative review is not automatically fake, and treating a real complaint as fake can damage trust further. Use the following checklist before you decide.

  • Does the review contain repeated exclamation points such as '!!' or '!!!'? MIT research cited in the source material found this pattern more often in reviews from people who had not made a purchase.
  • Does the review make specific requests such as 'please', 'bring back', 'offer more' or 'go back to'? The same research found these requests more often in reviews without a purchase.
  • Is the review unusually long and detailed compared with your normal reviews?
  • Does the reviewer have only one review, or reviews only of unrelated locations? This is one of the hallmarks of fake reviews noted in the TripAdvisor context.
  • Does the review describe an experience that your records can confirm or contradict?

If the answer to several of these is yes, treat the review as suspected fake and follow the response and reporting steps below. If the review is negative but specific and consistent with a real interaction, treat it as genuine feedback and respond accordingly.

A worked example: the pizza restaurant

Suppose you run a pizza restaurant and a one-star review appears that says the toppings were wrong and the atmosphere was wrong, with several exclamation marks and a request to 'bring back' an old menu item. Before assuming it is fake, check your order records and booking system. If you find no matching order, and the reviewer has only one review, the checklist above suggests it is worth treating as suspected fake. Respond publicly and courteously, invite the reviewer to contact you privately, and report the review to the platform if it breaches policy. At the same time, ask genuine customers prompt questions such as which topping they enjoyed most, what kind of occasion the restaurant suits, and how they found the menu price points. Those specific, experience-based reviews make your profile look authentic and give future readers something useful to judge.

What to do when you suspect a fake review

  1. Log the review with the platform, the date, the reviewer name, the rating and the exact wording. This gives you a record if you need to escalate.
  2. Check your own records for a matching transaction or booking.
  3. Respond publicly and courteously. Acknowledge the concern, show willingness to fix it, and invite private contact. Do not accuse the reviewer of lying in public.
  4. Report the review to the platform if it breaches that platform's review policy. On TripAdvisor, for example, buying reviews, offering incentives and posting reviews for your own business are against policy.
  5. Keep collecting genuine reviews with specific prompts so that your profile has a strong base of authentic feedback.
  6. If the problem is persistent, consider legal or regulatory advice, particularly in the UK where the CMA has taken an active interest in fake reviews.

The bottom line

Fake reviews are a real and measurable problem. They mislead buyers, put honest operators at a disadvantage and erode confidence in reviews as a whole. The evidence here is a dated reference, not a current audit, so check the latest platform and regulatory information before acting. The practical response is consistent: reply professionally, report where policy allows, gather genuine reviews with specific prompts, and avoid any shortcut that puts your reputation at risk.

Reader decision checklist: fake or genuine?

Use this checklist before you act on a suspicious review. It separates a suspected fake from a genuine negative review, which is the distinction that matters most in practice.

  • Repeated exclamation points ('!!' or '!!!'): MIT research cited here found this pattern more often in reviews from people who had not made a purchase.
  • Specific requests such as 'please', 'bring back', 'offer more' or 'go back to': the same research found these more often in reviews without a purchase.
  • Unusually long and detailed text compared with your normal reviews.
  • A reviewer with only one review, or reviews only of unrelated locations: one of the hallmarks noted in the TripAdvisor context.
  • A described experience your records can confirm or contradict.

If several answers point to fake, treat the review as suspected fake and follow the response and reporting steps. If the review is negative but specific and consistent with a real interaction, treat it as genuine feedback and respond accordingly.

What to log when you report a suspected fake review

Keep a simple record for each suspected fake review so you can escalate if needed. Capture the platform, the review URL or ID, the date posted, the reviewer display name, the star rating and the exact wording. Note whether your own records show a matching transaction or booking, and record the date you reported the review and any platform response. This log is what lets you show a pattern if the same account or network keeps targeting your profile.

Frequently asked questions

Are fake reviews illegal?

In the UK, the source material refers to the 2008 Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations, which forbid paying for fake reviews or misrepresenting a trader as a consumer. Platform policies also prohibit buying reviews, offering incentives and posting reviews for your own business. The exact legal position can vary by country and by platform, so check current guidance for your jurisdiction.

How can I tell if a review is fake?

Look for repeated exclamation points, specific requests such as 'please' or 'bring back', unusually long and detailed text, and reviewers with only one review or reviews of unrelated locations. None of these is conclusive on its own, so combine them with your own records. A negative review that is specific and consistent with a real interaction should be treated as genuine feedback.

Should I respond to a fake review?

Yes. The source material cites review response speed and frequency as a local SEO ranking factor and notes that 89% of consumers will read responses. Reply courteously, show willingness to fix the issue, and invite private contact. If the review is fake, you will not hear back, but the public reply still demonstrates that you take feedback seriously.

What should I do if I suspect a fake review on TripAdvisor or Amazon?

Report it to the platform using its review-reporting process. On TripAdvisor, buying reviews, offering incentives and posting reviews for your own business are against policy. On Amazon, the source material notes that fake reviews have been a significant problem in some categories. Keep a record of the review and your report in case you need to escalate.

How many consumers have read a fake review in the last year?

The survey cited in the source material is the basis for this figure. Its headline gives 74% of consumers who had read a fake review in the last year, while its body text cites 82% from the same survey; read these as related but not identical measures. The same survey gives age breakdowns: 92% in the headline and 89% in the body for 18-34-year-olds, 74% for 35-54-year-olds and 59% for consumers over 54. These are dated reference figures, so check current survey data before relying on any single number.