Review Platform Guidelines
A review request that is perfectly acceptable on one platform can be suppressed, removed or treated as fraud on another.
This guide sets out the main rules for Google, Yelp, Facebook, Tripadvisor, the Better Business Bureau, Yellow Pages and Angi, then turns them into a short audit you can run against your own review workflow.
Why platform rules matter
Local businesses now face a long list of review sites, from broad platforms such as Google, Yelp and Facebook to industry-specific directories. Reviews influence how prominently a business appears in local search and whether consumers decide to buy, so many companies have experimented with postcards, SMS, in-store displays, giveaways and email to ask for them.
The difficulty is that each platform defines differently what a business may do to obtain a review and what a review may say. Breaches can be costly: a review may be hidden, a profile may carry a public warning, or an account may be restricted. The sections below summarise the rules that matter most for day-to-day review management.
Google review guidelines
Google publishes detailed rules for businesses and reviewers, mainly under its prohibited and restricted content policy, with additional format-specific criteria that rule out practices such as review gating.
No review gating. Businesses may not use a third-party tool to filter out negative reviews, nor ask only customers known to be happy. In the past, some brands used software to send unhappy customers to private feedback and happy ones to a public platform; Google now treats that as creating a false impression.
Do not review your own business. Reviews are meant to reflect genuine customer experience, so reviewing your own business, or asking staff to pose as customers, breaks the rules.
Do not review competitors. Content posted by a competitor to undermine a business or product is deceptive. Google says such content will be removed, and repeat offenders may face a site-level penalty that affects visibility, traffic and sales.
No payment for reviews. You cannot pay customers to leave a review. Payment makes a glowing review more likely and undermines fair feedback. Google warns that breaching content will be removed and that serious or repeated breaches can lead to penalties or removal from Google Business Profile.
Do not solicit reviews in bulk. Google does not ban asking for reviews, but requests should go to all customers equally. A mass email to an entire mailing list is poor practice: some recipients may have bought years ago, and a steady flow of recent, genuine reviews is more useful than a one-off influx. Ask consistently when a transaction is completed.
Yelp review guidelines
Yelp's rules overlap with Google's on inappropriate content, promotional content, conflicts of interest and payment, but one difference is central: Yelp tells businesses not to ask for reviews at all.
No soliciting and no payment. Yelp says reviews are meant to come from people who share genuine experiences without being asked or tempted. Its automated software may not recommend reviews that appear to have been prompted by the business, and because many businesses ask only happy customers, solicited reviews can bias ratings. Yelp also prohibits paying for reviews and offering incentives to have a review removed.
No review gating. Yelp's guidelines say businesses cannot ask for reviews after requesting feedback elsewhere, such as in surveys or contact forms.
What happens if you breach the rule. Yelp says its software can recognise solicited reviews and treat them as less trustworthy. They may be moved to the 'not recommended' section and will not count towards the star rating. If Yelp has evidence that a review was compensated, a Compensated Activity Alert can appear on the business profile.
Conflicts of interest. You may not review your own business, ask an employee to do so, or leave a poor review for a competitor. Reviews of a relative's or friend's business, or of a business in your networking group, are also off-limits because they lack objectivity. Yelp's recommendation software is designed to spot such conflicts.
Facebook review guidelines
Facebook now calls reviews Recommendations. They are a yes/no choice rather than a star rating, and consumers can add text and images to explain their answer.
No spam. Facebook's Community Standards include a no-spam rule and state that the company works to limit content designed to deceive or mislead. You should not incentivise people to leave large numbers of positive recommendations, nor spam a competitor's profile with negative ones.
No misrepresentation. Facebook's Integrity policy requires users to create accounts under their true identity, described as the name they go by in real life. It prohibits multiple accounts, a false date of birth, inauthentic profiles and impersonation. In practice, you cannot create several accounts under aliases to recommend your own business, nor ask others to open a second account to recommend you. Accounts in continual breach may be disabled.
No incentivised reviews. Under its Pages, Groups and Events policy, Facebook states that pages, groups and events must not incentivise people to misuse Facebook features or functionality. Offering cash, a discount, or free product or service in exchange for a positive Recommendation falls foul of that rule.
Tripadvisor review guidelines
Tripadvisor differs from Yelp: it does not penalise businesses for asking guests to review their experience, and it says recent reviews carry more weight in its popularity ranking. The platform provides free tools to help, including reminder cards, flyers, a review collection tool called Review Express, a widget and a Facebook app.
Paid review fraud. Tripadvisor prohibits incentivised reviews and runs a dedicated fraud team. Buying or selling fake reviews is described as dishonest and illegal in many countries. Tripadvisor says it can distinguish a genuine submission from a purchased one and can trigger an investigation automatically. It works with third-party sites and advertising services to track sellers and may even go undercover to gather evidence. If paid reviews or suspicious activity are detected on your listing, the platform will approach you for more information. The paid reviewer's account can be blacklisted, and your own account or business profile may carry a red badge warning users that a pattern of suspicious behaviour has been detected. Other penalties include loss of ranking in Tripadvisor search and disqualification from Tripadvisor awards. Reviews found to be incentivised are removed.
Incentivised reviews. Tripadvisor treats any reward or preferential treatment offered to secure a review as a breach. The ban covers prize draws and raffles, a reduced rate or discount on a future stay, and promises of an upgrade or free access to paid facilities. Tripadvisor monitors through community reports, its fraud team and screening technology, and removes reviews found to breach the rules.
Biased reviews and blackmail. Paid and incentivised reviews also fall under the biased reviews policy. A guest who threatens a business with a bad review is acting in a biased way, as is anyone affiliated with the business, such as a family member, friend or employee. Tripadvisor calls this 'review boosting'. A review flagged as biased is not published and an investigation is opened.
Review vandalism. Anyone associated with a business is prohibited from reviewing similar businesses nearby. Submitting false reviews about competitors is treated as review vandalism and can attract harsh penalties if proven.
Better Business Bureau review guidelines
The Better Business Bureau (BBB) is one of the most trusted review platforms, and it applies its own rules to business reviews.
Fake reviews. BBB vets every review before publication. It validates the reviewer's email address or phone number, then asks the business to confirm that the interaction took place and to respond to the comments.
No anonymous reviews. BBB does not accept reviews from anonymous users, although it does not publish identifying details about the reviewer when a review is accepted.
No paid reviews. BBB does not allow incentivised reviews, so customers cannot be compensated in any way. The BBB website does not spell out additional punishments for businesses that breach the rules, but fake or paid reviews will not be published, which means any time and money spent obtaining them is wasted.
Yellow Pages review guidelines
Yellow Pages says it does not monitor or censor reviews, but it expects businesses and reviewers to follow its guidelines and policy. Those rules prohibit paying for reviews, reviewing your own business, reviewing a competitor's business and astroturfing.
Astroturfing. Business owners can report reviews that are defamatory or fake. Abusing that route to have every negative review removed and leave only positive ones is astroturfing. Yellow Pages says this misleads customers and can damage your online reputation. The platform does not set out specific punishments, but it notes that suspicious reviews will be removed. Because a Yellow Pages business rating is based on star ratings, losing reviews will probably lower the rating.
Paying for reviews. Business owners may not pay for reviews or offer incentives, whether for their own profile or to encourage reviews of competitors. Yellow Pages does not specify a punishment, but paid, untrue reviews are a form of fraud and are illegal in many countries.
No friends or family. Business owners may not request reviews from friends or family. A review found to be unsubstantiated is removed from the platform.
Angi review guidelines
Angi (formerly Angie's List) treats a review as fake if it comes from you, from anyone who works for you or has an interest in the business such as a shareholder, or from a friend or family member. Reviews that breach these policies may be redacted, deleted or rejected.
No anonymous reviews. Angi does not accept anonymous reviews. The reviewer's name and address are visible to the business being reviewed, which the platform says ensures fairness.
No reviewing competitors. Because anonymous reviews are not allowed, you cannot fraudulently review a competitor: the business will be able to identify you. Angi also requires reviewers to have first-hand experience of the business, which a competitor would not have.
No incentivised reviews. Angi does not permit compensation or incentives for reviews. Reviews must reflect the actual experience delivered by the business, so buying them is not allowed. Links are also not permitted in reviews.
A practical review-request checklist
Use this checklist before you send any review request or run any review campaign.
- Identify the target platform first. If the request is for Yelp, do not ask at all. If it is for Tripadvisor, asking is allowed and encouraged. If it is for Google, asking is allowed but must be offered equally to all customers.
- Remove all incentives. No cash, discounts, free products, prize draws, upgrades or preferential treatment in exchange for a review on any of the platforms covered here.
- Remove gating. Do not screen customers by sentiment, do not send only happy customers to a public platform, and do not ask for a public review after a private survey or contact form on Yelp.
- Check who is being asked. Do not ask staff, friends, family, shareholders or anyone with an interest in the business to review it. Do not review competitors.
- Check the channel and timing. Avoid a single mass email to an old mailing list. Ask consistently after a completed transaction, and keep the request tied to a real experience.
- Check identity rules. On Facebook and Angi, anonymous or duplicate accounts are not allowed. On BBB, reviews are validated before publication.
- Record your process. Keep a short written note of who was asked, when, through which channel and with what wording, so you can show that requests were equal and non-incentivised if a platform asks.
Worked example: one request, two platforms
A hotel completes a guest's stay and wants more reviews. On Tripadvisor, the hotel may hand the guest a reminder card and point them to its listing; Tripadvisor encourages businesses to ask and says recent reviews help its popularity ranking. The same hotel must not run the same request for Yelp: Yelp's software may treat a prompted review as less trustworthy, move it to the 'not recommended' section and exclude it from the star rating. If the hotel offered the guest a free upgrade for leaving the review, that would breach Tripadvisor's incentivised-review rule and could lead to removal of the review and, in serious cases, a red warning badge on the profile.
The lesson is not that one platform is stricter overall. It is that the same operational action has different consequences depending on where the review is requested.
Removal, suppression and warning badges are not the same
Platforms describe breaches in different ways, and the practical effect on a business differs:
- Removal. The review is taken down. This is the outcome Tripadvisor describes for incentivised reviews and Yellow Pages describes for suspicious or unsubstantiated reviews.
- Suppression or non-recommendation. The review may remain visible in a separate section but not count towards the rating. Yelp describes moving solicited reviews to 'not recommended' and excluding them from the star rating.
- Public warning. A profile may carry a visible alert. Yelp describes a Compensated Activity Alert when it has evidence of compensation; Tripadvisor describes a red badge when a pattern of suspicious review behaviour is detected.
- Account or profile action. Facebook may disable accounts in continual breach of its Integrity policy; Google warns of penalties and possible removal from Google Business Profile for serious or repeated breaches.
When you audit your process, ask which of these outcomes your current practice could trigger, not just whether a review might be deleted.
| Platform | Asking for reviews | Incentives or payment | Review gating | Self or competitor reviews | Stated consequence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allowed, but ask all customers equally; avoid bulk requests | Prohibited | Prohibited | Prohibited | Content removed; possible penalties or removal from Google Business Profile | |
| Yelp | Businesses should not ask | Prohibited, including incentives to remove a review | Prohibited | Prohibited, including relatives, friends and networking groups | Reviews may be moved to 'not recommended' and excluded from rating; Compensated Activity Alert possible |
| Not specifically banned, but spam and incentivisation rules apply | Prohibited | Not specifically addressed | Prohibited through identity and integrity rules | Accounts in continual breach may be disabled | |
| Tripadvisor | Encouraged; free tools provided | Prohibited | Not specifically addressed | Prohibited, including review vandalism | Reviews removed; red badge; loss of ranking; award disqualification |
| Better Business Bureau | Not specifically addressed | Prohibited | Not specifically addressed | Not specifically addressed | Fake or paid reviews not published |
| Yellow Pages | Not specifically addressed beyond friends and family | Prohibited | Not specifically addressed | Prohibited, including astroturfing | Suspicious reviews removed; rating may fall |
| Angi | Not specifically addressed | Prohibited | Not specifically addressed | Prohibited; first-hand experience required | Reviews may be redacted, deleted or rejected |
This table summarises the rules described in the sections above. Platform policies can change, so check the current published guidelines before running a campaign.
Frequently asked questions
Can I ask customers for reviews?
It depends on the platform. Google allows requests as long as you ask all customers equally and avoid bulk mailouts. Tripadvisor encourages requests and provides free tools. Yelp tells businesses not to ask at all, and its software may not recommend reviews that appear to have been prompted. Facebook does not ban asking outright, but its spam and incentivisation rules still apply.
What is review gating?
Review gating is screening customers by sentiment so that happy ones are sent to a public review platform and unhappy ones are sent to private feedback. Google and Yelp both prohibit it. Yelp specifically bans asking for a review after requesting feedback through a survey or contact form.
Can I offer a discount or free product in exchange for a review?
No, on every platform covered here. Google, Yelp, Facebook, Tripadvisor, BBB, Yellow Pages and Angi all prohibit payment or incentives for reviews. Tripadvisor also bans prize draws, raffles, reduced future rates, upgrades and free use of paid facilities offered to secure a review.
What happens if I break the rules?
Consequences vary. Reviews may be removed, as Tripadvisor and Yellow Pages describe. Yelp may move solicited reviews to 'not recommended' and exclude them from the star rating. A profile may carry a public warning, such as Yelp's Compensated Activity Alert or Tripadvisor's red badge. Facebook may disable accounts in continual breach, and Google warns of penalties and possible removal from Google Business Profile for serious or repeated breaches.
Can employees or family members leave a review?
No. Google prohibits staff posing as customers. Yelp prohibits employees reviewing the business and reviews from relatives, friends or networking groups. Tripadvisor treats reviews from family, friends or employees as 'review boosting'. Angi treats reviews from people who work for the business, shareholders, friends or family as fake. Yellow Pages does not allow requests to friends or family.