Skip to content

Review Gating

Review gating is the practice of asking only customers you expect to be positive to post a public review, while keeping less favourable feedback private.

It is treated as deceptive content under Google's review policies and is also addressed in FTC guidance for marketers. This guide explains how gating works, how it can happen by accident, what the risks are, and how to request reviews in a way that includes every customer.

What is review gating?

Review gating happens when a business invites only customers likely to be happy to leave a Google review, or when it shows only positive reviews on its own pages. A common pattern is to ask for private feedback first, judge whether the response is positive, and then send only the favourable respondents to a public review platform. The result is a skewed set of public reviews that no longer reflects the full customer experience.

Gating is not always deliberate. A receptionist who asks whether a guest enjoyed their stay and then says 'then we'd really appreciate a review' has, in effect, made the request conditional on a positive answer. That small linking word is enough to turn an ordinary request into a gated one.

What does Google say about review gating?

Google lists review gating under 'Deceptive content' in its prohibited and restricted content guidelines, and the policy carries heavy penalties. Businesses that want to build a Google review profile are expected to ask everyone for a review rather than cherry-picking the customers most likely to respond positively. Because gating often happens quietly, many businesses can breach the guidelines without realising it.

Is review gating illegal?

The Consumer Review Fairness Act was introduced to stop businesses from using contracts or legal threats to prevent honest reviews. Review gating sat in a grey area: cultivating only positive reviews through pre-screening, or displaying only the best reviews on a website, was considered unethical and against some platform rules but was not explicitly illegal. That changed when the Federal Trade Commission updated its framework and signalled it would act against brands suspected of review gating.

The FTC's guidance for marketers states that businesses should not ask only those likely to give positive feedback, should not exclude negative reviews, and should not display positive reviews more prominently. In January 2022 the FTC fined the fashion retailer Fashion Nova $4.2 million after finding it selectively displayed only positive reviews, which the FTC says deceives consumers and is illegal.

What are the risks of review gating?

Negative reviews can harm a business's reputation, and some businesses weigh that risk against the chance of being caught gating. The calculation is flawed. Beyond non-compliance with review-site rules and the FTC framework, responding to negative reviews can be beneficial: it shows a commitment to customer care and signals to other reviewers that their feedback matters. Negative reviews also reveal where products or services need improvement.

If gating is detected, the consequences can include an FTC fine and action by review platforms, such as removing reviews or flagging suspicious activity to viewers.

How should local businesses request reviews?

The safest approach is to ask every customer for a review, regardless of what they are likely to say. A two-step process can still work: send a feedback request that does not mention reviews, then follow up with a review request to everyone, including customers who gave negative feedback. The key is that the review invitation is not conditional on a positive answer.

Use the checklist below to test a review-request workflow before it goes live.

Review-request compliance checklist

  • Every customer who completes a transaction receives the same review invitation.
  • The invitation does not depend on a prior satisfaction answer.
  • Private feedback is not used to decide who is asked for a public review.
  • Negative reviews are not hidden, excluded, or displayed less prominently than positive ones.
  • Review requests avoid wording such as 'since you enjoyed it' or 'then please leave a review'.
  • The same rules apply to email campaigns, SMS, and in-person requests.
  • A named person checks the workflow against Google's guidelines and FTC guidance before launch.

Worked example: the hotel reception desk

A receptionist asks a departing guest, 'Have you enjoyed your stay with us this weekend?' The guest says yes. The receptionist replies, 'Then we'd really appreciate it if you could leave us a review on Google.' The word 'then' makes the review request sound conditional on the positive answer. A neutral version would ask every departing guest, regardless of their answer, whether they would like to leave a review. The difference is not the friendliness of the request but whether the invitation is offered to everyone on the same terms.

Frequently asked questions

What counts as review gating?

Asking only customers you expect to be positive to leave a public review, or showing only positive reviews on your own pages, counts as review gating. It also includes using private feedback to filter who receives a public review request.

Can review gating happen by accident?

Yes. A request that links a review invitation to a previous positive answer, such as 'since you enjoyed your stay, please leave a review', can amount to gating even when no one intended to filter customers.

What penalties can review gating attract?

The FTC can issue fines, and review platforms such as Google can remove reviews or flag suspicious activity. Google may remove all reviews on a profile, not only the ones it suspects were gated.

How do I ask for reviews without gating?

Ask every customer for a review on the same terms. If you collect private feedback first, follow up with a review request to everyone, including customers who gave negative feedback.