Reviews and the law: a US business compliance guide
Online reviews can shape whether a customer picks you, but the rules around them are not just platform etiquette.
US federal and state law now covers how reviews are bought, displayed, written and answered. This guide maps the main obligations, shows where platform terms are stricter than the law, and gives a calm escalation path when a review looks illegal. It is general information, not legal advice; consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
Quick map of the laws that touch reviews
The legal landscape is layered. The FTC Final Rule on Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (2024) is the broadest recent federal instrument, but it sits alongside older state and federal rules. The legal directory table below summarises which law affects which party and what behaviour it targets. Use it as a starting map, not a substitute for advice on your facts.
Platform rules vs the law: a first decision check
Before treating a review problem as a legal one, separate two questions. First, does the conduct break the review platform's own terms? Second, does it break a law? A practice can be lawful yet still get you banned from a platform. Incentivising reviews is the clearest example: there is no blanket statutory ban on unconditional incentives, but platforms including Yelp are firmly against them. Signing up to a platform usually means accepting its terms, so breaching them can raise a contract issue even where no statute is broken. Run this check before you act:
- Is the review itself false in a factual way, or is it opinion?
- Did your business offer a reward tied to positive sentiment?
- Is a review written by someone connected to the business without disclosure?
- Does your website display reviews in a way that misleads about the whole picture?
- Have you threatened a reviewer, physically or legally?
If any answer points to a legal issue, move to the escalation steps later in this guide. If it is only a platform-rule issue, use the platform's reporting process.
The FTC Final Rule: what it actually bans
Announced in October 2024, the Final Rule is formally 16 CFR Part 465: Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials. It targets knowing violators and gives regulators a direct fining route that did not exist in the same form before. It does not replace earlier laws or cover every review issue; it strengthens the enforcement toolkit.
Key prohibitions:
- Fake reviews and testimonials written by someone with no real experience of the business, or who misrepresents that experience. This includes AI-generated fakes, coordinated fake-review attacks and testimonials falsely attributed to celebrities.
- Buying or selling fake reviews where the business knew or should have known they were false.
- Incentives conditional on a positive or negative review, whether the condition is explicit or implied.
- Insider reviews from managers, officers or others with a vague link to the company, and undisclosed reviews from employees or immediate family.
- Review suppression: threatening or intimidating reviewers to prevent or remove negative reviews, including legal threats.
- Misrepresenting displayed reviews as representing all or most submissions when negative ones have been hidden.
- Passing off a company-controlled website as an independent review source.
- Buying or selling fake social media influence indicators such as followers or views, where the buyer knew or should have known they were fake.
The penalty exposure is civil, not criminal: up to $51,744 per violation, or per day for ongoing violations, according to the 2024 inflation-adjusted figure. The FTC has published the full 163-page ruling for those who need the detail.
Worked example: suppression versus honest display
Two captured cases show the line. Fashion Nova was fined after hiding thousands of reviews rated below four stars; that pattern of hiding negative feedback was treated as deceptive review practice and would be a clear breach under the Final Rule. By contrast, a business does not have to put its worst review on the homepage. The test is whether the display misleads a consumer into thinking the shown reviews represent all or most submissions. A simple rule: if you claim a perfect five-star rating on Google and it is not true, you are exposed. If you show a representative sample and label it honestly, you are on safer ground.
Other US laws that still apply
The Final Rule is not the whole picture. Four other areas matter for review writers and businesses:
- Defamation (state-based). A statement that injures a third party's reputation can be defamatory if it is a false statement of fact, published to a third person, made with malice or negligence, and causes harm. Opinion such as 'the food was bland' is protected by the First Amendment; a false factual claim such as 'the food was laced with arsenic' can cross the line. Sharing a genuine bad experience is protected; inventing or exaggerating facts to damage a business can lead to court.
- Anti-SLAPP laws (state-based). Strategic lawsuits against public participation have been used to intimidate or silence people through costly, baseless legal action. Anti-SLAPP rules protect people exercising First Amendment rights, including honest opinions and criticism. In one captured case, a Tampa restaurant sued a diner over a one-star Yelp review seeking $50,000; the judge dismissed the suit in February 2025, ruling the comments were opinion, and the listing received a 'Consumer Alert: Questionable Legal Threats' label.
- Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA, 2016). This federal law made it illegal to put clauses in contracts that stop customers posting honest reviews or penalise them for negative feedback, and it tackled requirements to give up intellectual property rights in reviews. It followed Palmer v. KlearGear, where a customer was billed $3,500 after a negative review and successfully sued. Breaking the CRFA can lead to fines.
- Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (1996). This shields websites and review platforms from liability for user-posted content. A business cannot sue Yelp or Google simply for hosting a review; it must pursue the reviewer or use the platform's removal process if the review breaches the site's terms.
Responding to reviews without breaking privacy law
Your reply is also subject to law. Three regimes matter most:
- California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA/CRPA). California privacy law protects consumers' personal information and regulates its use. Other states including Virginia, Connecticut and Utah have their own protections. Avoid disclosing anything that could identify a customer or reveal private information without consent, wherever your customers are.
- HIPAA. For healthcare businesses, HIPAA protects patients' private health information. You cannot share details about a patient or their treatment in a response, even if the patient has already shared them publicly. Avoid appointments, treatments, diagnoses or anything that could identify the patient; even thanking a patient by name can be risky. If a reviewer raises a serious concern, ask them to contact you privately.
- GLBA. Financial services businesses such as banks, credit unions and lenders must protect private personal financial information, including balances and credit history. Do not disclose financial details in a response, even if the review raised them. Encourage private contact instead.
A practical field map for safe replies:
- Customer name: use only if the reviewer used it publicly and even then consider a generic greeting.
- Appointment or treatment details: never include.
- Account, balance or credit information: never include.
- Resolution path: always offer a private channel.
- Public facts already stated by the reviewer: still avoid repeating sensitive categories.
A safe escalation path for a review that looks illegal
A review only crosses into lawbreaking if it includes defamation or involves threats or harassment. Hurtful but lawful reviews are not illegal. If you believe a review is illegal, follow these steps in order:
- Stay calm and assess. Decide whether the review is truly illegal or just negative. Consider the Streisand Effect: an attempt to silence a review can draw more attention to it.
- Document everything. Save screenshots, note the date and time, and capture related correspondence. This evidence matters if you escalate to the platform or to a lawyer.
- Contact the review platform. Yelp, Google and others have procedures for reporting reviews that breach their terms and content guidelines. Provide clear evidence; platforms are often cautious and may act only when the violation is clear-cut.
- Get legal advice. If the review may break the law, consult a defamation lawyer about whether the case has merit. Next steps could include a cease and desist letter or a lawsuit. The bar is high: courts generally will not punish opinions, so action tends to succeed only if you can prove the review is false.
- Keep building genuine reviews. While legal and platform processes run, encourage recent customers to share real experiences so the illegal review has less visibility and less effect on your overall rating.
Staying on the right side of the line
Most honest reviews and responsible responses are perfectly fine. The risks come from buying fakes, suppressing negatives, hiding connections, tying rewards to sentiment, or disclosing private information in replies. The legal landscape is complex and keeps evolving, so treat this guide as a map rather than a substitute for professional advice. When in doubt, a qualified lawyer is the right person to guide you through the specific facts.
| What the law means | Who it affects | Law |
|---|---|---|
| Stops incentivizing positive reviews | Businesses | FTC Final Rule on Consumer Reviews (2024) |
| Stops undisclosed insider reviews | Businesses | FTC Final Rule on Consumer Reviews (2024) |
| Stops misleading review displays on websites | Businesses | FTC Final Rule on Consumer Reviews (2024) |
| Bans the buying or writing of fake reviews | Businesses and consumers | FTC Final Rule on Consumer Reviews (2024) |
| Protects business reputation from false statements made by reviewers | Businesses and consumers | Defamation Laws (state-based) |
| Shields customers from frivolous lawsuits meant to silence reviews | Consumers | Anti-SLAPP Laws (state-based) |
| Protects customers’ rights to post honest reviews without being fined or punished by businesses | Consumers | Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA, 2016) |
| Shields platforms from liability for reviews posted by users | Review platforms | Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act (1996) |
Captured reference dated October 2025. Verify current law and penalties before acting.
| Rule Area | What You Can Do | What You Cannot Do | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Incentivized Reviews | Offer rewards for all reviews, good or bad | Pay or give incentives only for positive reviews | Even implied pressure counts as a violation. And be wary of review site guidelines! |
| Employee / Insider Reviews | Post reviews with clear disclosure of relationship | Pretend to be just a normal customer if you’re actually an insider | Businesses are responsible for monitoring and preventing undisclosed insider reviews |
| Owned Review Websites | Make any link clear on the review platforms you own | Pretend a website posting reviews of your business is nothing to do with you if you’re actually the owner | Make any link clear, even if the reviews are genuine and not written by you |
| Review Suppression | Accept negative feedback and respond professionally | Threaten a reviewer for leaving feedback | If a review shouldn’t be there keep a calm head and go through the proper legal and review platform channels for removal |
| Review Suppression | Give a fair picture of your online reviews on your website | Hide, filter, or misrepresent reviews shown on your website | Must not mislead that displayed reviews represent all submissions |
| Fake Reviews | Ensure all reviews are genuine and based on real experience | Publish or buy fake reviews written by people or AI | AI itself is not banned to help you write legitimate reviews or review responses |
| Social Media Influence | Use authentic follower counts, likes, views | Buy/sell fake followers or engagement | Applies if you knew, or should have known, indicators were fake |
Captured reference dated October 2025. Verify current law and penalties before acting.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to offer a discount for leaving a review?
Only if the reward is not conditional on the review being positive or negative. The FTC Final Rule bans incentives tied to sentiment, including implied pressure. Even where it is lawful, check the platform's own rules: Yelp, for example, is firmly against incentivised reviews.
Can I sue a reviewer for leaving a bad review?
Only in narrow circumstances. A genuine bad experience or an opinion such as 'the food was bland' is protected. A false statement of fact, published to others, made with malice or negligence and causing reputational harm may be defamatory. Anti-SLAPP laws in many states also protect reviewers from baseless suits meant to silence them. Get legal advice before acting.
Can I remove a negative review from Google or Yelp?
You cannot sue the platform simply for hosting it, because Section 230 shields platforms from liability for user content. You can report the review if it breaches the platform's terms, and you can pursue the reviewer directly if the review is defamatory. Platforms are often cautious and may act only on clear-cut violations.
What should a healthcare business say in a review response?
Avoid confirming that the person is a patient, and do not mention appointments, treatments, diagnoses or anything that could identify them. Even using a patient's name can be risky under HIPAA. Thank the reviewer generically and invite them to contact you privately to resolve the concern.
Does the FTC Final Rule replace older review laws?
No. It strengthens the enforcement toolkit but does not replace defamation law, anti-SLAPP rules, the Consumer Review Fairness Act or Section 230. Those continue to apply alongside it.