Skip to content

Local Directory Traffic in 2013: What the 22% Decline Means for Citations

Building and cleaning local citations remains a standard part of local search work, but the directories that host those citations are not a stable audience pool.

A 2013 study of 40 large US directories and internet yellow pages (IYPs) tracked monthly visitor estimates and found that aggregated traffic fell from 137 million in January to 107 million in December. This guide restates the study's findings, separates the annual trend from the December uptick, and turns the evidence into a practical way to judge directory value today.

What the 2013 study measured

The study compared estimated US traffic to 40 of the largest and best-known directories and IYPs over January to December 2013. Figures came from Quantcast. Some sites had implemented Quantcast Measurement and were officially tracked; for others the visitor numbers were estimates. Quantcast describes its method as estimating the number of people accessing a website from online and mobile web in aggregate.

Two caveats matter when reading the numbers. First, because some figures are estimates, individual site totals should be treated as directional rather than exact. Second, Yelp.com data in Quantcast was only available from August to December 2013, so Yelp was removed from charts where its partial-year data would distort a 12-month trend.

The study's purpose was to calculate total traffic across the top 40 sites, compare visitor numbers between them, and identify macro trends. The authors cross-referenced those trends with Google algorithm updates to see whether the two moved together. That cross-reference is a correlation exercise, not proof that any single update caused a specific site's change.

The Big 12 directory group

From the 40 sites, the study selected a sub-group of the most prominent directories, called the Big 12. These were the sites the authors judged most relevant to search marketers. The group is listed in the directory table below.

The Big 12 were analysed separately for average monthly traffic, month-by-month movement and annual change. That separation is useful because the aggregate trend and the experience of individual brands can point in different directions.

Aggregated traffic: the 22% annual decline

Across the top 40 directories and IYPs, estimated aggregated traffic fell 22% over 2013, from 137 million visitors per month in January to 107 million in December. That is a loss of about 30 million monthly visits across the group.

The decline was not evenly spread. January to February saw an 11% fall, and April to May brought a further 13% drop. December, by contrast, showed a 6% increase from November. The December uptick had a single dominant cause: Whitepages.com added roughly 8 million users month on month. Remove Whitepages from the calculation and overall industry traffic fell 2% in December.

Yelp was excluded from the aggregate chart because of limited data. From August to December, Yelp averaged about 83 million visits per month, more than double any other directory in the study. That figure supports a useful distinction: directories as a category were not simply abandoned by users. A large, loyal audience can cushion a site against search-driven volatility.

Month-to-month movement and the Google update timeline

The study overlaid a Google algorithm update timeline, borrowed from Moz, on the monthly traffic chart. The months with the largest swings were January to February and April to May. The updates highlighted around those periods were:

  • January: Panda #24 on 22 January 2013, affecting 1.2% of queries.
  • May: the Phantom update on 9 May, an unconfirmed change widely discussed by webmasters; the Domain Crowding update on 21 May, aimed at limiting multiple consecutive results from the same root domain; and Penguin 2.0 (the fourth Penguin update) on 22 May.
  • August: Hummingbird on 20 August, a core algorithm change.
  • October: Penguin 2.1 (the fifth Penguin update) on 4 October, described as a moderate update.
  • December: an unnamed period of high activity around 17 December with no confirmed update.

These were not the only updates in the year. They are highlighted because they coincided with visible changes in directory traffic. The study is careful to present this as correlation. For example, traffic began falling in September, before Penguin 2.1 in October, which suggests Penguin 2.1 was not the main driver of the autumn and winter trend.

A separate Moz analysis of the Big 20 sub-domains the day after Penguin 2.0 found Yelp was the largest day-over-day loser at -8.11%. The study also notes Yellowpages.com lost 4.37% in the same period.

Big 12 traffic averages and the Local.com example

Average monthly traffic across the Big 12 was about 15 million visits. Yelp averaged 83 million visits per month from August to December. The next highest averages were Whitepages at 32 million, Mapquest at 20 million, Yellowpages at 18 million and Local.com at 11 million. Three of the bigger sites averaged fewer than 3 million visits per month: Citysearch.com at 2.8 million, Dexknows.com at 1 million and Insiderpages at 500,000.

Local.com is a useful example of why monthly data matters. It had 14.2 million visitors in April, falling to 11 million in May, 8.3 million in June and 7.9 million in July. A gradual recovery began in August and reached 12.9 million visitors in December. Despite that turbulent path, Local.com ended 2013 with more monthly traffic than it started with.

How to use this evidence when choosing directories

The 2013 figures are a dated reference, not a current ranking of directory value. Treat them as a historical baseline and check present-day traffic, category fit and citation consistency before committing budget.

A practical decision checklist:

  1. Does the directory serve your category and geography? A high-traffic general directory is not automatically useful for a niche service.
  2. Is the listing information accurate and consistent with your other citations? Fixing wrong data is usually the first task.
  3. Does the site still attract a plausible audience? The 2013 study shows how quickly directory traffic can move, so verify current figures rather than relying on old averages.
  4. Is the site's own search visibility stable? Directories that rank for local terms can send referral traffic even if their overall visitor count is falling.
  5. Is the cost proportionate to the likely referral value? A large directory with a weak category match may deliver less than a smaller, better-targeted one.

A worked example from the study: Whitepages added about 8 million users between November and December 2013, enough to turn a 2% industry decline into a 6% aggregate increase. If you were judging the whole market from the headline December number alone, you would miss that the gain came from one site. The same logic applies today: check whether a directory's growth is broad or driven by a single outlier.

Big 12 directory group
Directory
Yelp.com
Local.com
Angieslist.com
Whitepages.com
Manta.com
Citysearch.com
Mapquest.com
Superpages.com
Dexknows.com
Yellowpages.com
Merchantcircle.com
Insiderpages.com

The Big 12 group was selected by the study authors from the 40 sites as the most prominent directories. Membership reflects 2013 prominence, not current traffic or quality.

Frequently asked questions

Did directory traffic really fall 22% in 2013?

Yes, according to the study's Quantcast-based estimates. Aggregated monthly traffic across the top 40 US directories and IYPs fell from 137 million in January 2013 to 107 million in December 2013, a 22% decline. Some site figures were estimates rather than officially tracked numbers, so the direction and scale are more reliable than any single site's exact total.

Why did December 2013 show a 6% increase?

The increase was driven almost entirely by Whitepages.com, which added about 8 million users month on month. With Whitepages excluded, overall industry traffic fell 2% in December. This is a good example of why an aggregate headline can hide a single-site outlier.

Were the Google updates proven to cause the traffic decline?

No. The study overlaid a Google update timeline on the traffic chart and found that several updates coincided with sharp monthly swings, especially in January to February and April to May. The authors present this as correlation. They also note that traffic began falling in September, before Penguin 2.1 in October, which suggests that update was not the main driver of the autumn trend.

Which directories performed best and worst in 2013?

Salespider.com was the biggest gainer, up 74%. Yelp.com, Whitepages.com, Local.com and Allpages.com were the only other sites to increase traffic. Yellowpages.com, Chamberofcommerce.com and Switchboard.com each fell by more than 20%. Among the Big 12, Superpages.com, Manta.com, Merchantcircle.com, Citysearch.com and Insiderpages.com all declined by more than 50%.

Is this 2013 data still useful for citation planning today?

It is useful as a historical baseline and as a reminder that directory audiences can shift quickly. It is not a current ranking. Before investing in a directory, check its present-day traffic, category fit and citation consistency, and treat the 2013 figures as a dated reference rather than a live benchmark.