US Local Consumer Reviews: What 2010 Survey Respondents Said
This page summarises the US findings from a 2010 online poll about how people find local businesses and use customer reviews when deciding whether to trust or choose one.
It is a historical snapshot, useful for understanding the pattern at the time rather than a description of current behaviour.
Background
The poll was carried out online in September and October 2010 with 2,012 local consumers in the US and UK. This page covers only the US respondents. Five questions explored searching behaviour, review reading, trust, choice and whether online reviews carry the same weight as personal recommendations.
US compared with the UK
US respondents searched online more often and read reviews more often than UK respondents. The reverse was true for acting on what they read: UK respondents were more likely to trust a business after positive reviews and more likely to equate online reviews with personal recommendations.
Finding local businesses online
79% of US respondents had used the internet to find a local business in the previous 12 months. Men were slightly more likely than women to search at least monthly (29% compared with 24%). Searching was much more frequent among younger respondents: 42% of those aged 16-34 searched every month, compared with 19% of those aged 55+. Once people had searched once, they tended to do so more often.
Reading reviews before deciding
71% of US respondents had consulted online customer reviews when judging a local business. Men consulted reviews more regularly than women (23% compared with 20%). By age, the 35-54 group consulted reviews most regularly, with 74% having done so compared with 65% of respondents aged 55+.
How reviews affected trust and choice
Positive reviews changed how businesses were judged. 55% of US respondents said they trusted a local business more after reading positive reviews, and 50% said they were more likely to use one. Men were more likely than women to report increased trust (57% compared with 51%), while women were slightly more likely to report increased likelihood of using the business (51% compared with 49%). Younger respondents were more responsive on both measures: 64% of those aged 16-34 trusted a business more after reading reviews, compared with 52% of those aged 35-54, and 50% of the younger group were more likely to use a business compared with 44% of those aged 55+.
Online reviews compared with personal recommendations
67% of US respondents trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations. That figure was 70% for women and 66% for men. Age made a larger difference: 77% of respondents aged 16-34 trusted online reviews, compared with 61% of those aged 55+.
How to interpret these findings
Use this as a checklist when reading the findings. First, separate searching from trusting: most respondents searched online, but fewer said positive reviews made them more likely to choose a business. Second, check the subgroup: younger respondents consistently searched, trusted and acted on reviews more than older respondents, while the 35-54 group was the most regular review reader. Third, compare countries carefully: higher US searching and review reading did not mean higher US trust or choice. Finally, treat every percentage as belonging to the 2010 US sample, not to present-day consumers.
| Measure | US respondents | UK respondents |
|---|---|---|
| Had consulted online reviews | 71% | 61% |
| Trusted a business more after positive reviews | 55% | 62% |
| Trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations | 67% | 72% |
Historical 2010 survey figures; US and UK samples combined totalled 2,012 consumers.
Frequently asked questions
When was this US survey conducted and who took part?
The poll was run online in September/October 2010 and covered 2,012 local consumers across the US and UK. The figures on this page are for the US portion of that sample.
Did US respondents trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations?
Yes. In the US sample, 67% said they trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations. The share was 70% among women and 66% among men, and 77% among people aged 16-34 compared with 61% among people aged 55+.
How did US and UK responses differ?
US respondents were more likely to search online and read reviews, while UK respondents were more likely to act on positive reviews. For example, 71% of US consumers had consulted online reviews compared with 61% in the UK, but 62% of UK consumers said positive reviews would make them trust a business compared with 55% in the US.