Opening Hours and Local Rankings: What a 50-Location Study Found
Does a business rank better when Google shows it as open?
An external 50-location study tested that question across ten categories, running Local Search Grid reports during and outside listed opening hours. The results show a relationship in some categories, no clear effect in others, and a strong caution against changing hours just to chase positions. This page summarises the captured findings and adds a decision checklist for owners.
What the study tested
Fifty business locations were selected across ten primary categories, five per category, to represent different kinds of searcher intent. Each location was set up in Local Search Grid with a 7 x 7 grid, 500m spacing and ten non-navigational keywords. Grids were only adjusted when automatically placed over large bodies of water, national parks or rural areas.
Reports were run manually twice a day for three days: once outside opening hours and once during opening hours. Exceptions were marked where a business was listed as open 24 hours or had no opening hours associated with its profile.
The ten categories were Coffee Shop, Day Spa, Dentist, Department Store, Electrician, Fast Food Restaurant, HVAC Contractor, Lawyer, Movie Theater and Real Estate Agent.
Overall results: higher averages during open hours
Across the categories, Local Search Grid reports run during opening hours reflected higher average local rankings than reports run outside those hours. The largest movement appeared in Fast Food Restaurant, where rankings improved by 2.4 positions on average during opening hours.
Those averages were steadier than some earlier small-scale tests had suggested. Individual locations and individual keywords could swing more sharply, but averaging across ten keywords produced a more moderate variation. The study also noted that earlier tests had shown dramatic fluctuations for individual businesses and specific keywords, so the category average should not be read as a promise for any single listing.
Open vs closed: coffee shops and dentists
Most coffee shops in the study showed fairly steady results across the three days, with higher local rankings during open hours. Coffee Shop #3 was the exception. The study did not use navigational keywords such as 'coffee shop near me', and it noted that a listing being open does not automatically make it the most helpful result for every searcher.
The dentist results are useful because two locations had different schedules. Dentist #1 was closed on Fridays and Dentist #2 was closed on Wednesdays. Reports were still run at the times they would normally have opened (10am CST for Dentist #1 and 9am EST for Dentist #2). During those daytime windows, when nearby practices were likely open, their rankings dropped much lower than their typical rankings outside normal practice hours.
Businesses set to 'open 24 hours'
Some locations were listed on Google Business Profile as open 24 hours, which allowed a comparison with similar businesses using standard hours. HVAC Contractor #3 stayed steady at 3.5 across the three days, apart from one result averaging 3.6, even though reports were run at 8am and 10am PST. Contractor #4 was also consistent and held an average around 2, so being open 24 hours did not appear to guarantee an advantage.
Real Estate Agent #1 and #3 showed fluctuations across the three days despite being listed as open 24 hours. The study could not explain this from the results alone, but raised the question of whether Google weighs the plausibility of the stated hours. Emergency availability makes sense for some service area businesses; for real estate agents, the study suggested it could look more like an attempt to gain visibility.
What if no opening hours are listed?
Movie theaters often showed no opening hours on their Google Business Profiles, which the study treated as an industry norm given changing film schedules and late-night screenings. Their rankings did not appear to be affected by the presence or absence of opening hours. One possible explanation is that the profiles were set to 'Open with no main hours', which can display as always open. A quick search for three of the five theater names plus 'opening hours' returned an immediate snippet-style result, so it was not clear whether Google was pulling hours from other listing sites.
Electrician #1 had no hours listed and was not set to open 24 hours. Reports were run at 6am HST, when most electricians would be closed, and 8am HST, when they would typically be open. Rankings were lower at the time when searching for an electrician is more common. Electrician #4 followed the pattern seen with HVAC contractors set to open 24 hours and stayed consistent throughout the study.
What Google said about 'openness'
As of 15 December 2023, Google Search Liaison confirmed that Google had long used 'openness' in its local ranking systems and that it had recently become a stronger signal for non-navigational queries. The same statement noted that this could change as Google continued to evaluate its usefulness. That captured statement is dated and may no longer reflect current ranking behaviour.
The study argued there are good reasons to dial the signal back. For searches showing an immediate need, prioritising open businesses makes sense. But people also research restaurants, professional services and healthcare well before they intend to visit or book. A prospective client may compare lawyers, real estate agents or dentists over several stages, at times when those businesses are closed. Google Search Liaison acknowledged those points in a later reply and said the signal might change in various ways.
A decision checklist before changing your hours
Use this checklist to separate a genuine hours update from a ranking experiment.
- Is the change true? Only publish hours your business actually keeps. The study's own guidance was not to change opening hours to anything other than what is true and accurate.
- Does the query show immediate intent? If someone needs a service now, being open is relevant. If they are researching weeks ahead, the case is weaker.
- Is your category one where the study saw movement? Fast food showed the largest average shift; movie theaters showed none.
- Are you a service area business? Electricians and HVAC contractors set to open 24 hours did not show consistent ranking fluctuations in this study.
- Have you checked the trust cost? Incorrect business information can deter customers. The separate Local Business Discovery and Trust Report 2023 found that 62% of consumers would avoid a business with incorrect information.
- Will you measure it? Run location-based rank reports before and after any legitimate change, and compare averages across several keywords rather than one.
Worked example: reading a steady result
Suppose an HVAC contractor is listed as open 24 hours. In this study, HVAC Contractor #3 produced an average of 3.5 on all three days, with one report at 3.6, despite reports being run at 8am and 10am PST. That pattern suggests the open-24 label did not create a large swing for that listing.
Now compare a fast-food restaurant. The category average improved by 2.4 positions during opening hours. A single restaurant in that category might see a larger or smaller shift, and a single keyword might move more than the ten-keyword average. The useful comparison is between the category average and the individual listing's own baseline, not between two different businesses.
Google Business Profile hours states used in the study
The study encountered four practical states for opening hours on Google Business Profile:
- Standard opening hours: the business lists specific days and times. Reports run inside and outside those windows can be compared.
- Open 24 hours: the profile shows the business as always open. The study found this did not necessarily produce higher rankings.
- Open with no main hours: the profile may display as always open without a detailed schedule. The study suggested this might explain the movie theater results.
- No opening hours listed: the profile has no hours associated. Electrician #1 fell into this group and showed lower rankings during a typical search window.
Summary
The original study found a relationship between higher average local rankings and a business being open, but the effect varied by category and was not universal. Fast food showed the clearest average movement. Movie theaters and service area businesses set to open 24 hours did not show the same pattern. Google confirmed that openness had become a stronger signal for non-navigational queries, while leaving room for that to change.
The practical conclusion is narrow: keep your Google Business Profile hours accurate, measure your own rankings over time, and do not rewrite your schedule to chase a signal that may move. The full category charts for all three days are published in the appendix of the original study; reuse of those charts is subject to the original publisher's credit and linking terms.
| Primary Category | Keyword 1 | Keyword 2 | Keyword 3 | Keyword 4 | Keyword 5 | Keyword 6 | Keyword 7 | Keyword 8 | Keyword 9 | Keyword 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coffee Shop | coffee shop | coffee shops | coffee | cafe | coffeehouse | best coffee shop | best cafe | specialty coffee | coffee bar | espresso bar |
| Day Spa | spa | spas | massage spa | day spa | swim spa | spa massage | spa day | spa day packages | couples spa day | spa services |
| Dentist | dentist | dental clinic | dental practice | emergency dentist | family dentist | dental implants | teeth whitening | cosmetic dentist | pediatric dentist | invisalign |
| Department Store | department store | clothing store | retail park | shopping mall | outlet mall | shopping center | home goods store | superstore | outlet store | brand store |
| Electrician | electrician | residential electrician | commercial electrician | local electrician | emergency electrician | licensed electrician | electricians | appliance repair | auto electrician | electrician supply store |
| Fast Food Restaurant | fast food restaurant | fast food restaurants | best fast food restaurant | fast food | american restaurant | places to eat | burger restaurant | casual restaurants | casual dining | quick service restaurant |
| HVAC Contractor | hvac contractors | hvac repair | hvac system | hvac technician | hvac installation | air conditioning repair | air conditioning unit | hvac supply | hvac company | hvac mechanical contractor |
| Lawyer | personal injury attorney | personal injury lawyer | injury attorney | injury lawyer | car accident attorney | family law attorney | real estate attorney | divorce attorney | divorce lawyer | family lawyer |
| Movie Theater | movie theater | movie theater | movies | movie times | cinema | best movie theater | movie schedule | luxury movie theaters | new movie releases in theaters | film theaters |
| Real Estate Agent | real estate agent | realtor | real estate broker | realtor agent | real estate | realtor homes for sale | real estate valuation | commercial real estate agent | property for sale | houses for sale |
The table reproduces the ten non-navigational keywords used in the Local Search Grid reports for each primary category. The study ran reports manually twice a day for three days in December 2023. Keyword lists and rankings reflect that period and should not be treated as current search volumes or current ranking positions.
Frequently asked questions
Does being open 24 hours on Google Business Profile improve local rankings?
Not necessarily. In this study, HVAC Contractor #3 stayed at an average of 3.5 across three days, with one result at 3.6, despite being listed as open 24 hours. Contractor #4 was also consistent and held an average around 2. Real Estate Agent #1 and #3 fluctuated despite the same label. The study concluded that setting hours to open 24 hours does not necessarily give an advantage.
What is the difference between 'open 24 hours' and 'no opening hours listed'?
Open 24 hours means the profile displays the business as always open. No opening hours listed means the profile has no hours associated at all. The study treated these as separate conditions. Electrician #1 had no hours listed and showed lower rankings during a typical search window. Movie theaters often had no hours listed and showed no clear effect. One possible explanation is that some profiles were set to 'Open with no main hours', which can display as always open.
Should I change my opening hours to rank higher?
The study's own guidance was not to change opening hours to anything other than what is true and accurate. It also cited the separate Local Business Discovery and Trust Report 2023, which found that 62% of consumers would avoid a business with incorrect information. The ranking effect varied by category and Google said the signal might change. Accurate hours are the safer choice.
Which business category showed the biggest ranking change?
Fast Food Restaurant showed the largest average movement, with local rankings improving by 2.4 positions during opening hours. Movie theaters showed no apparent effect. The study cautioned that these are category averages across ten keywords, not guarantees for an individual listing.