Skip to content

Why a Real Owner Photo Builds Trust on a Local Business Website

Photos do more than fill space on a local website.

They give visitors a quick sense of who runs the business, what it does, and whether it feels credible. In a survey of more than 1,600 completed responses from a US consumer panel, people compared otherwise identical local business websites that differed only in the homepage image. The clearest winner was a genuine photo of the owner.

Images matter after the basics are clear

Visitors usually check practical details first, such as products, prices, address, phone number and opening hours. Images become more influential after a business passes that first check and someone is deciding whom to contact. At that stage, a face can make the service feel personal rather than anonymous.

What the overall results showed

Across both trade scenarios, a genuine owner image was the strongest trust signal. It was selected by 46% of respondents, compared with 33% for a generic product or office image and 21% for no image. In other words, 79% preferred a site with either a generic or staff photograph over a site with no photograph at all.

Plumbers: personal trust carried the most weight

For a plumbing scenario, 52% chose the owner image and only 16% chose no image. That stronger effect fits a service where a tradesperson may be invited into the home, so personal credibility carries extra weight. A faucet image also performed as a useful generic signal because it immediately confirmed the trade, while premises photos depended heavily on how attractive the building looked.

Accountants: owner photo led, premises quality mattered

For accountants, 40% chose an owner image, 34% chose a generic image and 26% chose no image. The owner still led, but by a smaller margin, which fits a service customers may visit at a business premises rather than invite into their home. A calculator image and premises photos were close as generic options, at 35% and 33% respectively. Premises quality mattered: one professional-looking building image reached 42% trust, while a weaker-looking building image reached 24%.

A practical image checklist for local businesses

Use this order of preference: 1) Add a clear, friendly, genuine photo of the owner or a staff member. 2) If a real person is not available, use an image that instantly identifies the trade, such as tools, a faucet or a calculator. 3) Show premises photos when customers must visit and the building looks professional. 4) Avoid a homepage with no image. 5) Replace obvious clip-art people with real photography wherever possible.

Appendix: scenarios and method

Scenario 1: The Plumber — You return home to find a minor plumbing disaster has flooded your kitchen. You urgently need a plumber but have no telephone number to hand. Searching online, you find local business websites of similar style with subtle differences, and vote for the one you trust most based on its website. Scenario 2: The Accountant — You have limited time to file your tax return for the previous calendar year and need expert help to complete the forms. Needing a local accountant but without a telephone number, you search online and find similar websites, again voting for the most trusted. Each mocked-up site changed only the homepage image, across three types: a genuine photo of the owner, manager or main employee, varied across different owners; a generic product or office photo, such as a tap or faucet for plumbers and a calculator for accountants, plus premises photos of varying quality; and no photo or image, with the same business information shown instead. Options were labelled A, B or C and the order was varied — for example ABC, CBA, ACB and BCA — to avoid choices based on position.

Frequently asked questions

Which type of image inspired the most trust overall?

A genuine photo of the owner or a staff member was the most trusted option overall, chosen by 46% of respondents. Generic images were chosen by 33% and no image by 21%.

Did results differ between plumbers and accountants?

For plumbers, an owner image was chosen by 52% and no image by 16%. For accountants, an owner image was chosen by 40%, a generic image by 34%, and no image by 26%.

Does a real photo beat a stock or clip-art person?

In a head-to-head plumbing test, 64% trusted a real business owner photo more than an obvious clip-art or stock image of a plumber.

What should a local business use if it cannot show the owner?

Show a clear, genuine photo of the owner or staff first. If that is not possible, use a relevant industry image or a strong photo of attractive premises. Avoid leaving the homepage without an image.