Local Link Building Tactics: What Local SEOs Reported Using
Link signals have long been part of local search, and the tactics used to earn them vary widely in perceived legitimacy.
This guide summarises a 2015 poll of 325 local SEO practitioners and adds a practical way to judge each tactic's risk and fit. The figures are a dated reference from April 2015, not a current measurement; check present conditions before acting on them.
What the 2015 poll asked and who answered
The poll asked one question: which tactics do you use to grow backlinks? It drew on 325 respondents who were users of the polling platform, typically SEO agencies and consultants providing local search services. The reported geographic split was 75% US, 13% UK, 6% Canada, 4% Australia and 2% rest of world. All individual responses were anonymous. Because the sample is self-selected and the data is from April 2015, treat the percentages as a historical snapshot rather than a benchmark for today.
The tactics on the ballot
Respondents could choose from a fixed list: content creation or amplification, paid links, blog or forum commenting, infographics, press releases, directories or citation building, guest posting or blogging, broken link building, offline events such as PR or sponsorship, website widgets or free tools, article syndication, and testimonials or interviews. The list matters because it frames what the percentages below actually measure: use of a named tactic, not its effectiveness.
Reported usage at a glance
The headline figures were: 31% used directories or citation building; 22% used content creation or amplification; 9% used press releases; 8% replicated competitor backlinks; 7% used guest blogging; 5% used testimonials or interviews; 5% used blog or forum commenting; 4% paid for links; 2% used offline events; and 1% used broken link building. The remaining listed tactics were on the ballot but did not appear in the published key findings. Read these as reported usage in April 2015, not as a ranking of what works.
Why the spread was narrow
The 2015 analysis argued that several years earlier the chart would have shown a more even spread. It suggested that by 2015, concern about Google's crackdown on unnatural linking was pushing most practitioners toward a handful of safer options. That interpretation is part of the historical record; it is not a claim about current enforcement or current best practice.
Citation building: the dual-benefit tactic
Citation building was the most reported tactic at 31%. A separate 2015 expert citation survey found 55% of experts rate accurate citations as critical to local search ranking, and the 2015 analysis noted that listing a business on important niche, local or national directories can help local ranking even without a link. A citation does not need to include a link; a link is an added bonus. The important distinction is quality: a mention-only listing on a low-ranking directory is not the same risk as a link from a low-quality directory. If you use listings specifically for links, be more selective about where you are listed.
Content marketing: links as a by-product
Content creation or amplification was used by 22%. The 2015 analysis warned against producing content solely to generate links: when links are the only goal, quality slips and industry readers tune out, so the tactic undercuts itself. A strong content strategy can still consider links, but link acquisition should not dictate your topics or the time you invest in them.
Press releases and competitor links
Press releases were used by 9%. Their purpose is to distribute news about a service or product to the press, but the method became associated with spammy link generation. The 2015 analysis described a post-Penguin consensus among internet marketers: stop syndicating releases without a newsworthy reason. Without news, a release issued only for links is likely to be seen as spam. Competitor link replication was used by 8%. It is a simple task with many audit tools available, and the reasoning is that top-ranking competitors tend to have strong backlink profiles with relevant links from authoritative sites. Copying the best and most relevant of those links may help close a gap more quickly.
Guest blogging, paid links and testimonials
Guest blogging was used by 7%. The 2015 analysis drew a line between spammy guest posting and genuine guest blogging: relevant site, good content, and links back kept in proportion. Paid links were used by 4%, and the 2015 position was unambiguous: buying backlinks is a very bad idea. The suggested alternative was to build site authority and create quality content that earns links. Testimonials or interviews were used by 5%. Offering a testimonial can thank a partner and may earn a link, with the added benefit of unique content you wrote yourself. Interviews are more shareable and can build authority for an individual or business, which can lead to further opportunities.
Commenting, broken links and offline events
Blog or forum commenting was used by 5%. It can be a legitimate way to interact, but the 2015 analysis noted a rule of thumb: links that are extremely easy to acquire usually carry less SEO benefit. Contributing to the discussion is the test. Broken link building was used by only 1%, yet the 2015 analysis described it as one of the lowest-risk tactics: find links pointing to redundant pages, then approach the webmaster with a relevant replacement that solves their problem and may earn you a link. Offline events such as PR or sponsorship were used by 2%. For local search, these can be a strong source of links; the 2015 analysis quoted panellist Mary Bowling urging businesses to join clubs, attend networking events, sponsor things and get their name into the community.
A practical checklist for choosing a tactic
Use the dated figures as context, then judge each tactic on its own terms. Ask: (1) Does the tactic require a link to be useful, or does it stand on its own? (2) Is the destination site relevant and of reasonable quality? (3) Would you be comfortable explaining the arrangement to a client? (4) Is the link easy to acquire, and if so, does the content still contribute something? (5) Does the tactic build a relationship that could continue? A tactic that fails questions two and three deserves more scrutiny regardless of how many respondents reported using it.
Worked example: a citation with and without a link
Suppose a local business is listed on two directories. Directory A is a low-ranking general directory and the listing contains only the business name, address and phone number. Directory B is also low-ranking, but the listing includes a followed link to the business site. Under the original guidance, the mention-only listing on Directory A is not the same risk as the linked listing on Directory B. The link changes the assessment. The practical move is to keep the mention-only citation if it supports consistency, and to be more selective about linked listings on low-quality sites.
Frequently asked questions
Are these percentages still current?
No. The figures come from a poll of 325 respondents over one week in April 2015. They are a dated historical reference, not a current measurement of local SEO practice. Check present conditions before using them to plan a campaign.
Does a citation need a link to help local ranking?
No. A citation can consist only of a mention or a form of name, address and phone number. A link is an added bonus. The quality of the directory matters more when a link is present.
Which tactic did the original describe as lowest risk?
Broken link building, despite being used by only 1% of respondents. The 2015 analysis described it as one of the lowest-risk tactics because it solves a problem for the webmaster and can build an ongoing relationship.
Why did the original advise against paid links?
The 2015 position was that buying backlinks is a very bad idea. It recommended building site authority and creating quality content that earns links instead.