Skip to content

Google, Bing and Yahoo: How Much Page-One Space Did Local Businesses Get?

This page reworks a March 2014 comparison of local results on Google, Bing and Yahoo.

Treat every percentage below as dated, unverified captured evidence from that study, not as a description of search results today. The useful lesson is how the balance between listings, local business websites and large websites shifted with the wording of a search.

What was tested and how results were classified

The study asked whether concentrating only on Google was justified, or whether Bing and Yahoo deserved more local SEO effort because they might favour local businesses. It tested three questions: which engine gave local businesses more first-page space, how that split changed by keyword type, and how it changed when a location was added to the query.

The method matters for interpreting the numbers. Over three days in March 2014, the researchers used 42 keywords across seven business categories and three locations of different sizes, creating 126 localised searches. Locations were Phoenix, Albuquerque and Salt Lake City. Google and Bing were set to a specific search location in the browser; Yahoo was anchored through proxy servers because it did not offer the same control.

Results were divided into three buckets. Local results meant listings in Google+, Bing Places or Yahoo Local, usually shown as a pack. Local business sites meant websites owned by a local, multi-location or franchise business. Large websites meant directories, reference sites, government and trade-body pages and similar non-local competitors.

Generic, service and long-tail searches produced different winners

For broad generic searches such as plumber or accountant, Google was the most generous to local businesses in the captured data. It allocated 40% of page-one space to local results and 19% to local business sites. Bing and Yahoo instead gave large websites 65% and 58% respectively. Yahoo was more generous than Bing on local results, which fits the note that Bing powered Yahoo organic results while the two were not identical.

Service searches such as radiator repair or divorce lawyer behaved differently. Fewer local results appeared on all three engines, suggesting weaker local intent. Google still showed the highest share of local results at 32%. Bing showed the highest share of local business sites at 32%, and was the only engine where local businesses collectively received more space than large sites for service terms. The captured analysis put Bing local-business space at 55% for service terms, compared with under 40% for generic terms.

Long-tail searches shifted the balance again. Yahoo and Google showed the most local results at 31% and 28%, while Bing was much more generous to local business websites and large websites lost ground across the board. In other words, the more specific the query, the more the page favoured a business's own site over directories and other large domains.

Location wording and the listing-versus-website distinction

Across keyword types, generic terms delivered the greatest share of local results and long-tail terms the lowest aggregate share. Google and Yahoo gave local results more prominence than Bing overall, with Google narrowly ahead of Yahoo.

For local business websites the pattern reversed. Long-tail terms returned the most local business results on all three engines, and Bing was more generous to those sites than Google or Yahoo. That distinction is the key decision point: a listing pack and a business website are not interchangeable. Generic demand was more likely to surface as a local pack, while specific demand was more likely to surface as a website result.

Adding a location also split the engines. Google returned more local results for searches without a geo-modifier, whereas Bing and Yahoo returned more local results when a geo-modifier was present. For local business websites, all three engines showed more results when a location was included, but Bing was particularly indifferent to whether the modifier was present. The captured explanation for Google was greater confidence in its local product and use of other location signals such as IP address. Even so, the study advised keeping location terms in on-site content, titles, alt text, links and citations, because engines still need to know where a business is located.

Decision checklist for a small business

Use the captured pattern as a planning checklist rather than a current benchmark.

  • For generic head terms, prioritise the local listing first: correct category, services and location signals, because that is where local packs were most prominent. On Google specifically, generic keywords triggered the highest percentage of local results and long-tail keywords the fewest, with more than twice as many local results shown for a generic term as for a long-tail term. Google Places optimisation should therefore focus more on generic and service terms, with correct category selection and a list of services treated as very important.
  • For service terms, build dedicated service pages, because local business websites gained prominence even as local packs shrank.
  • For long-tail terms, cover specific service and location combinations on your own site, because large directories were weakest there and searcher intent was more defined. On Google specifically, long-tail keywords triggered the greatest percentage of local business websites, while generic and service keywords returned the fewest local business sites. This is the mirror image of the Google local-results pattern: where long-tail terms triggered fewest local packs, they triggered most local business websites.
  • Optimise both Google Places and your website so you increase your chances of ranking for the widest mix of terms, rather than relying on one asset alone.
  • Do not drop location language just because Google showed local results without it in 2014; location evidence still helps engines place the business.
  • Check Bing and Yahoo separately for service and long-tail demand, since Bing favoured local business websites in those cases.

A practical example from the study's own keyword set makes the choice concrete. A search for accountant is generic and, in the captured data, was the kind of query most likely to trigger a local pack. A search for tax return is a service query, where a well-built service page had a better chance. A search for personal tax accountant in Phoenix AZ is long-tail plus location, where the business website was the stronger route. Matching the asset to the query type is more useful than treating every local search as the same task.

Frequently asked questions

Which search engine gave more page-one space to local businesses?

In the March 2014 captured study, Google gave the largest share of page-one space to local results across the keyword types tested, narrowly ahead of Yahoo and well ahead of Bing. That is dated evidence, not a current ranking claim.

How did keyword type change the result mix?

Generic terms produced the most local results. Service terms produced fewer local results and more large websites, while long-tail terms produced the most local business websites and the least competition from large sites.

What happened when a location was added to the search?

Google showed more local results when no location term was included, while Bing and Yahoo showed more when a location term was included. All three showed more local business websites for geo-modified terms, with Bing particularly indifferent to the modifier for that result type.