Google My Business Issues: What 310 SEOs Wanted Fixed
In 2018, an external research poll of 310 local SEO professionals and multi-location businesses asked which Google My Business problems they most wanted fixed and which should be tackled first.
The results still read as a useful diagnostic checklist for anyone auditing a Google Business Profile today — not because the platform has stood still, but because several of the same themes keep resurfacing.
What the poll asked
Respondents were asked two questions: which Google My Business issues they would like to see fixed, and which three of those issues should be fixed first. The poll was run among the original publisher's own user base, so the results reflect the views of people already working on local listings rather than a general consumer sample. The original research credited Sterling Sky's Joy Hawkins and Steady Demand's Ben Fisher for guidance on the issues facing GMB users.
The issues most wanted fixed
Reviews dominated the free-choice answers. The largest single complaint was fake reviews, cited by 33% of respondents, with contextless reviews and review spam networks close behind. A second cluster concerned control over listings: which photos appear, removal of duplicate and spammy listings, and the usability of the new Google My Business Agency Dashboard. A third cluster was communication: 21% wanted it easier to contact support, and 11% said responses were inconsistent or inaccurate. Others asked for clearer guidelines and more functionality inside GMB Insights. Every option offered in the poll was selected by at least one respondent, which is why the original research described the result as at least 22 distinct changes users wanted.
What should be fixed first
When asked to prioritise, respondents put verification at the top. A lack of clear guidelines came a very close second, with false and no-content reviews just behind. That ordering is a useful distinction: review problems affect the most people, but verification and guidelines were seen as the root causes that would make the other fixes easier. Among integration requests, Google Analytics was the most wanted, followed by Search Console, G+ and Data Studio.
A reader checklist for auditing a profile
Use the 2018 poll as a structured audit rather than a verdict on today's platform. For each item, note whether the issue still applies to your listing and what evidence you would need to confirm it:
- Reviews: are there reviews that look fake, contextless or part of a spam network? Record the review URL, date and the specific policy you believe is breached.
- Photos: can you control which images appear on the profile, and are any user-uploaded photos misleading?
- Duplicates: search for duplicate or spammy listings for the same business and log each one.
- Agency dashboard: if you manage client listings, note where the dashboard workflow breaks down.
- Support: record the channel used, the response time and whether the answer was consistent with published guidelines.
- Guidelines: check whether the current published guidelines answer your question; if not, that gap is itself the issue to report.
- Insights: note which metrics you need that are not available, and whether date-range filtering is possible.
- Integrations: list which Google services you would connect if the option existed.
- Verification: document each verification attempt and its outcome.
This checklist is a diagnostic aid, not a claim that every 2018 issue persists today.
Worked example: a multi-location business
Imagine a business with twelve locations. Using the poll list, the manager could sort each location into three buckets: review risk (fake or contextless reviews), listing control (duplicate or spammy listings, photo control) and process friction (verification, support, insights). The 2018 respondents said verification should be fixed first, so the manager might start by documenting every verification attempt across the twelve locations, then move to review risk. The value is not in copying the 2018 ranking, but in using it to decide what evidence to gather before contacting support or escalating an issue.
Review fraud, spam networks and contextless reviews
The poll used three related but distinct review complaints. Fake reviews are individual reviews that appear to come from someone who is not a real customer. Review spam networks are coordinated groups of fake reviews or fake profiles. Contextless reviews are reviews that lack enough detail to judge whether the reviewer actually used the business. Keeping these separate matters because the evidence you would collect and the policy you would cite differ for each.
Messages respondents wanted to send
The poll also invited open messages. Themes included asking Google to remember that businesses use the product, not only consumers; frustration that online-only businesses ranked less well than brick-and-mortar businesses in 2018; difficulty replacing a Google 360 photo taken by the Google van; requests for clearer ranking guidance and more consistent rules; and complaints that phone support was hard to reach and that staff knowledge varied. These are respondent views from 2018, not statements of current policy.
Expert comment
Ben Fisher of Steady Demand noted that Google does read user feedback but makes decisions using large data sets and a machine-learning-first approach, so a low-volume issue such as listing name spam may rank below larger problems such as spam networks or location spam. He also pointed to internal reorganisation as a reason plans can be lost, and encouraged users to keep submitting feedback through the Advertiser Community and social channels.
How this compares with 2014
The original research ran a similar study in 2014 asking which Google Places updates users wanted. Duplicate listings ranked first then, verification second, Google Analytics exports eighth and live chat support fourteenth. Four years later, duplicate listings, verification, Analytics exports and support were still being raised, even though Google had added business descriptions, videos, a directions heatmap, Q&A and posts in the intervening period.
Frequently asked questions
When was this poll run?
The results were published on 5 July 2018 and were based on responses from 310 users of the original publisher's local SEO tools. The page was later updated in 2025, but the poll data itself dates from 2018.
Which issue did most respondents want fixed?
Fake reviews were the single most-cited issue, named by 33% of respondents. However, when asked what should be fixed first, respondents put verification at the top, with clear guidelines a very close second.
Are these issues still current?
The poll reflects views captured in 2018. Google My Business has since been renamed Google Business Profile and many features have changed. Treat the list as a diagnostic checklist and check current Google guidance before acting on any specific item.
What is a contextless review?
In the poll, contextless reviews were reviews that lacked enough detail to judge whether the reviewer had actually used the business. They are distinct from fake reviews (which appear to come from non-customers) and from review spam networks (coordinated groups of fake reviews or profiles).