Skip to content

Local Pack vs Organic: How Search Engines Split First-Page Space

This page explains a 2015 comparison of how Google, Bing and Yahoo used first-page space for local businesses.

The study examined 300 search result pages across seven business categories and more than 15 US locations. It looked at three result types: local pack listings, organic results for large websites, and organic results for local business websites. The findings are a dated reference point, not a current ranking guarantee. Search result layouts have changed since the study, so treat the figures as historical evidence and check current conditions before making decisions.

What the study measured

The research asked three questions: which engine gives more first-page space to local businesses, how the split varies by keyword type, and how it varies between searches with and without a location. The team ran searches for seven local business categories: plumber, dentist, hairdresser, accountant, attorney, insurance agent and construction firm. Keywords were grouped into generic terms, service or product terms, and long-tail terms. Each group was tested with and without a location modifier. The charts compared the number of each result type per engine, with 2014 figures shown in brackets for context. Searches were anchored to more than 15 US locations of varying population size, including Phoenix, Albuquerque and Salt Lake City. Google and Bing allowed a browser search-location setting; Yahoo required proxy servers to anchor searches to the tested locations.

Searches without a location modifier

For generic terms such as plumber, accountant or florist, Google showed the most local pack results, averaging six, against Bing's three and Yahoo's four. Large websites still took a substantial share of first-page organic space, between 50% and 65%, which limited room for local business sites. Of the ten organic results Google displayed, only two went to local business websites. Bing and Yahoo showed fewer organic results overall, at eight and nine respectively, and the local-business share was broadly similar. The practical reading is that generic, high-traffic searches offer little organic ranking room for a local business; the local pack is the more realistic route to first-page visibility.

Long-tail terms without a location

Long-tail searches changed the balance. Google showed 50% fewer local pack results than in 2014 for these terms, and Yahoo showed the most local results of the three engines. Google and Bing both displayed more large-website results than in 2014. On the organic side, local businesses gained ground: about 50% more organic places went to local business sites. Long-tail terms are often seen as a fairer contest for smaller businesses because the content can be specific and searcher intent is clearer. Yahoo was the outlier for consistency, showing the same number of local results for long-tail terms as for generic terms, while Google and Bing varied their local offering by search type.

Service and product terms without a location

For service or product searches, Google again showed the most local pack results. Large websites featured prominently, and local business websites received far fewer organic places than in 2014. Across all three engines, large websites took about eight first-page positions while local businesses took about one. The local pack was the clearest opportunity for a local business to appear on page one for these terms; organic visibility was much harder to win.

Restaurants, bars and other leisure businesses

Leisure businesses such as restaurants, bars and cafes behaved differently from functional service businesses. For generic leisure keywords, Google showed its three-result pack while Bing and Yahoo returned five local results. Only Google gave a reasonable amount of organic first-page space to local business websites for these terms; Bing and Yahoo returned mostly large websites such as directories alongside their local results. When a location was added, Bing returned the most local results and local business websites featured more prominently in organic results across the engines. Google's organic results changed less with the location modifier, while Bing and Yahoo shifted more towards local area businesses. The study concluded that Google was the better option for individual leisure businesses seeking both local and organic visibility, while Bing and Yahoo offered more local-pack opportunity.

A practical checklist for reading the split

Use the study as a historical lens, not a current forecast. When planning where to focus, separate two different problems. A local pack absence means the business is not appearing in the map-style block; an organic squeeze-out means large websites are occupying the standard results. The two need different responses. For generic, high-traffic terms, expect the local pack to be the more realistic first-page route and prioritise a complete, consistent local presence. For long-tail terms, organic content specific to the query can be a fairer contest. For service or product terms, check whether the local pack is present at all before investing in organic-only tactics. For leisure businesses, compare the local pack and organic results separately because the engines treat these verticals differently. Always verify the current result layout for the specific query and location.

The 2015 format change

The study was published in July 2015 and later updated to note that Google reduced its local pack from seven results to three. That change is part of the historical record and explains why later result pages look different from the ones analysed. The figures on this page describe the result pages captured during the study period. They are not a statement about how any engine behaves today.

Study dimensions and result categories
DimensionValues used in the study
Business categoriesPlumber, Dentist, Hairdresser, Accountant, Attorney, Insurance Agent, Construction Firm
Keyword typesGeneric, Service/Product, Long-tail
Location modifierWith location vs without location
Result typesLocal pack, Large websites (organic), Local business websites (organic)
Locations testedMore than 15 US locations, including Phoenix AZ (1.5m), Albuquerque NM (560k), Salt Lake City UT (190k)
Search anchoringBrowser search-location setting for Google and Bing; proxy servers for Yahoo

Population figures are estimates from the latest census at the time of the study. The study is a dated reference; current result layouts may differ.

Frequently asked questions

What is a local pack in search results?

A local pack is a block of local business listings shown within a search result page, typically with map-style information. In the 2015 study, the pack appeared on Google, Bing and Yahoo and was counted separately from organic results. Google later reduced its pack from seven results to three.

Which search engine gave local businesses the most first-page space in the study?

For generic terms without a location, Google showed the most local pack results, averaging six, compared with Bing's three and Yahoo's four. For long-tail terms, Yahoo showed the most local results. The pattern varied by keyword type and by whether a location was included.

Do location modifiers change how many local results appear?

In the study, searches that included a location returned more local results overall across the three engines. Local business websites also gained a higher share of organic positions. The strongest effect was for long-tail terms combined with a location, which produced the highest percentage of local business websites in organic results.

Why do large websites dominate organic results?

The study found that large websites such as directories, review sites and national brands took between 50% and 65% of first-page organic space for generic terms. For service and product terms, large websites took about eight positions while local businesses took about one. This left limited organic room for local business websites, making the local pack the more realistic first-page route for many searches.

Are these findings still current?

The figures describe result pages captured during a 2015 study. Search layouts, pack sizes and ranking behaviour have changed since then. Use the findings as a historical reference and check the current result page for your specific query and location before making decisions.