Local Citation Survey: What 22 Experts Said About Citations
Citations have long been treated as a foundation of local SEO, but the 2018 Expert Local Citation Survey asked whether they still deserve the same attention.
This was the fourth edition of the survey, following earlier editions in 2016, 2015 and 2013, and where relevant the report compares findings across those years. Twenty-two local search practitioners shared their views on ranking impact, site choice, data accuracy and how many listings a new business should build. The findings are a dated reference point, not a current ranking guarantee. Use them to structure an audit and compare your own market before committing budget.
Key findings at a glance
The panel was clear that citations still matter, but the emphasis has shifted. Nine in ten experts said accurate citations are important to local search ranking, and none said they were unimportant. At the same time, 59% thought citations had become less important over the previous 12 months. That figure comes two years after the previous edition, and is significantly higher than the 19% who thought the same in 2016. The practical reading is that citations are a baseline requirement rather than a differentiator on their own.
The most valued citation-site factors were industry relevance, local relevance and domain authority. Niche and industry directories were the preferred structured citation type, chosen by 64% of experts. For data accuracy, phone number, city, ZIP code and URL were expected to be exact matches, while suite number was treated as the least critical field.
Are citations still important for local ranking?
The survey found broad agreement that accurate citations support local search ranking, but not that they guarantee visibility. Several contributors described citations as table stakes: a business may need a correct presence on key sites to compete, yet those listings rarely create an advantage in competitive markets on their own. Others pointed to reviews, Knowledge Panel engagement and conventional SEO factors as areas where effort may produce more movement.
Accuracy also has a consumer-facing effect. The Local Citations Trust Report cited in the survey found that 68% of consumers said they would stop using a local business if they found incorrect information on online directories. That figure is a reminder that citation work is not only about rankings: wrong details can cost enquiries directly.
A useful way to read the result is to separate presence from performance. A complete, consistent citation profile removes a potential weakness. It does not by itself outrank a competitor with stronger reviews, links or on-page relevance. That distinction matters when deciding how much of a local SEO budget should go to citation cleanup versus other work.
Quality versus quantity: where to spend effort
Quality won clearly in the panel's view. The recommended approach is to secure the most relevant and authoritative sources first, then consider additional listings only where they serve a real audience. Industry relevance, local relevance and domain authority were the top selection factors. Audience size and the display of user-generated reviews also counted, while NoFollow backlinks, photo and video support, and social-profile links were valued less.
A practical test for any candidate site is whether a customer could plausibly find the business there. A national directory with no local or sector focus may add a data point without adding discovery. A trade association, regional publication or city guide can do both. The panel's preference for niche and industry directories reflects that logic.
Structured and unstructured citations
Structured citations are formal business listings with a defined presentation of name, address and contact details, often marked up so search engines can read the data. Unstructured citations are mentions of the same business details on sites that are not primarily directories, such as news pages, association member lists or blog posts.
The experts favoured niche and industry directories for structured citations: 64% chose them as their most valued source, nearly double the number who did so in the previous survey. National directories were favoured by 18% of experts, fairly static from 2016 but a significant drop in popularity compared with 2015.
For unstructured citations, the experts could choose up to three options, and social media company pages were a new addition to that year's survey. The most favoured sources were industry associations, local government sites, local school or college sites, social media company pages and blog sites. Local government sources gained importance compared with the previous survey, while local blogs were less favoured.
How accurate does NAP+W data need to be?
NAP+W stands for name, address, phone number and website URL. The panel treated phone number as the field most likely to need an exact match, with city, ZIP code and URL also expected to be fully accurate by most respondents. Suite number was the least important element, so minor variation there is unlikely to justify a major cleanup project.
A sensible field-level approach is to lock the core identifiers first: the primary phone number, the city, the ZIP or postal code and the canonical URL. Then review business-name variants and suite formatting. If a name variation cannot be corrected on an important directory, structured data on the business website can record an alternative name or a same-as reference, but that does not replace correcting the listing where possible.
How many citations should a new business build?
There was no real agreement on the number of citations a new business needs. The average figure given by the panel was 35 citations in the first couple of months, with a median range of 21 to 30. That range is best treated as a planning benchmark rather than a target to hit mechanically. The more useful comparison is with established competitors in the same locality and sector.
A worked example: a new independent dental practice in a mid-sized city might start with the major platforms, then add a national health directory, a state or regional dental association, the local chamber of commerce and a city business guide. That could produce a first wave of roughly 20 to 30 listings. The next decision should be based on whether those sources are indexed, accurate and visible to patients, not on reaching an arbitrary total.
A citation workflow the panel would recognise
The strongest practical theme was sequence. The experts recommended cleaning up inaccurate citations before beginning to build new ones, and the majority recommended doing both together rather than treating them as strictly separate phases. Expect the first few months to carry more work than ongoing maintenance. After the core profile is correct, monitoring matters more than volume. The panel also warned that broad distribution networks can update partner sites at different speeds, leaving old and new data visible at the same time.
A workable sequence is: audit existing listings for duplicates and conflicting core fields; correct the major platforms and primary data providers; add the most relevant industry and local sources; verify that key pages are indexed; then set a review cadence. Manual work is slower but gives more control over important listings. Automated distribution can help with reach, but it still needs checking.
Citation decision checklist
Use this checklist before adding another directory or paying for a distribution service.
- Does the site serve the same industry or locality as the business?
- Would a real customer plausibly use the site to find a local provider?
- Is the site indexed and currently active?
- Are the core NAP+W fields already correct on the major platforms?
- Have duplicate or conflicting listings been cleaned up first?
- Is the business name consistent, or is any variation documented?
- Will the listing be monitored after publication?
- Is the expected benefit discovery or link value, and is that realistic for this site?
If most answers are no, the effort is better spent on the existing profile or on other local ranking factors.
| Factor | Panel view |
|---|---|
| Industry relevance | Most important |
| Local relevance | Most important |
| Domain authority | Most important |
| Displays user-generated reviews | Valued |
| Audience size | Valued |
| NoFollow backlinks | Least important |
| Photo and video support | Least important |
| Social profile links | Least important |
Ranking reflects the 2018 survey panel's stated priorities, not a measured ranking-factor study. Check current conditions before relying on it.
| Field | Panel guidance |
|---|---|
| Phone number | Exact match expected by nearly every expert |
| City | Majority expected complete accuracy |
| ZIP code | Majority expected complete accuracy |
| URL | Majority expected complete accuracy |
| Suite number | Least important; minor variation acceptable |
Based on the 2018 expert panel's responses. Field importance may vary by market and platform.
Frequently asked questions
Do citations still matter for local SEO?
The 2018 panel said yes, but with a caveat. Ninety per cent considered accurate citations important to local ranking, while 59% thought they had become less important over the previous year. Treat citations as a baseline requirement and compare their value with reviews, links and on-page work in your own market.
Is citation quality more important than quantity?
The experts favoured quality. Industry relevance, local relevance and domain authority were the top selection factors. A smaller set of relevant, accurate listings is generally preferred over a large number of low-relevance directories.
How many citations should a new business build?
There was no real agreement. The panel's average was 35 in the first couple of months, with a median range of 21 to 30. Use the range as a starting benchmark and compare with established local competitors before expanding.
Which NAP+W fields need to be exact?
Phone number was the field most consistently expected to match exactly. City, ZIP code and URL were also expected to be fully accurate by most experts. Suite number was the least important and tolerates minor variation.
What is the difference between structured and unstructured citations?
A structured citation is a formal business listing with defined name, address and contact details, often using structured markup. An unstructured citation is a mention of the same details on a site that is not primarily a directory, such as a news article, association page or blog post.
Should I clean up existing citations or build new ones first?
The panel recommended correcting inaccurate or duplicate listings before adding new ones, while the majority also recommended doing both together. Cleanup should come first so that new listings are built on consistent data.