Google My Business Expert Survey: What 22 Local SEO Specialists Said
This page summarises a 2020 survey of 22 local SEO professionals about Google My Business (now Google Business Profile).
It covers how effective they judged GMB optimization to be, which listing features and tasks they used, how they split work with clients, and where they wanted Google to improve. The figures are a dated reference from that survey, not a current benchmark.
Key findings at a glance
The panel's headline results were:
- 82% said GMB optimization is "very effective" for improving local pack rankings, and a further 18% said it is "fairly effective".
- 68% believed GMB was more important to local marketing success than it had been a year earlier.
- The five most valued tasks were, in order: growing Google reviews, spam fighting, keeping information up-to-date, responding to Google reviews, and writing Google posts.
- 100% of respondents used Google posts, photos, and business descriptions for client listings.
- The areas most often named for improvement were spam, GMB Insights, and support.
How effective is GMB optimization for local SEO rankings?
The panel drew a sharp line between the local pack and localized organic results. For the local pack, 82% rated GMB optimization as "very effective" and 18% as "fairly effective" — no respondent called it ineffective there.
For localized organic rankings, the picture reversed. 18% of the panel saw GMB as ineffective for organic search, and 45% saw it as not very effective. The survey linked this to Moz's 2018 Local Search Ranking Factors Survey, which estimated that 25% of local pack ranking factors come from GMB signals, compared with 8% of localized organic factors.
The practical takeaway: treat GMB as a local-pack and conversion asset first, and set client expectations that it is not a substitute for broader website SEO.
Worked example. If a client's goal is to appear in the map pack for "plumber near me", the survey evidence supports prioritizing GMB optimization. If the goal is to rank the website in blue-link organic results, the same evidence suggests GMB optimization alone will not carry it — website and link work remain part of the plan.
Is GMB management a priority for clients?
Nearly all of the experts treated GMB optimization and management as an important task for their clients. The survey also noted that GMB acts as a direct point of action for consumers, citing that 64% of consumers use Google My Business to find contact details for local businesses.
Experts described GMB as the first thing many searchers encounter, and as a driver of phone calls and website traffic that can exceed localized organic activity for some businesses.
Which GMB features did the experts use?
Every expert surveyed used business descriptions, photos, and Google posts for client listings. Three-quarters used GMB Insights. Q&A, while not a dashboard feature, was widely used.
The survey compared post usage with a wider industry survey in which 69% of local marketers used posts, suggesting the expert panel was ahead of the broader market at the time. It also cautioned that not every GMB capability suits every business, and recommended testing which features fit the local strategy rather than using features simply because they exist.
Which GMB tasks carried the most value?
When asked to pick up to five tasks, the panel put review growth at the top of the list. Spam fighting came next, followed by keeping listing information current, replying to Google reviews, and publishing Google posts. The ordering matters less than the pattern: the experts treated review management as the clearest priority, with listing accuracy and spam control close behind.
Several experts also pointed to features that were new or changing at the time, such as temporarily closed status and takeout/delivery attributes introduced during the COVID-19 period, and short names for gathering reviews.
Who handles which GMB tasks?
The survey asked experts which tasks they handled themselves, which sat with the client, and which were shared.
Tasks most often handled solely by the expert included tracking local rankings, managing business information and edits, and spam fighting. Clients were more likely to own setting up and responding to messages, and many helped grow and respond to Google reviews.
The survey's guidance was that local marketing works best with client involvement: the business knows its customers and niche, and review and message responses usually need context only the business can provide. Employees should be coached to ask for reviews.
Decision checklist for splitting GMB work
- Does the task need platform or policy knowledge (spam reports, edits, ranking tracking)? Keep it with the specialist.
- Does the task need customer context (replying to reviews, answering messages)? Keep it with the business, with templates and coaching from the specialist.
- Does the task need both (review generation)? Share it: the specialist sets the process, the business asks customers.
- Does the task need buy-in across the company (review culture)? Assign an internal owner.
How has GMB's importance changed?
Two-thirds of the experts said GMB was more important to local marketing success than it had been 12 months earlier, and none saw it losing value. Experts pointed to continued investment by Google, frequent changes and trials, and the platform's role in map pack visibility. Some also described GMB as still a disjointed product, and warned that listings should not be left unmanaged because changes can affect a business quickly.
Which changes had the biggest impact?
Answers varied by expert. Frequently mentioned changes included:
- Review-related updates: short names, replying to reviews on Google Maps for Android, auto-suggested replies, and review carousels.
- The Q&A section, which experts used for answering questions and finding content ideas.
- Service-area limits, which forced changes to how service areas were set up and affected some HVAC and plumbing clients.
- Practitioner listing changes in July 2019.
- The "Related To Carousel", which some experts linked to directory pages competing with the business's own listing.
- Slower support responses and an increase in suspensions, which experts described as stressful for businesses.
- COVID-19 changes, including temporarily closed status and new attributes, alongside a pause in review flow.
Where did the experts want improvement?
Experts could select up to five areas. The most-chosen areas were spam, GMB Insights, support, managing edits, and multi-location management.
Spam was the standout concern, with experts describing fake listings, fake reviews, keyword-stuffed names and slow removal. GMB Insights was seen as needing more granular, reliable data comparable to Search Console or Analytics. Support drew criticism for slow responses and limited guidance, and some experts noted edits stuck in pending status for long periods. Others raised issues specific to service-area businesses, multi-lingual listings, seasonal businesses, and bulk-account control.
What could Google do to make GMB more useful?
Suggestions from the panel included:
- Reduce the ranking weight of keywords in business names to cut spam.
- Strengthen verification, including checks against professional licensing sources.
- Rank service-area businesses by their service area rather than their verification address.
- Improve spam filters and speed up responses to spam reports.
- Lock sensitive fields such as website and phone number so the public cannot suggest changes.
- Stabilise core features before adding new ones, and make Insights data valid and linkable to Analytics or Data Studio.
- Add features for brands and franchises, such as bulk posts, messaging and new-review alerts.
- Add appointment-only hours.
- Provide faster, more consistent support and a clear community contact.
Frequently asked questions
Is GMB optimization effective for local SEO?
In this 2020 survey, all 22 experts rated GMB optimization as at least fairly effective for local pack rankings, with 82% calling it very effective. For localized organic results, most rated it as not very effective or ineffective. Treat the figures as a dated reference.
Which GMB tasks did the experts value most?
The top five were growing Google reviews, spam fighting, keeping information up-to-date, responding to Google reviews, and writing Google posts. Review management was the clearest priority.
What did the experts want Google to improve?
The most-chosen areas were spam, GMB Insights, support, managing edits, and multi-location management. Experts also asked for stronger verification, locked sensitive fields, better bulk controls, and faster support.
Should the agency or the client handle GMB tasks?
The survey found experts usually handled ranking tracking, business information and edits, and spam fighting, while clients often handled messages and helped with reviews. The recommended split is to keep platform-knowledge tasks with the specialist and customer-context tasks with the business, sharing review generation.