Skip to content

Online Reviews by Age, Gender and Income: What the Demographics Show

The same review page can mean different things to different consumers.

This guide breaks down a US-based survey of roughly 1,000 respondents by age, gender and household income, showing where review habits and trust levels diverge. Use it to decide which groups to watch more closely when monitoring reviews, and which groups may need a different prompt before they leave one.

Key takeaways

Women read online reviews more often than men. Men are most suspicious of reviews on Apple Maps and TripAdvisor, while women are most suspicious of reviews on Amazon and Google. Consumers under 44 are the most likely to notice fake reviews. Younger consumers are the most likely to leave a negative review, and older consumers are the most likely to leave a positive one. High-earning consumers are less likely to leave positive reviews than low-earning consumers.

Monitoring reviews across sites

Google is the most-used review site across every age band, but its lead narrows among consumers over 60, where usage is about 7 percentage points lower than in younger groups. Yelp follows a similar pattern: usage rises through the younger and middle age bands (53% of 18–29-year-olds, 55% of 30–44-year-olds and 56% of 45–60-year-olds) before falling to 41% among the over-60s. Apple Maps stands out among 18–29-year-olds at 26%, while Healthgrades and Facebook are used less. The Better Business Bureau shows the opposite trend, climbing from 21% in the youngest group to 40% in the oldest.

How often men and women read reviews

Across the survey, 98% of consumers said they read online reviews when deciding whether to use a local business. Within that group, 79% of women read reviews either always or regularly, compared with 75% of men. The gap is small, but it suggests that women are slightly more routine review readers. Treat this as a prompt to check whether your own review monitoring reflects who is actually reading, not just who is most likely to leave a review.

Fake reviews and site suspicion

Fake reviews take many forms, from review bombing to competitors trying to lower an average star rating. That makes site trust a separate question from site usage. Men were more suspicious than women across the sites measured, with a combined average of 71% versus 61%. Women were most suspicious of Google (83%) and Facebook (71%), while men were most suspicious of Apple Maps (87%) and TripAdvisor (83%). Amazon showed a notable split: 84% of women were suspicious of its reviews, compared with 64% of men.

Suspicion versus actually seeing a fake review

Men reported encountering more fake reviews than women across every site in the survey. But suspicion and exposure do not line up neatly. Although 84% of women were suspicious of Amazon reviews, only 49% had actually seen a fake review there. Although 87% of men were suspicious of Apple Maps reviews, only 6% had encountered one. This gap is worth keeping in mind: a consumer can distrust a platform without having direct evidence of fake reviews on it. Among age groups, 18–44-year-olds were more likely to notice fake reviews on Amazon and Google (58% combined average) than older consumers (38%).

When consumers leave a positive review

Across all age groups, consumers were most likely to leave a positive review when a business went above and beyond. Younger consumers were also more likely to leave a review when they felt a low average star rating was undeserved: 77% of 18–29-year-olds said so, compared with 67% of over-60s. Consumers over 45 were the most likely to help a business by reviewing a negative experience that was turned into a positive one.

Which consumers help or hinder local businesses

Older consumers were more willing to help: 39% said they would only leave a review for a positive experience, and just 4% said they would only leave one for a negative experience. Consumers aged 18–44 were both the least likely to leave only a positive review and the most likely to leave only a negative one. Around 20% of consumers aged 18–60 had not left any review, positive or negative, in the past year. Income adds another layer: consumers earning under $100k were the most likely to leave a positive review, while those earning over $200k were the most likely to leave a review for both positive and negative experiences.

A practical checklist for review monitoring

Use the demographic patterns above as a starting point, not a fixed rule. First, list the review sites your customers actually use, then check whether your monitoring covers the sites where suspicion is highest as well as those where usage is highest. Second, separate review-reading frequency from review-leaving likelihood: a group that reads often may still be unlikely to post. Third, segment your review requests by age band and income band where you have that data, and note which groups respond to service recovery versus exceptional service. Fourth, track suspicion and exposure separately so you do not treat a platform's reputation as proof of fake activity. Finally, review the pattern quarterly rather than assuming it is permanent.

Frequently asked questions

Do older consumers trust online reviews more than younger ones?

In this survey, consumers over 60 were the most trusting group, while those aged 18–44 were the least trusting across the sites measured. That does not mean older consumers ignore reviews; it means they were less likely to report suspicion of them.

Why can a consumer distrust a review site without having seen a fake review there?

Suspicion can come from a site's public reputation, news coverage or general awareness of fake-review problems, rather than from a personal encounter. The survey shows this gap clearly: 84% of women were suspicious of Amazon reviews, but only 49% had seen a fake review there.

Which consumers are most likely to leave a positive review?

Consumers who feel a business went above and beyond are the most likely across all age groups. Older consumers and those earning under $100k were also more likely to leave a positive review than their counterparts.