Skip to content

Local link building: what 20 experts prioritised in 2018

Published 13 February 2018 by Rosie Murphy, Content Marketer, and tagged Citations & Listings and Local SEO, this summary draws on a 20-expert panel surveyed in 2018.

The specialists broadly agreed that links still matter for local rankings, but that relevance, relationships and steady effort matter more than volume. The findings below are dated captured evidence, summarised as a practical checklist for planning local link work.

Priority and effectiveness in 2018

In the 2018 panel, 11% called link building their most important task and 72% called it very important; none rated it less important than other optimisation work. Every panellist said link building was effective for local rankings, with 55% calling it very effective. On importance versus a year earlier, 75% said equally important and 25% said more important, with none saying less important. The source placed this in a dated context: Possum in 2016 increased the importance of the searcher's physical location and cut spam and duplicates, Hawk filtered similar businesses, the Fred update in March 2017 appeared to target low-quality spam links, and the Local Search Ranking Factors Survey showed link signals growing in importance from 2016 to 2017. For 2018, 35% expected acquiring links to become harder, most expected no change, and none expected it to become easier.

Misconceptions to avoid

The clearest misconceptions were treating link building as a one-off job, relying only on citations, judging links only by domain authority, and treating links as secondary to citations and on-page work. A useful distinction is between a link that merely exists and a link that is topically and geographically relevant, from a page people might actually visit, and that can also bring referral traffic or brand visibility. Relevance was repeatedly placed ahead of raw authority: a small community site with few outgoing links could be more useful than a large directory listing.

Sources, traits and anchor text

Most valued sources were local community websites (75%), local news and content sites (70%), and high domain authority sites (60%), followed by industry news and content sites and other local businesses at 45% each. For traits, quality and authority came first, with 90% calling it highly valuable. Diversity of sources was valued by 90%, diversity of anchor text by 90% but fewer called it highly valuable, and quantity was least valued, with 65% calling it valuable or highly valuable. For anchor text, city name, business name and product or service keywords were valued; state name or abbreviation was least valued.

Strategies that earned most support

The strongest strategies were sponsoring local charities, clubs or organisations, requesting links from existing brand mentions, and creating locally focused resources. Also valued were relationships with local businesses and influencers and research-based content. Least valued were commenting, links in social profiles, infographics, webinars and sharing on social media. Blogging sat in the middle, and running competitions was the tactic experts were least sure about. A practical sequence is: audit current and competitor links, list existing relationships and mentions, identify community and local-content opportunities, create a locally useful asset, then use personal outreach to promote it.

Practical checklist

Use this checklist before starting: confirm the business, location and competitor context; check existing links and brand mentions; prioritise locally and topically relevant sources over authority alone; choose a mix of sponsorship, local resources, relationships and research content; keep anchor text natural and varied; use short, personal email and relationship building rather than social requests; and review effort against likely return instead of chasing a fixed monthly quota. Treat the approach as ongoing digital PR and brand building, not a one-time campaign.

Frequently asked questions

How many local links should a business aim to acquire each month?

There is no universal monthly minimum. The panel noted that 5-20 good, relevant links a month would be excellent, but the right number depends on location, competition and industry, and forcing a quota can lower standards.

Which link sources were rated most valuable?

Local community websites were chosen by 75%, local news and content sites by 70%, and high domain authority sites by 60%. Local relevance was treated as more important than authority alone.

Which outreach processes were rated most effective?

Short personal email was selected by 65%, detailed personal email by 60%, and slow-burn relationship building by 55%. Social media outreach was rated far less effective.

Which link traits matter most?

Quality and authority ranked highest, followed by diversity of link sources and diversity of anchor text. Quantity was the least valued trait.