Skip to content

What Different Consumer Groups Want from a Local Business Website

A local business website has to serve several audiences at once.

The same page may be read by a younger shopper checking opening hours on a phone, a mid-life customer comparing prices, and an older visitor looking for a phone number and address. This guide turns a dated consumer survey into a practical planning checklist. The survey was based on a panel of 800 consumers in the United States, with a mix of ages and genders. It is useful as a reference point, not as a current measurement of every market.

What the survey covered and who took part

The survey explored five areas: consumer attitudes towards local business websites, the key information people look for, the website factors that make someone want to use a business, common problems, and preferred contact methods. The age split was 18–34 (44%), 35–54 (34%) and 55+ (22%). The gender split was female (56%) and male (44%). These proportions describe the panel, not the wider population. The findings are presented as a historical reference from the survey period and should be checked against current conditions before being used as a forecast.

How attitudes differ by age

Younger consumers (18–34) were the group most likely to expect a business to have a website and to contact a business because it had one. If a business had no website, or an unattractive one, younger respondents were much less likely to use it. Mid-life consumers (35–54) were less demanding about whether a website existed, but still more likely to make contact when one did. They were the least likely to be put off by an ugly website. Older consumers (55+) were less concerned about whether a business had a website or how good it looked, but they still associated a smart website with credibility.

How attitudes differ by gender

The gender differences were smaller. Female respondents were more likely to contact a business that had a website and more likely to see a website as adding credibility. They were also more expectant about a business having a website, but relatively few were put off by an ugly one. Male respondents were also more likely to make contact when a website existed and gave similar credibility credit, though at a lower rate. They were less insistent that a business must have a website, but more likely to be put off by an ugly one.

The core information every group looks for

Across all age groups, the same core information came out on top: a product or service list, a price list, opening hours, a phone number and a physical address. In practice, visitors are trying to settle four things before they act: whether you are open when they need you, whether you offer what they need, what it will cost, and which channel gets them a reply. That common ground makes the first layer of a local business website straightforward. The differences appear in what each group emphasises beyond that layer. Younger consumers placed more importance on a good-looking website and mobile optimisation. Mid-life consumers were more focused on key business information. Older consumers were especially insistent on product lists, a phone number and a physical address, and placed more importance on fast website speed.

What makes someone want to use a local business

Practical details were the most persuasive across all groups: business details, proximity, and clear address or contact information. Younger consumers were still persuaded by those core features, but less strongly than older consumers. A good-looking website with clear photos was more enticing to this age group than to any other. Mid-life consumers were more influenced by business details and proximity than younger consumers, but less than older consumers. Older consumers were the most influenced by business details, proximity and clear address or contact details. Website videos and social media were almost irrelevant to the 55+ group. Female respondents were far more influenced by proximity and clear address or contact details, and put more trust in online reviews. Male respondents were less influenced by proximity or address details and less enticed by testimonials, but a freephone number or fast website speed could be more influential.

Common problems that deter visitors

Poor-quality content, a missing phone number and missing prices were the main obstacles across the panel. Younger consumers were less deterred by distance but more off-put by a slow or buggy website, and less likely to want to use a business whose site was not mobile-friendly. Mid-life consumers were less put off by those factors than older consumers, but were harsher than younger consumers when a website did not match their requirements. Older consumers were the most deterred by poor-quality content, which was the top off-putting feature for the 55+ group. Female respondents ranked poor-quality content as the number one feature that stopped them using a local business, and to a much larger extent than male respondents. Male respondents were most put off by a missing phone number or missing product prices, and were also discouraged by missing map or address details. Poor-quality content was less off-putting to male respondents.

Preferred contact routes

Telephone contact was the preferred method across all ages and genders. Younger consumers were more in favour of email than older consumers and the most likely age group to use social media to contact a business. They were also the least likely to visit a business in person. Mid-life consumers also favoured telephone and email and were the most likely to use a request-a-callback feature. Older consumers favoured telephone but were also the age group most in favour of visiting the store or premises; they were more likely to visit than to email, and had no interest in contacting a business through social media. Female respondents favoured telephone more than male respondents but were more inclined to email or contact forms. Male respondents still favoured the telephone but were more in favour of visiting the premises than sending an email, and were more favourable towards a request-a-callback feature than female respondents.

A practical checklist for a local business website

Use the survey as a starting point, not a rulebook. The following checklist turns the findings into a review you can run on a real site.

  1. Core information first. Put opening hours, product or service list, price list, phone number and physical address where a visitor can see them without hunting. This was the shared priority across every group.
  1. Check the mobile experience. Younger respondents placed more weight on mobile optimisation and were more likely to abandon a site that was not mobile-friendly.
  1. Test speed. Older respondents placed more importance on fast website speed, and younger respondents were more put off by a slow or buggy site.
  1. Review visual quality. A good-looking site with clear photos mattered more to younger respondents and to male respondents. An ugly site was more off-putting to male respondents than to female respondents.
  1. Make contact routes visible. Telephone was the shared preference. Add email and a callback option for younger and mid-life visitors, and make the address and visit information clear for older visitors.
  1. Treat content quality as a trust issue. Poor-quality content was the top deterrent for older respondents and for female respondents. Check spelling, accuracy and completeness before adding more pages.
  1. Use proximity and reviews where they matter. Female respondents were more influenced by how close a business was and by online reviews. Male respondents were less influenced by proximity but more responsive to a freephone number or fast speed.
  1. Do not assume social media is a universal contact channel. It was almost irrelevant to older respondents as a contact route.

Worked example: a local service business

Imagine a local service business whose website has a strong visual design but hides its phone number in a footer, lists no prices, and loads slowly on a phone. The survey evidence suggests different reactions. Younger visitors may be attracted by the design and photos but deterred by the slow mobile experience. Older visitors may be less concerned with the design but more deterred by the missing phone number and unclear pricing. Male visitors may be more put off by the visual or speed issues, while female visitors may be more influenced by proximity and reviews. The practical response is not a single redesign. It is to make the phone number, address, opening hours, service list and prices visible, improve mobile speed, and then review the visual layer. That sequence addresses the shared core information first and the audience-specific signals second.

Frequently asked questions

What information do consumers most want on a local business website?

Across the survey panel, the shared priorities were a product or service list, a price list, opening hours, a phone number and a physical address. Those five items answer the practical questions visitors bring to a local business site.

How do younger and older consumers differ?

Younger respondents were more likely to expect a website to exist and were more influenced by a good-looking site with clear photos and by mobile optimisation. Older respondents were less concerned with appearance but more focused on core information such as product lists, phone numbers and addresses, and placed more importance on fast website speed. Poor-quality content was the top deterrent for the 55+ group.

Do male and female consumers react differently to local business websites?

The differences were smaller than the age differences. Female respondents were more likely to contact a business with a website and more likely to see a website as adding credibility. Male respondents placed more importance on a good-looking website and supplementary information such as images and accreditations. Female respondents placed more importance on product lists and opening hours and were more influenced by proximity and reviews.

What is the preferred way to contact a local business?

Telephone contact was the preferred method across all ages and genders in the survey. Younger respondents were more open to email and social media, mid-life respondents were the most likely to use a request-a-callback feature, and older respondents were the most likely to prefer visiting the premises in person.

Are these findings still current?

The survey is a dated reference from the period in which it was conducted. Consumer habits and website technology change, so treat the findings as a starting hypothesis and check current conditions, your own analytics and recent customer feedback before making decisions.