Local Business Websites and Google My Business: How Consumers Used Each Channel
When a customer needs a phone number, opening hours or directions, several online sources compete for attention: the business's own site, its Google My Business listing and third-party directories.
This report examines how a panel of US consumers used those sources in 2019, which one they trusted most for accurate contact details, and what website problems would make them choose a different business.
What the 2019 survey measured
An independent panel of 500 US-based consumers was asked about using Google My Business listings, local business websites and business directories to find and contact local businesses. The findings below are a dated reference point from that survey, not a current measurement of consumer behaviour. Recheck present-day conditions before treating any figure as today's norm.
Key findings from the report:
- Consumers trusted contact details on a local business's own website more than details on Google My Business or online directories.
- 64% of consumers had used Google My Business to find contact details for local businesses.
- The Google My Business features consumers were most likely to have used were opening hours, directions and reading reviews.
- Only 8% of consumers never looked at websites when choosing which local business to use.
- 50% of consumers would be deterred from using a local business if contact information on its website was out of date.
Which local business types consumers searched for
Respondents were asked which of 28 industries they had searched for using Google. 87% had used Google to find businesses, and the average respondent recalled local searches across five different industries. Every listed industry had been searched by at least some respondents.
The most commonly searched categories were:
- Restaurants and cafés (56%)
- Grocery stores (37%)
- Clothing stores (34%)
- Hotels and B&Bs (34%)
- Medical practices and healthcare (28%)
Frequently needed services such as restaurants and cafés appeared most often in recall. Less frequently needed categories, including senior living services, in-home care and childcare, were likely to be searched by a smaller share of people.
Where consumers looked for a phone number or address
87% of consumers had looked online for a local business's phone number or address. The channels they recalled using were:
- 64% had used Google My Business listings.
- 49% had visited a local business's own website.
- 23% had visited an online business directory.
Consumers were slightly more likely to find contact details in Google My Business results within search pages than in Maps. Among those who had used the listing in Maps, most had also used it in search results. A notable share of businesses therefore received enquiries from people who never reached the website at all.
Websites still mattered for contact details, with about half of respondents recalling a visit to a business site for that purpose. Directories also remained part of the journey, which means contact data needs to be consistent across all three channel types rather than correct on only one.
Which source consumers trusted for accurate contact details
Asked which source they expected to hold the most accurate and up-to-date contact information, consumers split as follows:
- 56% trusted the local business's own website most.
- 32% trusted Google My Business most.
- 12% trusted directories most.
The website held the largest share of trust, but a substantial group preferred another source. Taken together, 44% of consumers trusted a source other than the business's own website more. For businesses, that means the listing and directory records carry real weight in the customer's judgement of accuracy, not just the site.
A practical way to read the split: a customer who needs a phone number may check the website first, but if the listing shows a different number or the directory record is stale, the mismatch itself becomes a reason to hesitate. Consistency across sources protects the trust the website has earned.
Which Google My Business features consumers used
The most-used Google My Business features, in the order reported, were:
- Checked opening hours
- Found directions
- Read reviews
- Visited the business's website
- Looked at photos of a business
- Booked a hotel room
- Viewed a business's Popular Times
- Booked a table in a restaurant
- Called a business using the 'Call' button
- Left a review
The pattern is that passive uses dominate: checking hours, getting directions and reading reviews were far more common than active contributions such as editing listings, adding photos or answering questions. Some of the people taking active steps may have been familiar with local marketing or encouraged by Google's Local Guides programme.
Many of the most popular actions do not involve direct contact with the business. Someone checking hours or reading reviews may be well into the buying journey before the business knows they exist. That makes complete, current listing information important: hours, images and responses to customers all feed the decision before any call or visit.
How often consumers visited a local business website
Despite the reach of Google My Business, websites remained part of the choosing process:
- 22% of consumers checked websites every time they were deciding on a local business.
- 76% looked at local business websites at least half of the time.
- Only 8% never looked at websites when choosing a business.
A listing carries limited detail compared with a website. Listings serve people who already know the business or are close to a decision, while a website is where a customer can learn about the business's particular offering. The two channels work best as complements: the listing answers immediate questions such as hours and location, and the website carries company details, images and product information that would not fit in a listing. A website also gives a business the chance to rank for relevant searches and to show what distinguishes it from competitors.
Website problems that deterred consumers
Respondents were asked which situations would make them less likely to use a local business. 91% would be put off by at least one of the following:
- Out-of-date contact information
- Poorly written content and typos
- Out-of-date pricing information
- Lack of prices
- Difficult to find in search results
Out-of-date contact information would stop half of consumers from using a local business. That connects directly with the earlier finding that many people visit a website to find a phone number or address: a stale detail blocks the next step in their journey.
Poorly written content also mattered. Local marketing budgets do not always stretch to professional copywriting, but a site still needs to look as professional as the brand it represents. Images played a part too: 34% of consumers looked at photos on Google My Business, and 29% would be deterred if a site had no images. Photos of products, services and the business itself give customers a clearer sense of what to expect.
How consumers preferred to contact a local business
Asked how they preferred to make contact after finding a local business online, consumers ranked the channels as follows:
- Phone call
- Visit the business location
- Message via contact form
- Contact via social media
Calls were the clear preference. In a comparable question asked in 2016, 41% preferred calls, 20% emails and 19% visiting the business, so the preference for calls had grown by the time of this survey. Because respondents were asked for a single preference, the ranking does not show how often each channel is used in practice, and responsiveness by email or social media was not standard across local businesses.
A caller is likely to be interested already, so the call is a chance to answer questions, show the business's personality and provide the kind of service a visitor would receive in person. To make the most of calls, the report suggested that local businesses should:
- Keep phone numbers correct and consistent across the website and other local listings.
- Staff phones adequately, with an answerphone service outside opening hours.
- Consider call tracking numbers to see where calls originate.
- Train staff in customer service and in converting enquiries by phone.
- Explore tools such as Google's CallJoy to free up employees.
A channel-by-channel checklist
Use this checklist to decide what each channel needs to carry, based on the consumer tasks the survey identified.
Website
- Current phone number and address, visible without hunting.
- Prices or clear pricing guidance, kept up to date.
- Professional copy, checked for typos.
- Images of products, services and the business.
- Enough detail to explain what makes the business different.
Google My Business listing
- Opening hours kept current, including holiday changes.
- Directions and location details accurate.
- Reviews read and responded to.
- Photos added and refreshed.
- Questions answered promptly, with common questions added.
Directories
- Name, address and phone number matching the website and listing.
- Records claimed and corrected where possible.
- Stale duplicate entries removed.
Phone handling
- Numbers consistent everywhere.
- Cover for calls outside opening hours.
- Staff ready to answer questions and convert interest.
The common thread is consistency. A customer may check any of these sources in any order, and a mismatch between them is itself a signal about how carefully the business is run.
Frequently asked questions
Do local businesses still need a website if they have a Google My Business listing?
In the 2019 survey, only 8% of consumers said they never looked at websites when choosing a local business, and 76% looked at them at least half of the time. A listing answers immediate questions such as hours and directions, but a website carries the detail a listing cannot hold: products, services, company information and images. The two channels worked best together rather than as substitutes.
Which source did consumers trust most for accurate contact information?
56% expected the local business's own website to have the most accurate contact details, 32% trusted Google My Business and 12% trusted directories. That left 44% trusting a source other than the website, which is why contact data needs to match across all three.
What is the difference between passive and active Google My Business use?
Passive use covers actions such as checking opening hours, getting directions and reading reviews. Active use covers contributing actions such as editing listings, adding photos or answering questions. In the survey, passive uses were far more common. A business should therefore treat the basic listing information as the priority, because that is what most customers actually look at.
How did consumers prefer to contact a local business?
Phone calls came first, followed by email, visiting the location, contact forms and social media. The preference for calls had grown since a comparable 2016 question, where 41% preferred calls. Because respondents gave a single preference, the ranking shows preference rather than actual channel volume.