Local Consumer Review Survey 2010: How Consumers Used Online Reviews
This page explains the findings of a 2010 survey of 2,012 online consumers in the United States (1,138) and the United Kingdom (874).
Fieldwork ran from 30 September to 10 October 2010. The figures below are the combined US and UK results for five of the ten questions asked, split by age and gender. They are a historical reference point, not a description of current consumer behaviour; review platforms, search products and local discovery habits have changed substantially since 2010.
Why the survey was run
The survey set out to answer three practical questions about local consumer behaviour: how often people consult online reviews of local businesses, how those reviews affect trust and purchase intent, and whether online reviews carry as much weight as personal recommendations. At the time, review content was spreading beyond restaurants and bars into trades, professional services and other local sectors, and local discovery was increasingly mediated by social directories, local-social apps and local search services. The survey was designed to put numbers behind those shifts rather than rely on anecdote.
Sample and method
The poll covered 2,012 online consumers: 1,138 in the US and 874 in the UK. Fieldwork took place between 30 September and 10 October 2010. Ten questions were asked in total; this part reports five of them, with results broken out by age and gender to surface demographic differences. The headline figures on this page are the aggregated US and UK results. Country-specific breakdowns were published separately.
Headline findings at a glance
The survey's own summary highlighted six points: 70% of people had used the internet to find a local business in the previous 12 months; younger consumers used the internet more often for that purpose than older consumers; 67% of local consumers had consulted online customer reviews of local businesses; younger consumers were more influenced by positive reviews than older consumers; female consumers were more likely to choose a local business with positive reviews; and 69% of local consumers trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations. Each of these is unpacked, with its demographic splits, in the question sections below.
Question 1: Using the internet to find a local business
Respondents were asked how many times in the last 12 months they had used the internet to find a local business. Overall, 70% had done so at least once in that period. The gender split showed a gap in non-use: 25% of women had never used the internet to find a local business, compared with 19% of men. Once a consumer had used the internet for this purpose at least once, most went on to use it more frequently. By age, 29% of people aged 55 and over had never used the internet to find a local business, while 11% of people aged 16-34 used it almost every day for that purpose. The pattern was consistent: younger consumers searched more often than older ones.
Question 2: Reading reviews to judge a local business
Respondents were asked whether they had ever read online customer reviews to decide whether a local business was a good business. Overall, 67% had. The gender difference was small: 68% of women and 66% of men. The age difference was larger: 60% of consumers aged 55 and over had consulted online reviews of local businesses, compared with 68% of consumers aged 16-34. In other words, review-reading was already a majority activity across age groups in 2010, but it was more established among younger respondents.
Question 3: Effect of reviews on opinion of a business
Respondents were asked how online customer reviews affected their opinion of a local business. Overall, 58% said they trusted a local business more after reading positive online reviews. Men were slightly more likely than women to say this (59% versus 57%), but men were also more likely to ignore reviews. By age, 67% of people aged 16-34 said they trusted a local business more after reading positive customer reviews, compared with 53% of people aged 35-54. This question measures a shift in trust after positive reviews; it does not measure whether a review caused a purchase.
Question 4: Influence of reviews on choosing a business
Respondents were asked how online customer reviews influenced their decision to use or select a local business. Female consumers were more likely to say they would select a local business with positive reviews: 52% of women said they were more likely to use a local business after reading positive customer reviews. Among men, 39% said they chose local businesses based on price and location rather than online customer reviews. By age, 51% of people aged 16-34 said they were more likely to use a local business after reading positive customer reviews, compared with 46% of people aged 55 and over. This is a stated likelihood, not an observed purchase.
Question 5: Reviews versus personal recommendations
Respondents were asked whether they trusted online customer reviews as much as personal recommendations. Overall, 69% said they did. Women were slightly more trusting than men: 71% versus 68%. The survey summary treats this as a headline result: a large majority of local consumers in 2010 placed online reviews on a par with recommendations from people they know. That is a strong claim about stated trust, and it should be read alongside the sample and fieldwork date rather than as a permanent property of consumer behaviour.
How to read these figures
Use this checklist before quoting any number from the survey. First, check the sample: 2,012 online consumers, 1,138 in the US and 874 in the UK, polled between 30 September and 10 October 2010. Second, check whether the figure is aggregated or country-specific; the headline numbers here are combined US and UK results. Third, check whether the question asked about trust, opinion or stated likelihood to choose; those are different outcomes. Fourth, check the demographic split; a gap between age or gender groups is a difference in stated response, not proof of cause. Fifth, treat the figures as a 2010 reference point and look for more recent evidence before drawing conclusions about today's consumers.
Worked example: reading the age gap in trust
Take the trust question. Among people aged 16-34, 67% said they trusted a local business more after reading positive customer reviews; among people aged 35-54, the figure was 53%. The difference is 14 percentage points. A careful reading says: in this 2010 sample, younger respondents were more likely to report a trust increase after positive reviews than middle-aged respondents. It does not say that positive reviews cause younger people to buy, that the gap persists today, or that the same gap would appear in a different sample. The same discipline applies to the 51% versus 46% gap on stated likelihood to choose a business, and to the 71% versus 68% gender gap on trusting reviews as much as recommendations.
Survey question map
The five reported questions map to distinct reader questions. Question 1 asks how often people use the internet to find a local business. Question 2 asks whether they have read reviews to judge a local business. Question 3 asks how reviews affect their opinion of a business. Question 4 asks how reviews influence their decision to use or select a business. Question 5 asks whether they trust reviews as much as personal recommendations. Each question is reported with a gender split and an age split, so the same headline number can sit alongside different demographic patterns.
Limits and caveats
The survey reports stated attitudes and stated behaviour from an online panel in two countries in late 2010. It does not observe actual purchases, and it does not test whether reviews changed decisions. The demographic splits are descriptive. The survey was run before many current review and local-search products existed, so the platform landscape described in the background section is historical. Where a figure is used in a current argument, it should be labelled with its 2010 date and checked against newer evidence.
Frequently asked questions
When was the survey carried out and who took part?
Fieldwork ran from 30 September to 10 October 2010 and covered 2,012 online consumers: 1,138 in the US and 874 in the UK. The headline figures on this page are the combined US and UK results.
What is the difference between Question 3 and Question 4?
Question 3 asked how reviews affected a respondent's opinion of a local business, and 58% said they trusted a business more after positive reviews. Question 4 asked how reviews influenced the decision to use or select a business, and the answers were stated likelihoods, such as 52% of women saying they were more likely to use a business after positive reviews. Trust and stated choice are related but not the same outcome.
How should the age and gender splits be interpreted?
They describe differences in stated responses within this 2010 sample. For example, 67% of respondents aged 16-34 said they trusted a business more after positive reviews, compared with 53% of those aged 35-54. That is a 14-point difference in reported trust, not evidence that reviews cause purchases or that the gap holds in other samples or later years.
Can these figures be used to describe consumer behaviour today?
No. They are a dated reference point from 2010. Review platforms, local search products and consumer habits have changed since then. Use the figures with their date attached, and look for more recent evidence before making claims about current consumers.