Skip to content

Do local businesses still need a website?

Search results now let people call, book, browse menus and read answers without opening a business site. That makes the question fair — but it does not make a website redundant. Use this guide to judge what a profile can do, what it cannot, and what your own site should cover.

Why the website question is being asked

Two years before this argument became common, the answer would have been an unqualified yes. The shift since then is not that customers stopped wanting information — it is that Google increasingly supplies that information inside search results themselves. Hours, location, booking links, reviews, questions and answers, posts, menus and service lists can all appear without a click through to a business-owned page.

That change explains the doubt. A 2017 CNBC/SurveyMonkey small-business survey reported that 45% of small businesses had no website, and among those with one, only 37% used it to share news with customers and potential customers. Alternatives such as a Yelp listing or a Facebook page were already being used in place of a site.

Consumer behaviour also moved. Research cited for 2019 found 82% of consumers read online reviews for local businesses, yet not all of them then visited a website. The share visiting after positive reviews fell in 2017, recovered in 2018, and fell again in 2019. In the 2017 analysis, visiting a website was still the most common next step at 37%, but 17% went to the business in person — up from 7% in 2016 — and 10% contacted it directly, up from 3%. The suggested explanation was that search results were starting to replace the website for routine information.

Click data pointed the same way. WordStream research reported the median click-through rate for the number one Google ranking was down 37% in the year reported, suggesting fewer searchers were reaching business websites from top positions.

What Google now does inside search results

Google Business Profile — now commonly called Google Business Profile in local search practice — has added features that once required a site visit:

  • Action buttons: a free mobile listing can carry controls such as get directions, message us and call now.
  • Wait times: restaurant listings could show estimated waits, with predefined descriptions such as kosher food or some kosher food, so menu details no longer had to be checked on a website.
  • Action links: links for tasks such as make a reservation or order online can start from the listing.
  • Posts: news and offers can be shared from the listing, a feature introduced in July 2017.
  • Menus and services: bars and restaurants can upload menus, and the feature was later expanded beyond food menus to service lists.
  • Questions and answers: common questions can be shown in the listing, reducing the need to ask by phone or browse a site.

These features are useful for quick, in-the-moment tasks. They are not the same as owning a full, controllable web presence. Directory listings, social pages and review sites can act as proxy home pages, and third-party platforms may combine booking, commerce and reviews. That convenience is exactly why they can draw traffic away from an individual site — and why relying on them alone leaves the business dependent on platforms it does not control.

Six reasons to keep a website anyway

  1. Local SEO foundation — Ranking in local pack listings without a website is described as far more difficult. With mobile and voice search growing, a site gives an agency or in-house team the pages, signals and content needed to support visibility and footfall.
  1. Consumer expectation — Even when people can act from search results, many still expect a business to have a site. The Local Search Association Digital Consumer Study cited found 63% of consumers used the website to find a local business or interact with it.
  1. A shareable link — A business URL is more credible and more useful to share than a profile link. It can be sent in a pitch, a referral or a message, and can point people to images, video, price lists and products from one place. A pet store or nail salon, for example, can use one link for its full range.
  1. Content for relevance — A website is the home for content that clarifies services, locations and expertise. That content supports relevance and helps earn the links that improve visibility.
  1. Brand control — A site works as a virtual office or storefront. It is owned media, so the business controls presentation, authority, values and culture in a way a profile or social page does not.
  1. Customer service — Detailed replies are often impractical on social media. A site can host an up-to-date FAQ or service contact page, and a single link can direct each customer to the right answer.

Decision checklist: profile, website, or both?

Treat the profile as the fast lane and the website as the owned base. The profile handles immediate actions; the site handles depth, proof and control.

Use this checklist before deciding to drop or delay a site:

  • Can customers find your full services, prices, images and products from one owned link?
  • Do you have pages that support local relevance for each service or location?
  • Can you publish content and earn links to pages you control?
  • Does the site show your brand, values and expertise clearly?
  • Is there an FAQ or service page you can link to instead of answering every query in social comments?
  • Would a customer who finds you on a directory, review site or social page still have a trusted place to verify you?

If several answers are no, a profile alone is not covering the job. If the site exists but is thin, the priority is not necessarily a redesign — it may be clearer service pages, current FAQs, useful images and price information, and content that answers the questions customers ask before they visit.

Final thoughts

Google Business Profile, directory listings and social pages are valuable assets. They give customers quick access to essential details and can drive calls, directions and bookings. They should complement a website, not replace it.

A professional website remains a central marketing asset because it supports local SEO, link building, brand building and the expectations customers bring when they check a business out. The practical question is therefore not whether to have one, but what it must do better than a profile: explain, prove and convert in depth, while the profile captures the quick action.