Skip to content

What makes consumers choose a local business?

Consumers rarely pick a local business because it happens to sit at the top of a results page.

Most weigh a small set of practical signals — how close it is, what other customers say, whether the listing looks complete, and whether pricing is clear. This guide turns those signals into a checklist you can apply to your own listing.

Rankings are one input, not the decision

A high position helps a business get seen, but it is not the reason most consumers click. In the survey, only 6% of consumers said they simply clicked the first result. The rest compared a handful of factors before choosing which business to contact or visit. That means a listing can rank well and still lose the customer if the surrounding signals are weak.

What consumers check during research

During the research stage, consumers scan a shortlist of businesses and compare the details visible in search results, maps and listings. The research-stage priority table below shows the full captured ranking of factors, with the percentage of consumers who considered each one. Read it as a dated reference from the survey period and check current conditions before treating any figure as a live benchmark.

Different channels, different expectations

The channel a consumer uses shifts what they notice. Proximity weighs more heavily on Google Search, Google Maps and review or business listing sites, and less on voice search or AI tools. Review sites amplify review signals: nearly half of consumers using those sites looked at review count and star rating. AI-tool users were more likely than average to judge a business by its name and how professional it seemed. The channel comparison table below preserves the full captured breakdown.

Industry changes the weighting

The same factors do not carry equal weight across sectors. Professional services buyers leaned less on proximity and more on review volume, star rating and complete information. Food and drink and health and medical businesses saw proximity rise to the top. Trades and home services placed extra weight on reviews and on clear pricing or deals. Use the sector notes as a prompt to check which factor your own customers are most likely to screen on first.

The red flags that send customers elsewhere

Many consumers look at a business and decide not to make contact. The red-flag table below preserves the full captured list of reasons consumers gave for skipping a business. Negative reviews, unclear pricing and low star ratings lead, but inactivity signals — no reviews, out-of-date reviews, missing information, no photos, an abandoned-looking listing — also appear throughout.

A decision checklist for your own listing

Use this checklist to review a listing the way a consumer would. It is a practical application of the captured factors, not a guarantee of being chosen.

Worked example: a trades listing under review

Suppose a plumbing business appears in a local search. A consumer scans the result and sees a complete address, a 4.6 star rating with 38 reviews, a clear call-out fee and a quote request button. That listing satisfies the research-stage factors (proximity, star rating, review count, complete information, clear pricing) and the decision-stage factors (clear information, best reviews, clear pricing). Now suppose the same business had no photos, reviews from three years ago and no pricing information. The red-flag table shows those inactivity signals would put some consumers off before contact. The difference is not the ranking position; it is the visible evidence of an active, complete business.

Reputation problems versus inactivity problems

The red-flag data separates two kinds of failure. Reputation problems are negative reviews, a low star rating and unclear pricing. Inactivity problems are no reviews, old reviews, missing information, no photos and an abandoned-looking listing. Both cost customers, but they need different fixes: reputation problems need review responses and service improvements, while inactivity problems need a listing refresh and a review-request routine. Treat them as separate workstreams rather than one generic 'improve your listing' task.

Channel-specific research factors
FactorGoogle SearchGoogle MapsSocial mediaAI toolsOther search enginesVoice searchReview sites / business listingsApple Maps
How high in the results the business appeared15%18%26%30%25%30%26%24%
The star rating42%42%44%36%42%31%48%38%
The number of reviews41%42%37%37%38%31%49%30%
Photos of the business or its work26%28%32%32%25%26%40%33%
The business name or how professional it sounded15%19%21%27%22%20%24%26%
The address or how nearby it is47%49%41%37%42%33%45%43%
Whether the listing had complete information37%36%30%27%40%30%38%38%
The category or type of service listed25%26%26%28%28%25%33%30%
Whether the listing was an advert11%16%15%17%14%17%22%19%
If there was clear pricing or a deal/offer32%30%35%32%35%29%33%32%
Just clicked the first result5%5%5%5%8%4%3%4%

Dated survey reference; check current conditions.

Frequently asked questions

Do consumers just click the top result?

No. Only 6% of surveyed consumers said they clicked the first result without comparing. Most weighed several factors, with proximity, star rating and review count leading the research-stage list.

Which factor matters most when consumers research a local business?

Proximity was the most common research-stage factor at 44%, followed by star rating at 38% and review count at 37%. Complete information and clear pricing also featured strongly.

What makes consumers choose one business over another at the decision stage?

Clear and complete information (32%), the most or best reviews (30%) and clear pricing or a deal (29%) were the top three decision-stage factors. Proximity and star rating followed at 27% each.

What red flags stop consumers contacting a business?

Negative reviews (33%), unclear pricing (32%) and a low star rating (30%) were the most common reasons. Inactivity signals such as no reviews, out-of-date reviews, missing information and an abandoned-looking listing also appeared.

Does the channel change what consumers care about?

Yes. Proximity weighs more on Google Search, Google Maps and review sites, and less on voice search and AI tools. Review sites amplify review signals, while AI-tool users place more weight on the business name and how professional it seems.

Research-stage factors consumers considered
RankFactor%
1The address or how nearby it is44%
2The star rating38%
3The number of reviews37%
4Whether the listing had complete information34%
5If there was clear pricing or a deal/offer30%
6=Photos of the business or its work24%
6=The category or type of service listed24%
8How high in the results the business appeared16%
9The business name or how professional it sounded14%
10Whether the listing was an advert11%
11Just clicked the first result6%

Dated survey reference; check current conditions.

Google SearchGoogle MapsSocial mediaAI toolsOther search enginesVoice searchReview sites / business listingsApple Maps
How high in the results the business appeared15%18%26%30%25%30%26%24%
The star rating42%42%44%36%42%31%48%38%
The number of reviews41%42%37%37%38%31%49%30%
Photos of the business or its work26%28%32%32%25%26%40%33%
The business name or how professional it sounded15%19%21%27%22%20%24%26%
The address or how nearby it is47%49%41%37%42%33%45%43%
Whether the listing had complete information37%36%30%27%40%30%38%38%
The category or type of service listed25%26%26%28%28%25%33%30%
Whether the listing was an advert11%16%15%17%14%17%22%19%
If there was clear pricing or a deal/offer32%30%35%32%35%29%33%32%
Just clicked the first result5%5%5%5%8%4%3%4%
Decision-stage factors that influenced the chosen business
RankFactor%
1Clear and complete information (hours, address, phone)32%
2The most or best reviews30%
3Clear pricing or a deal/offer29%
4=The closest or able to come to the customer’s home27%
4=The best star rating27%
6A friend or family member had recommended them25%
7=They responded quickly after I made an initial enquiry22%
7=I recognized the business name22%
9They had a professional-looking website (20%)20%
10=They had the best photos18%
10=They appeared first or near the top of the results18%

Dated survey reference; check current conditions.

Red flags that stopped consumers contacting a business
RankFactor%
1Negative reviews33%
2Unclear pricing or no offers32%
3Low star rating30%
4No or few review24%
5Out-of-date reviews21%
6Missing or incorrect information20%
7Couldn’t find a website18%
8=No photos on the listing16%
8=The listing looked abandoned or unclaimed16%
10Didn’t appear high enough in the results13%
11The listing was a paid advert11%

Dated survey reference; check current conditions.