Skip to content

Local Review Sites Compared: Which Platform Grew Fastest?

Local business reviews shape how customers choose where to spend.

This analysis tracks how five major platforms — Google, Facebook, Yelp, TripAdvisor and Foursquare — accumulated new reviews between 2012 and 2017. The figures come from aggregated, anonymised review data for roughly 50,000 US-based businesses. Use the findings as a historical reference point, not a current ranking.

How the comparison was built

The dataset covers approximately 50,000 US-based local businesses across many categories. Review counts were aggregated and anonymised, then compared year on year from 2012 to 2017, with a closer monthly look at July 2016 through July 2017. Five platforms were selected: Google, Facebook, Yelp, Foursquare and TripAdvisor. Four carry listings across all industries; TripAdvisor was included for its prominence in travel and hospitality and to contrast a niche platform with general ones. Foursquare was included because it once held a large body of local review and rating data, even though its business focus later shifted toward location intelligence. Product and general review sites such as Amazon and Trustpilot were excluded because the study concerns local businesses.

Cumulative review growth, 2012–2017

Across the five-year window, Google showed the steepest rise in total review volume. Yelp, Facebook and TripAdvisor also accelerated their accumulation, but none matched Google's pace. Foursquare was the only platform to plateau over the period, consistent with its shift away from consumer review engagement. The pattern suggests that scale and ease of leaving a review matter as much as the size of a platform's existing user base.

Year-on-year growth rates

The table below shows the percentage change in new reviews for each platform against the previous year. Facebook's 2013 figure reflects a very low starting base after reviews were introduced in late 2012. The adapted view flattens that early Facebook spike so the other platforms' trajectories are easier to read.

Average new reviews per business

Total volume tells only part of the story. A platform can accumulate a huge number of reviews overall while the typical business on it gains relatively few. Looking at the average per business separates the two effects.

In 2016, TripAdvisor businesses in the sample gained an average of 47.5 new reviews each — roughly three times the Google average. That reflects TripAdvisor's concentration in travel and hospitality rather than a broad, all-industry footprint. Foursquare recorded the lowest average, peaking at 4.1 new reviews per business and falling to 3.4. Yelp grew steadily to a peak of 11.9 reviews per business in 2016. Facebook's average fell to 7.2 in 2016 from 13.6 in 2013, which may reflect a larger business base rather than declining engagement. Google more than doubled its average, reaching 15.1 new reviews per business in 2016, up from 6.9.

Platform-by-platform notes

Google. Google moved from third place in review volume in 2014 and 2015 to first from 2016 onward. Its mobile location tracking lets it prompt users to review places they have recently visited, and those prompts make it easy to submit a short review with photos straight from a phone. That prompt-driven flow has been part of Google's recommendation heritage since the Hotpot era. Volume leadership did not equal trust leadership, though: the 2017 Local Consumer Review Survey found Google was consumers' third most trusted review site, behind Facebook and Yelp.

Facebook. Facebook's early growth came from a low base after reviews launched in late 2012. The December 2012 Nearby announcement let users share recommendations with friends for the first time, which helps explain the 2013 spike. Later gains were slower but still substantial. Facebook Local, the separate app, had seen limited success: Google Play Store estimates put downloads at 100,000–500,000 in January 2018, far below Yelp's 10–50 million and TripAdvisor's 100–500 million Android users. News feed changes that favour discussion posts could also affect how visible local businesses are, potentially pushing them toward paid advertising or the Facebook Local app.

Yelp. Yelp grew at a steady 55–68% per year before 2017, though its growth rate slowed. 2016 was a difficult year, with the platform scaling back operations outside North America and culling further international expansion plans. In May 2017 its stock dropped 30% after disappointing sales. Yelp also took a firm stance in 2017 against businesses asking for customer reviews; while authenticity matters, actively discouraging requests could mean fewer reviews on Yelp going forward, with businesses potentially shifting their requests to other platforms.

TripAdvisor. TripAdvisor's percentage growth slowed from 115% in 2015 to 82% in 2016 but remained positive, with a strong second quarter in 2017. As a business, 2017 was tumultuous: results fell below analysts' estimates, and the Financial Times reported that TripAdvisor shares had declined 15 per cent that year amid concerns about turning audience growth into revenue growth.

Foursquare. Foursquare's review volume stayed low and its consumer focus shifted toward location data. It still operates two local-social apps that engage local consumers, but there have been predictions it may exit consumer recommendations and instead sell its significant data set. The average consumer reads 10 reviews before trusting a business, so Foursquare's low per-business volume limits how useful it is as a primary review destination.

Choosing where to focus review efforts

Use this checklist to translate the historical trends into a practical starting point. It is not a current ranking — platform policies and user behaviour change.

  • General local services: Prioritise Google, given its sustained lead in total and per-business review growth. Add Facebook for social proof.
  • Hospitality and travel: Include TripAdvisor alongside Google. Its per-business review density is high in that sector.
  • Food, retail and services with a social audience: Consider Yelp where it is active in your market, but check current local adoption and any active request policies.
  • Location-heavy or check-in-driven audiences: Foursquare may still matter for discovery, but expect fewer reviews per business.
  • All businesses: Track reviews on the platforms your customers actually use, and check current platform guidelines before launching a request campaign.

Worked example: reading the Google figures

Suppose a local service business wants to understand Google's 2016 performance in the dataset. Google's new reviews jumped 278% year on year, and the average business gained 15.1 new reviews in 2016 versus 6.9 in 2015. That combination — rapid total growth and a higher per-business average — indicates that growth was not simply driven by more businesses joining the platform. For a business planning review requests, the lesson is that Google's prompt-driven review flow can generate steady volume; the same effort on a platform with lower per-business averages may yield fewer reviews. The trust caveat matters too: high volume did not make Google the most trusted platform in the 2017 survey.

Year-on-year growth table

The interactive table below preserves the original percentage figures for each platform from 2013 to 2016. Use it to compare growth rates side by side. Note that Facebook's 2013 value reflects its first full year of reviews and should not be read as a typical growth rate.

Frequently asked questions

Which local review site grew fastest between 2012 and 2017?

Google showed the steepest cumulative and year-on-year growth in the dataset, including a 278% rise in new reviews in 2016. Facebook, Yelp and TripAdvisor also grew, while Foursquare plateaued.

Which platform had the most reviews per business?

TripAdvisor led on average new reviews per business, reaching 47.5 in 2016. That reflects its concentration in travel and hospitality rather than a broad all-industry footprint.

Did Facebook reviews decline?

Facebook's average new reviews per business fell from 13.6 in 2013 to 7.2 in 2016, but its total review volume still grew strongly in 2016 and 2017. The per-business drop may reflect a larger business base rather than weaker engagement.

Why did Foursquare reviews plateau?

Foursquare shifted its focus toward location intelligence and enterprise data, and its consumer review volume stayed low and flat over the period. It was the only platform in the study without a clear upward trend.

Did Google's review volume lead make it the most trusted review site?

No. The 2017 Local Consumer Review Survey found Google was consumers' third most trusted review site, behind Facebook and Yelp, even though Google led on review volume. Volume growth and trust leadership are separate measures.

Year-on-year growth in new reviews by platform, 2013–2016
Review Site2013201420152016
Yelp66%68%55%59%
Facebook1683%-11%-18%71%
Foursquare16%-16%-12%-3%
Google1%80%114%278%
TripAdvisor51%70%115%82%

Figures are historical percentages from the original dataset covering approximately 50,000 US businesses. They are not current growth rates.