Citation Volume and Google Local Rankings: What a 2018 Study Found
A citation is a mention of a business's name, address and phone details on another site.
This page summarises a 2018 study of 122,125 local businesses, drawn from 18,580 related keywords, that compared citation counts with Google Local positions. The figures below are a dated reference point, not a current benchmark. Use them to frame an audit, then re-check live data before making decisions.
Headline findings
The study reported that businesses ranking in positions 1-3 in Google Local averaged 85 citations. It also found a correlation between higher citation counts and higher local positions. That is a correlation, not proof of cause: the study's own authors noted that many factors affect local rankings and that more citations do not automatically produce higher positions.
The findings were set alongside Moz's 2017 Local Search Ranking Factors Survey, which put the combined effect of citation consistency and volume at 13% of local ranking influence. Apple Maps, Google My Business and Bing were excluded from the citation count because the data was unavailable at the time.
Key numbers from the study:
- Average citations for a business in Google Local position 1: 86
- Average citations for businesses ranked 1-3 overall: 85
- Share of businesses with none of the ten most-used citation sites: 5%
- Highest industry average: hotels, at 152 citations each
- Lowest industry average: photographers, at 34 citations each
- Second-lowest industry average: tradesmen, at 47 citations each
- Share of tradesmen missing all ten top citation sites: 18%
- Gap between the most-used and tenth most-used citation site: 33 percentage points
Because these figures date from 2018, treat them as a historical snapshot. Citation platforms, their popularity and Google's local algorithm have all changed since. Re-run a citation audit on current data before quoting any of these numbers to a client or using them in a business case.
Which citation sites local businesses used most
Across the industries studied, the same handful of general-purpose sites dominated. Excluding Google My Business, Apple Maps and Bing, Facebook and Yelp were the clear leaders, used by 84% and 80% of the businesses analysed respectively. Other familiar names in the top ten included YP, Mapquest and Yahoo!.
The spread between the most-used and tenth most-used site was 33 percentage points. That concentration matters for planning: a small set of platforms carries most of the citation footprint, while industry-specific directories fill in the rest. The study published separate top-site lists for each of the 26 industries it covered, which is the right place to look when you need vertical-specific destinations rather than general ones.
Industries with the biggest citation gaps
The ten most-used sites in the study were general-purpose and not tied to a location or sector, so it was notable that 5% of the businesses analysed had none of them. The gap widened sharply by industry. Among tradesmen, 18% were missing all ten top sites, and the same group averaged 47 citations per business, the second-lowest figure in the study. Photographers averaged 34, the lowest of any industry, while hotels averaged 152, the highest.
For a reader using this as a diagnostic: a low count alone does not tell you whether the problem is missing core sites or missing industry-specific ones. Check both. A tradesman with a Facebook page but no trade directory listings has a different gap from one with no core listings at all.
How to use the findings in a citation audit
The study's practical value is as a framing device for a citation audit, not as a target to hit. A short checklist:
- Confirm the business appears on the core general sites the study identified as most-used (Facebook, Yelp and the other top-ten names).
- Check the industry-specific directories for the relevant vertical, since the study found these vary by sector.
- Record the current count and compare it with the study's industry average only as a rough reference point, noting the 2018 date.
- Separate missing-site problems from inconsistent-data problems; the study measured presence, not accuracy.
- Present the comparison as evidence of a pattern, not a guarantee of ranking movement.
A worked example using the study's own figures: a photographer with 20 citations sits below the study's 34-citation industry average, while a hotel with 100 sits well below the 152 average for hotels. In both cases the useful next step is to identify which specific sites are missing, not simply to add volume.
Limits of the evidence
Three limits are worth stating plainly. First, the study is a snapshot from 2018; citation platforms and local ranking behaviour have moved on. Second, the relationship between citations and rankings is correlational, and the study's authors explicitly declined to claim causation. Third, the three biggest platforms by local search importance at the time (Google My Business, Apple Maps and Bing) were excluded from the counts, so the totals describe the wider citation web rather than the primary local profiles.
Use the numbers to start a conversation about citation coverage, and verify current conditions before relying on any specific figure.
Frequently asked questions
Does having more citations guarantee a higher Google Local ranking?
No. The study found a correlation between citation counts and local positions, but its authors stated that many factors affect local rankings and that more citations do not automatically produce higher rankings. Citations are one input among several.
Why were Google My Business, Apple Maps and Bing left out of the citation counts?
The study states that data for those three platforms was unavailable at the time, so they were excluded. The counts therefore describe the wider citation web rather than the primary local profiles.
Which industries had the highest and lowest average citation counts?
Hotels had the highest average at 152 citations per business. Photographers had the lowest at 34. Tradesmen were second-lowest at 47 and also had the largest share (18%) missing all ten top citation sites.
Are these citation figures still current?
They are a historical snapshot from a 2018 study. Citation platforms and local ranking behaviour have changed since, so re-check live data before using any of these numbers in a business case or client report.