Burger King vs McDonald's: US Google Review Ratings Compared
A national average can hide a lot.
Two chains can post the same headline star rating while individual restaurants, and whole states, sit well apart. This page works through a captured February 2023 snapshot of Google ratings for Burger King and McDonald's locations across the USA, then turns the pattern into something a franchise or enterprise team can actually act on: which locations to look at first, and what to check once you get there.
The national picture
Across the USA, the average Google rating for both brands sits at 3.5 stars. Neither chain pulls ahead on the national average, so the more useful comparison is at state level. Burger King has the higher average rating in 23 states, McDonald's leads in 19 states plus the District of Columbia, and eight states are tied. State averages stay within a narrow band, from 3.3 to 3.8 stars, which suggests that location-level execution matters more than brand-level reputation.
Where Burger King performs best
New York, South Dakota and West Virginia share the highest average Burger King rating at 3.7 stars. New Hampshire has the lowest state average at 2.9 stars. Less than half of US states meet the national Burger King average of 3.5, with 24 states at or above it and 26 states (27 including DC) below. The top-rated individual Burger King is at 3040 Ella Blvd in Houston, Texas, where reviews frequently name specific employees and praise their customer service.
Where McDonald's performs best
Hawaii is the top-rated state across both brands, with McDonald's averaging 3.8 stars. Utah has the lowest McDonald's state average at 3.2 stars. Twenty-nine states fall below the 3.5 baseline for McDonald's. The highest average rating for any single McDonald's location is 4.2 stars, which is above the baseline but still short of standout performance across the estate.
Location-level facts worth noting
The most-reviewed McDonald's in the USA is at 6875 Sand Lake Rd in Orlando, Florida, known as the World's Largest Entertainment McDonald's, with 18,590 Google reviews at the time of the research and a 4.0 average rating. The top-rated outlet overall is the Burger King at 3040 Ella Blvd in Houston, Texas, with a 4.4 star rating. Across the estate, the 7,216 Burger Kings have 4.06 million Google reviews (an average of 562 per restaurant), while the 13,247 McDonald's restaurants have 16.3 million reviews (an average of 1,231 per restaurant).
What multi-location operators can learn
Scale brings both visibility and risk. A location with thousands of reviews can drift towards an average rating simply because volume attracts a wider range of feedback. The New Hampshire Burger King example shows how negative keywords such as 'disgusting' can surface prominently in review snippets, which matters because searchers often scan those keywords before reading individual reviews. The Orlando McDonald's shows the opposite pattern: high volume paired with a 4.0 average and distinctive customer experience. The practical lesson is to monitor review content, respond to feedback consistently, and treat location-level ratings as operational signals rather than brand-level verdicts.
A short checklist for franchise and enterprise teams
Use this checklist when reviewing a multi-location estate:
- Compare each location against the brand's own baseline, not just against competitors.
- Flag locations where negative keywords appear in the top review snippets.
- Track review volume alongside average rating, because high volume can mask or amplify problems.
- Look for reviews that name individual staff members, as these often signal service consistency.
- Respond to both positive and negative feedback to show active management.
How the comparison was built
The figures on this page come from a third-party research snapshot captured in February 2023. That study gathered Google Business Profile information for every Burger King and McDonald's location in the USA and used a script to retrieve each location's Google review rating and total review count. This page did not run its own data collection; it reports the captured results and treats them as a dated snapshot rather than a current reading. Ratings and review counts will have moved since. The state leaderboard below reproduces the captured results in full. Review-management tooling is a separate matter from the original study: if a team wants to track ratings and review volume across many locations, the practical approach is to choose a monitoring tool, connect each location's profile, and set a regular reporting cadence. The specific tool and setup depend on the operator's own configuration and are not part of the research described here.
| State | Winner | Avg. Review Rating | State | Winner | Avg. Review Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama (AL) | TIE | 3.4 | Montana (MT) | MCDONALD'S | 3.5 |
| Alaska (AK) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 | Nebraska (NE) | BURGER KING | 3.4 |
| Arizona (AZ) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Nevada (NV) | MCDONALD'S | 3.5 |
| Arkansas (AR) | BURGER KING | 3.6 | New Hampshire (NH) | MCDONALD'S | 3.5 |
| California (CA) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 | New Jersey (NJ) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 |
| Colorado (CO) | MCDONALD'S | 3.3 | New Mexico (NM) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Connecticut (CT) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 | New York (NY) | BURGER KING | 3.7 |
| Delaware (DE) | TIE | 3.4 | North Carolina (NC) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
| District of Columbia (DC) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 | North Dakota (ND) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 |
| Florida (FL) | MCDONALD'S | 3.5 | Ohio (OH) | BURGER KING | 3.4 |
| Georgia (GA) | BURGER KING | 3.4 | Oklahoma (OK) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Hawaii (HI) | MCDONALD'S | 3.8 | Oregon (OR) | MCDONALD'S | 3.4 |
| Idaho (ID) | TIE | 3.6 | Pennsylvania (PA) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Illinois (IL) | MCDONALD'S | 3.5 | Rhode Island (RI) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
| Indiana (IN) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | South Carolina (SC) | TIE | 3.3 |
| Iowa (IA) | TIE | 3.4 | South Dakota (SD) | BURGER KING | 3.7 |
| Kansas (KS) | MCDONALD'S | 3.4 | Tennessee (TN) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
| Kentucky (KY) | BURGER KING | 3.6 | Texas (TX) | MCDONALD'S | 3.6 |
| Louisiana (LA) | TIE | 3.4 | Utah (UT) | BURGER KING | 3.3 |
| Maine (ME) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Vermont (VT) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Maryland (MD) | BURGER KING | 3.6 | Virginia (VA) | TIE | 3.4 |
| Massachusetts (MA) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Washington (WA) | MCDONALD'S | 3.5 |
| Michigan (MI) | TIE | 3.4 | West Virginia (WV) | BURGER KING | 3.7 |
| Minnesota (MN) | MCDONALD'S | 3.4 | Wisconsin (WI) | MCDONALD'S | 3.3 |
| Mississippi (MS) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Wyoming (WY) | MCDONALD'S | 3.3 |
| Missouri (MO) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
Ratings reflect a February 2023 snapshot of Google Business Profile data and may have changed since publication.
Frequently asked questions
What is the average Google rating for Burger King and McDonald's in the USA?
Both brands average 3.5 stars across their US locations in the February 2023 snapshot.
Which brand has the better Google review ratings?
Burger King has the higher average rating in 23 states, McDonald's leads in 19 states plus DC, and eight states are tied. Nationally, the averages are level at 3.5 stars.
Which individual location has the highest rating?
The Burger King at 3040 Ella Blvd in Houston, Texas, has a 4.4 star rating, the highest of any outlet in the comparison.
Which location has the most reviews?
The McDonald's at 6875 Sand Lake Rd in Orlando, Florida, known as the World's Largest Entertainment McDonald's, had 18,590 Google reviews at the time of the research.
Why do small differences in star ratings matter for multi-location businesses?
Review research cited in the original analysis suggests that moving from 3.5 to 3.7 stars can affect conversion, directions requests and contact rates. For franchise operators, the practical focus is on lifting below-average locations rather than relying on brand reputation.
| State | Winner | Avg. Review Rating | State | Winner | Avg. Review Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama (AL) | TIE | 3.4 | Montana (MT) | MCDONALD’S | 3.5 |
| Alaska (AK) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 | Nebraska (NE) | BURGER KING | 3.4 |
| Arizona (AZ) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Nevada (NV) | MCDONALD’S | 3.5 |
| Arkansas (AR) | BURGER KING | 3.6 | New Hampshire (NH) | MCDONALD’S | 3.5 |
| California (CA) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 | New Jersey (NJ) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 |
| Colorado (CO) | MCDONALD’S | 3.3 | New Mexico (NM) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Connecticut (CT) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 | New York (NY) | BURGER KING | 3.7 |
| Delaware (DE) | TIE | 3.4 | North Carolina (NC) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
| District of Columbia (DC) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 | North Dakota (ND) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 |
| Florida (FL) | MCDONALD’S | 3.5 | Ohio (OH) | BURGER KING | 3.4 |
| Georgia (GA) | BURGER KING | 3.4 | Oklahoma (OK) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Hawaii (HI) | MCDONALD’S | 3.8 | Oregon (OR) | MCDONALD’S | 3.4 |
| Idaho (ID) | TIE | 3.6 | Pennsylvania (PA) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Illinois (IL) | MCDONALD’S | 3.5 | Rhode Island (RI) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
| Indiana (IN) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | South Carolina (SC) | TIE | 3.3 |
| Iowa (IA) | TIE | 3.4 | South Dakota (SD) | BURGER KING | 3.7 |
| Kansas (KS) | MCDONALD’S | 3.4 | Tennessee (TN) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |
| Kentucky (KY) | BURGER KING | 3.6 | Texas (TX) | MCDONALD’S | 3.6 |
| Louisiana (LA) | TIE | 3.4 | Utah (UT) | BURGER KING | 3.3 |
| Maine (ME) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Vermont (VT) | BURGER KING | 3.6 |
| Maryland (MD) | BURGER KING | 3.6 | Virginia (VA) | TIE | 3.4 |
| Massachusetts (MA) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Washington (WA) | MCDONALD’S | 3.5 |
| Michigan (MI) | TIE | 3.4 | West Virginia (WV) | BURGER KING | 3.7 |
| Minnesota (MN) | MCDONALD’S | 3.4 | Wisconsin (WI) | MCDONALD’S | 3.3 |
| Mississippi (MS) | BURGER KING | 3.5 | Wyoming (WY) | MCDONALD’S | 3.3 |
| Missouri (MO) | BURGER KING | 3.5 |