Consumer Review Behavior Trends 2010–2025: What Changed and What Still Matters
This trend analysis looks back across the Local Consumer Review Survey series from 2010 to 2025.
It traces how often US consumers research local businesses, which review factors they weigh, how trust has moved, and where review activity may go next. The aim is practical: help local businesses decide which review-management habits are still worth the effort and which assumptions need revisiting.
How to read the trend data
The survey questions have not stayed identical across every year. Some were amended, removed or introduced at different points, so not every result can be compared like-for-like. The charts also appear to skip a year between 2020 and 2022 because publication moved from the end of the year to the start. The edition published at the start of 2022 therefore reports consumer insights looking back across 2021. Treat the figures as a dated historical reference and check current conditions before making decisions.
How often consumers research local businesses
Between 2010 and 2023, the survey measured how often consumers used the internet to find information about local businesses. From 2015 to 2016, the share researching almost daily rose by 13% year over year. That period coincided with wider connectivity and access to online information. Pew Research data shows US adult smartphone ownership reaching 77% by 2016, and Statista data shows US adult internet use rising from 75% to 86% between 2015 and 2016.
The 2020 peak and the later shift
By 2020, 59% of US consumers said they looked for information about local businesses almost every day. COVID-19 restrictions and lockdowns changed priorities, including higher importance placed on safety measures, and local business research rose sharply. In 2022 and 2023, almost-daily research fell while weekly research rose steadily. Businesses cannot control search frequency, but the timeline shows how technology and global events shape customer and purchase behavior. A PESTLE analysis remains a useful framework for monitoring those external factors.
Reading reviews: always, regularly, never
From 2019 to 2025, the share of consumers who said they always read online reviews began to dwindle, while the share reading them regularly rose sharply from 2020 to 2022. The share who never read reviews stayed low across the last four years. That suggests reviews remain an important step in the research journey. The shift may also reflect changes in spending and priorities: US consumers may simply be shopping around less rather than treating reviews as less important.
Which review platforms consumers use
The top spots did not change significantly between 2020 and 2025, but the contest between Facebook and Yelp for second most popular review site among US consumers is notable. Zooming out shows a clear decline for Facebook over the period. In the 2023 Local Business Discovery & Trust Report, Facebook was both one of the most used platforms and the most distrusted. Political scandals over personal data misuse, the rise of fake news, and unfavorable opinion of its CEO as of 2025 all sit alongside that trust decline. Organic visibility on social platforms has also become harder as ads are prioritised, which may add to consumer scepticism. Facebook should not be discounted: stay present on the platforms your audiences use and trust. As of 2025, Google remained the top platform for reading online reviews, with a slight percentage bump since the previous year.
When alternative review platforms stop being alternative
Only in the last few years have platforms outside the traditional review format been included in the consumer research. Consumers had already been using YouTube, Instagram and TikTok for research, decisions and their own reviews; formal recognition of these channels in local marketing and review management is newer. The traditional and alternative categories may now be merging from the consumer's point of view. Some alternative platforms reach more consumers than niche review sites: in 2025, 7% of consumers said they used Healthgrades to read reviews, compared with almost half using local news outlets and over a third using YouTube. These channels should not be discounted from a review management strategy.
Review recency: from peak concern to greater leniency
Consumers pay attention to many parts of a review, from average rating and recency to the written details. Between 2018 and 2020, consumers placed more importance on recency than at any other point in the series. From 2019 to 2020, the pandemic made recent experiences more relevant as opening hours, product availability and safety measures changed quickly. The 22% increase between 2017 and 2018 is harder to explain. Since then, the perception of recency has shifted. Consumers may be more lenient towards local businesses, and may also understand that recency, quantity and star ratings are vanity metrics that do not reflect the full customer experience.
Star ratings: expectations have relaxed
Consumer expectations around star ratings have relaxed in a similar way to recency. The way the survey asked about star ratings changed between 2014 and 2019, so the data is split into two charts; from 2020, the nuances of rating scales were recognised. The general downward trend shows fewer consumers expecting local businesses to have an average rating of five stars. That reinforces the point that consumers are more understanding of the difficulty of maintaining high ratings, and that a rating is not a realistic standalone indicator of quality.
Trust in online reviews compared with personal recommendations
Trust in online reviews reached its peak in 2016 and 2017, when 84% of consumers agreed they trusted this information as much as personal recommendations. In the last five years, the trend has moved significantly downward. This is not necessarily negative. It suggests a broader shift in social awareness: consumers are more aware of the extremes and nuances of other people's behavior. Some people are known complainers, and today's consumers may be better at detecting extreme, unnecessary or entitled review sentiments. All experiences are shaped by norms, cultures and biases; consumers are now more socially aware of those factors and can be more objective about what they see online. In the early days of online reviews, and during the mid-2010s when Tripadvisor was at its peak, consumers were more willing to take experiences at face value.
Fake reviews: awareness has fallen, not necessarily the problem
A few years ago, the industry seemed to reach a peak of fake review problems. In 2019, 82% of consumers felt they had come across fake reviews. Since then, the percentages have dropped, most significantly between 2020 and 2022, when the figure decreased by 18%. The latest consumer research also shows drops across the board for the platforms where consumers are confident they have spotted fake reviews. This does not necessarily mean there are fewer fake reviews. Review platforms are faster and harder in cracking down, and consumers may be less focused on fakes than business owners are.
Writing reviews: a steady habit and rising willingness
The question about whether consumers had written a business review in the last 12 months changed format, so the timeline is simplified to yes or no. Since 2020, the trend for both answers has remained fairly steady. Across the last five years, close to three in four US adults reported having written an online review at some point. By 2020, leaving a review had become a routine part of how people behave online and move through a purchase. As of 2021, consumers had also become more willing to write a review even if they had not done so in the last year. Challenging circumstances for businesses, including the pandemic and fluctuations in global economies, may have made consumers more aware of hardships for local businesses and more willing to leave feedback. For business owners, the lesson is that consumers are overwhelmingly willing to write a review; the task is to give them a strong reason and catch them at the right time.
What the 15-year view means for review management
Shifts in social awareness should reassure many small business owners. A consistent stream of new, positive reviews is integral for online visibility, but these factors are not the be all and end all for prospective customers. Consumers are willing to make their own minds up from a variety of positive and negative reviews, and the evidence shows more leniency around the minimum requirements local businesses should meet to be given a chance. Existing review profile features, such as Google Business Profile attributes, can help socially-conscious consumers find and support a business. Attributes covering business ownership (such as LGBTQ-owned, black-owned and female-owned) and commitments to accessibility, inclusion and safety can remind consumers that a small business is doing its best. None of this means aiming for sub-standard experiences or relaxing review generation. What can be relaxed is the worry about how average or negative feedback is perceived by prospective customers. Showing that feedback is heard and answered, while maintaining presence and availability across online channels, is a positive indicator for consumers doing their research.
Where consumer review behavior may be headed
Reading and writing reviews is now established behavior, so consumers are likely to look for and share experiences on other platforms they spend time on. That includes TikTok, Instagram and YouTube, but there may be other competitors not yet considered. In the local SEO world, there has been speculation about whether Apple Maps will become a true competitor to Google Maps. In the past two years it has made significant user experience improvements and continued to develop its business offering with Apple Business Connect. A business can get ahead by claiming and optimising its Apple Maps listing. As alternative review platforms maintain their presence and improve local search features, such as Instagram's Explore with interactive map functionality, the definition of an official review platform may change. The distinction between traditional and alternative may become obsolete.
A practical checklist for review management
Use the trend evidence to decide where to spend effort:
- Check whether your review profile is claimed and optimised on Google, and consider Apple Maps as a second map listing.
- Audit the non-traditional channels your customers already use for research, such as YouTube, Instagram and TikTok, and decide whether they belong in your review plan.
- Review your Google Business Profile attributes for ownership, accessibility, inclusion and safety, and add any that accurately describe the business.
- Set a routine for responding to both positive and negative feedback, and keep your presence and availability consistent across channels.
- Do not treat star rating or recency as the only quality signals; read the written detail and look at the mix of reviews.
- Keep asking for reviews at the right moment, because willingness to write one is high.
Worked example: why a niche review site is not the whole plan
Imagine a local business deciding where to focus its review efforts. In 2025, 7% of consumers said they used Healthgrades to read reviews. Almost half used local news outlets, and over a third used YouTube. A plan that only monitors a niche review site would miss the larger audience reading and sharing experiences on news and video channels. The practical move is to keep the niche site accurate, then check whether the business appears correctly and consistently on the broader channels customers actually use.
Falling trust is not the same as falling importance
Two trends can look alike but call for different responses. Trust in online reviews has fallen from its 2016–2017 peak, yet the share of consumers who never read reviews has stayed low. The first trend is about how consumers weigh what they read; the second is about whether they read at all. A business that sees lower trust should focus on responding to feedback and showing a balanced review profile. A business that sees reviews being ignored should check whether its listing is visible and available on the channels customers use. Treating both trends as one problem can lead to the wrong fix.
Google Business Profile attribute map
The trend analysis points to Google Business Profile attributes as a way to help socially-conscious consumers find a business. The attributes named in the research cover:
- Business ownership: LGBTQ-owned, black-owned, female-owned.
- Commitments: accessibility, inclusion and safety.
Use only attributes that accurately describe the business. The value is in helping consumers recognise a business that matches their priorities, not in adding labels for their own sake.
Frequently asked questions
Do consumers still read online reviews?
Yes. Between 2019 and 2025, the share who said they always read reviews began to dwindle, but the share who never read reviews stayed low across the last four years. Reviews remain an important step in the research journey. The shift may reflect consumers shopping around less rather than treating reviews as less important.
How important is review recency?
Recency mattered more between 2018 and 2020 than at any other point in the series, especially during the pandemic when opening hours, availability and safety measures changed quickly. Since then, the perception of recency has shifted, and consumers appear more lenient. Recency is one factor among several, not a standalone quality signal.
Are star ratings still important to consumers?
They matter, but expectations have relaxed. The general downward trend shows fewer consumers expecting local businesses to have an average rating of five stars. Consumers appear more understanding of how hard high ratings are to maintain, and a rating is not a realistic standalone indicator of quality.
Why has trust in online reviews fallen?
Trust peaked in 2016 and 2017, when 84% of consumers agreed they trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations. The decline since then suggests a broader shift in social awareness. Consumers are more aware of the extremes and nuances of other people's behavior and can be more objective about what they read online.
Which platforms do consumers use for reviews?
As of 2025, Google remained the top platform for reading online reviews. Facebook and Yelp have contested second place, with Facebook showing a clear decline over 2020–2025. Non-traditional channels also reach large audiences: almost half of consumers used local news outlets and over a third used YouTube, compared with 7% using Healthgrades.
Are consumers willing to write reviews?
Yes. Over the last five years, almost three-quarters of US adults have written an online review. As of 2021, consumers had also become more willing to write one even if they had not done so in the last year. The task for businesses is to give them a strong reason and ask at the right time.