Car Dealerships and Google Business Profile Insights: What the Data Shows
Car dealerships were among the standout industries in a large Google My Business Insights study.
This guide walks through the six insight areas the study examined, explains what each metric means, and shows how a dealership can turn the findings into a practical profile routine. The figures are a dated reference from the study period, so treat them as a benchmark to learn from rather than a current market reading.
The six insight areas at a glance
The study tracked dealership performance across direct searches, discovery searches, views on Search, views on Maps, customer actions and call timing, then compared year-on-year change. Each metric answers a different question, and mixing them up leads to the wrong fix. Use this map before reading the numbers:
- Direct search: someone typed the dealership name or address into Google Search or Maps. A drop here usually points to brand or listing accuracy issues.
- Discovery search: someone searched a category, product or service and the listing appeared. A drop here points to category, service and relevance signals.
- Views on Search: the listing was found through Google Search, including local pack results.
- Views on Maps: the listing was found through Google Maps.
- Customer actions: website clicks, phone calls and directions requests, the three interactions the study treated as closest to conversion.
- Call timing: when calls arrive by day and hour, useful for staffing rather than ranking.
Direct and discovery searches
Across the industries studied, hotels and restaurants led on discovery searches, with car dealerships close behind and the remaining industries well back. For the average dealership, discovery searches improved gradually over the September 2017 to December 2018 window. Direct and discovery searches moved in a broadly similar pattern, with discovery showing a more exaggerated version of the same shape.
One month stands out. Direct searches were fairly stable until August 2018, when they rose 49% from July and held there until holiday seasonality took over. Discovery searches showed the same jump. The study's author linked the timing to a Google core algorithm update and to a GMB Insights update that widened the places counted as customer discovery. That link is a hypothesis, not a proven cause, so treat it as a prompt to check your own August-to-December pattern rather than a rule.
Views on Search and Views on Maps
Ordered by Views on Search, the average dealership sat above restaurants in the top-ten industry chart. The study offered two explanations. First, dealerships sit between spread-out and commonly searched: there is less local competition than in restaurants, and buyers will travel further, so searches often use a county-level modifier rather than a town. Second, buying a car involves more research and browsing, which produces more clicks through to dealership websites.
Over time, Views on Search and Views on Maps followed much the same pattern, which suggests the biggest driver is seasonal consumer behaviour rather than a difference between the two surfaces. The exception was January and March 2018, when Views on Search spiked without a matching Maps spike. A January uplift after the seasonal downturn is plausible; the study suggested the gap itself looked more like a technology change than a behaviour change, and pointed to a March algorithm update. That remains an open question, not a settled finding.
Customer actions: clicks, calls and directions
The average dealership led the pack on customer actions. It did not receive the most directions requests, but it won on clicks and calls, receiving 222 more clicks per month than the nearest category competitor, hotels. Two factors explain the gap. A search for a dealer is a search for cars, and a GMB listing can only show so much stock, so many views end in a website click. Dealerships also tend to invest heavily in local search because competition is county-wide and average order values are high.
The study pointed to supporting signals: dealerships had more than twice the average number of Google reviews and an above-average number of citations per business. Consistent performance across several studies suggested deliberate investment rather than luck. The March 2018 spike in actions could reflect an algorithm update producing more reliable local results, but the study noted that March 2017 data was not included, so a seasonal explanation cannot be ruled out. What the chart does show is an industry that invested in profile optimisation in 2018 and used features such as Google Posts, photos and Q&A to lift clickthroughs.
When calls arrive
Call timing does not tell you much about ranking, but it is useful for staffing. Calls were fairly evenly split across the week, with only Monday, Saturday and Sunday deviating from the norm. The study reported the following split:
- Monday: 20%
- Tuesday: 17%
- Wednesday: 17%
- Thursday: 17%
- Friday: 17%
- Saturday: 11%
- Sunday: 1%
A practical reading: keep weekday phone cover steady, expect a lighter Saturday, and do not staff Sunday as if it were a normal trading day unless your own call data says otherwise.
Year-on-year change
Comparing October to December 2017 with the same quarter in 2018, the biggest improvement was in how often dealerships appeared in search. The average dealership saw a 40% increase in discovery searches and a 64% increase in direct searches. Website clicks also rose 39% year on year. The study text also described the average industry figure as 39%, which reads as a contradiction in the original; treat the dealership click figure as the reliable one and check any industry comparison against the full study.
The broader point is that the click destination and the local result before it both matter. A profile that wins the click but sends people to a slow or thin page wastes the gain.
A dealership profile checklist
Use the study's patterns as a monthly routine rather than a one-off audit:
- Check direct searches first. If they fall while discovery holds, review name, address and category accuracy.
- Check discovery searches next. If they fall, review service and product categories, and the wording of your business description.
- Compare Views on Search with Views on Maps. A gap that opens only on Search is worth investigating as a surface or feature change, not automatically as a demand drop.
- Track clicks, calls and directions separately. A click-heavy profile with few calls may need clearer phone prompts; a call-heavy profile with few clicks may need stronger stock or offer content.
- Review Google reviews and citations quarterly. The study linked dealership performance to above-average review counts and citation coverage.
- Use Posts, photos and Q&A to give searchers a reason to click through.
- Match phone staffing to the weekday pattern above, then adjust with your own call data.
Worked example: if your direct searches jump sharply in one month while discovery searches stay flat, the study's August 2018 pattern suggests checking for a platform or algorithm change before assuming a demand shift. If both rise together, seasonal demand is the more likely driver.
What this means for a dealership
The study's clearest lesson is that profile investment pays back in visibility and actions. Dealerships with infrequent purchases, spread-out competition and high-cost inventory are a good fit for that approach. The year-on-year rises in searches, clicks and views show an industry taking the profile seriously, and Google responding with more features and dynamic elements. The figures here are a dated reference from the study period; check current performance in your own Insights before setting targets.
Frequently asked questions
What does Google My Business Insights measure?
It reports how people found and interacted with a listing: direct searches, discovery searches, views on Search and Maps, and customer actions such as website clicks, calls and directions requests. Call timing is also reported.
What is the difference between a direct search and a discovery search?
A direct search means someone typed your business name or address into Google Search or Maps. A discovery search means someone searched a category, product or service and your listing appeared.
Why did dealership direct searches jump in August 2018?
The study linked the 49% month-on-month rise to a Google core algorithm update and a GMB Insights update that widened the places counted as discovery. That is a hypothesis, not a confirmed cause.
Which day gets the most calls to a dealership?
Monday was highest at 20%, with Tuesday to Friday each at 17%, Saturday at 11% and Sunday at 1%. The split is a dated reference, so check your own call data.