Local Consumer Review Survey 2020
In 2020, local business reviews were both a routine part of choosing a nearby service and a source of reassurance during a disrupted year.
This summary turns the findings of the published 2020 Local Consumer Review Survey into a review-management checklist for local businesses, with the original industry table preserved exactly.
Key findings at a glance
The 2020 survey found that 93% of US consumers had used the internet to find a local business in the previous year, and 34% searched every day. Online reviews were read by 87% of consumers, up from 81% in 2019. Positive reviews made 94% of consumers more likely to use a business, while negative reviews made 92% less likely. The survey also found that 79% of consumers trusted online reviews as much as personal recommendations.
How Covid-19 changed review behaviour
The pandemic produced mixed effects rather than a single direction of change. Among respondents, 37% searched for fewer local businesses online, while 28% searched for more. Review reading followed a similar pattern: 34% read fewer reviews than in a normal year and 31% read more. Health and safety measures became part of the decision: 67% said they would not use a business if reviews said it lacked Covid-19 health and safety measures, and 23% said they had chosen not to use a business for that reason. A further 17% said they had written negative reviews for businesses without such measures, while 22% wrote reviews to support struggling local businesses.
Which industries consumers review most
The table below shows, for each industry, the proportion of consumers who look at reviews and the proportion who believe reviews are important. The importance column is measured only among consumers who have ever seen reviews in that industry, so it should not be read as a share of all consumers. Restaurants and cafés had the highest share of consumers looking at reviews (93%), followed by hotels and B&Bs (90%) and medical and healthcare (89%). The full table is preserved exactly as supplied.
What review readers care about
Star rating was the most influential review factor in 2020, followed by legitimacy, recency, sentiment and quantity. Only 48% of consumers would consider using a business with fewer than 4 stars, and just 19% would use one with fewer than 3 stars. Recency mattered too: 86% looked only at reviews from the past three months, 73% required reviews from the last month, and 50% considered only reviews from the past two weeks. The average consumer read 10 reviews before trusting a business, but 20% read more than 10 and 8% read more than 20. A steady stream of recent reviews is therefore more useful than a single burst of activity.
Where consumers look and what they trust
Google was the most-used site for local business information in 2020, used by 63% of respondents. Facebook followed, then Yelp at 32%. Trust did not follow usage: the Better Business Bureau was seen as the most trustworthy source of reviews, despite being the least used of the key sites. Amazon reviews were trusted by 78% of consumers, and 60% trusted reviews on a company website. The survey did not distinguish between third-party reviews shown on a company site and first-party reviews written by the business itself, so that figure should be read with that limitation in mind.
Responding to reviews
Among consumers who read reviews, 96% also read business responses, and 40% always read them. Responses mattered regardless of sentiment: 69% were more likely to use a business that responded to positive reviews, and 70% were more likely to use one that responded to negative reviews. Templated replies put off 70% of consumers. Speed mattered as well: 20% expected a response within a day, and only 39% were happy to wait more than three days. Among consumers who had written a review, 77% recalled receiving a response, but only 35% received a response to every review.
Writing reviews and asking for them
72% of US consumers had written a review for a local business, up from 66% in 2019. Positive experiences were the more common trigger: 63% had written a review after a positive experience, while 32% had written one after a negative experience. Asking worked: 73% had been asked to write a review, and 72% of those who were asked went on to write one. Email was the most recalled request method (45%), followed by in-person requests at the point of sale (34%) and requests on a receipt (30%). Incentives were less common but still present: 12% had been offered a discount, 9% cash and 8% a gift or free service. Those incentives conflict with many review platforms’ guidelines and can undermine trust.
A practical review-management checklist
Use the 2020 findings as a set of checks rather than a guarantee of current conditions. First, confirm that your star rating is at least 4 and aim for a steady flow of recent reviews rather than a one-off push. Second, make sure the first 10 reviews on each key site represent the experience you want customers to see. Third, respond to both positive and negative reviews with specific, non-templated replies, and aim to reply within a few days. Fourth, ask for reviews through more than one channel, such as email and a point-of-sale prompt. Fifth, avoid offering discounts, cash or gifts in exchange for reviews. Finally, check the review sites your customers actually use, including industry-specific sites, rather than assuming one platform covers everyone.
How the survey was conducted
The 2020 Local Consumer Review Survey was conducted in November 2020 with an independent consumer panel of 1,013 US-based consumers. Age-group breakdowns were representative of the US population. Consumers who said they do not read online reviews were not asked questions about their review behaviour. The findings cover local business reviews on sites such as Google, Facebook, Tripadvisor and Yelp. This page summarises that published research; it is not a new survey conducted by this site.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between review recency and review volume?
Recency is about when a review was written; volume is about how many reviews exist. The 2020 survey found that 73% of consumers only paid attention to reviews from the last month, while the average consumer read 10 reviews before trusting a business. A business with many old reviews can still lose trust if nothing recent is visible, and a business with a few very recent reviews may still need more volume to satisfy readers who look further back.
Should a business respond differently to positive and negative reviews?
The survey found similar expectations for both: 69% were more likely to use a business that responded to positive reviews, and 70% were more likely to use one that responded to negative reviews. What mattered was that the response felt specific rather than templated. A practical approach is to thank the reviewer for positive feedback and to address the specific issue in negative feedback without copying the same reply across reviews.
How should the industry table be used?
Use it to see where review reading is most common and where consumers say reviews matter most. The importance column is not a share of all consumers; it is measured only among those who have seen reviews in that industry. The table also shows only the first 10 of 34 entries in the original interactive table, so it should be treated as a starting point rather than a complete ranking.
| Industry | Consumers who look at reviews in this industry | Consumers who believe reviews are important in this industry |
|---|---|---|
| Restaurants / Cafés | 93% | 87% |
| Hotels / B&Bs | 90% | 87% |
| Medical / Healthcare | 89% | 87% |
| Automotive Services | 87% | 86% |
| Clothing Stores | 87% | 66% |
| Dentists | 86% | 85% |
| Repairs | 86% | 85% |
| Grocery Stores | 85% | 74% |
| Hair / Beauty | 85% | 75% |
| Car Dealerships | 84% | 81% |
The importance column is measured only among consumers who have ever seen reviews in that industry. The table shows the first 10 of 34 entries in the original interactive table.