Online Reputation Management Survey: What Local Marketers Prioritise
A 2018 survey of 255 marketers, small businesses and enterprise employees at the Local Business Marketing Summit explored how local businesses view, use and prioritise online reputation management.
This page summarises the findings and turns them into a practical checklist for monitoring, generating and responding to reviews.
Why reputation matters
Every respondent rated a positive reputation as important, and 87% called it very important to business success. When asked to pick the three most important benefits, respondents ranked trust first, followed by converting searchers into leads and boosting local search rankings. Standing out from competitors and generating more clicks and calls also featured. The pattern suggests trust is treated as the foundation: a business that earns confidence is more likely to attract enquiries and visibility without relying only on direct sales tactics.
Time, priority and barriers
The average respondent devoted 17% of the working week to reputation management — close to a full day — with enterprise businesses spending the most. Most respondents (69%) fell in the 1-20% band. Looking ahead, 77% intended to make reputation management a priority in the next 12 months and 76% planned to spend more time on it; only 2% called it a very low priority and only 2% definitely would not increase time. Time (50%) and budget were the main constraints on doing more. A useful response is to work smarter: set a routine for monitoring, asking for reviews and replying, rather than reacting ad hoc.
The hardest tasks — and how to approach them
Identifying and removing fake reviews was rated the most difficult task. Next came encouraging customers to write reviews, educating staff about why reviews matter, finding the most relevant sites to focus on, and getting a single overview of feedback across sites. Practical implications: check reviews regularly so suspicious entries can be reported quickly and answered with a justification if they remain; ask for reviews at natural moments such as during a transaction, by follow-up email, or via receipts; share feedback with the whole team and act visibly on complaints; and monitor both general platforms and industry-specific sites.
Review sites and fake reviews
Google, Facebook and Yelp led by a clear margin, followed by TripAdvisor and Yellow Pages. A further 40 review sites were named beyond the top sites, showing how fragmented the review landscape is. Do not stop at the big three: map where your customers search, where competitors appear, and which niche sites your sector uses. 58% of businesses had received fake reviews and a further 21% were uncertain whether they had; fake negative reviews were far more common than fake positive ones, and some businesses had received both.
Software use and adoption barriers
44% of respondents used reputation management software, mainly to monitor reviews, with a further 11% planning to adopt it. This question about why software is used was answered only by the 44% who currently use it: monitoring reviews is the most common use, while a lesser proportion use it to generate new reviews — even though generating reviews is the second-hardest reputation task. SMBs were least likely to use it (26% current, 6% planning). Among non-users, lack of resources was the biggest barrier and 37% were discouraged by ROI; 48% of agencies and freelancers cited resourcing. For a small team, the decision test is simple: does the tool save time on monitoring and replies, help you ask more customers at the right moment, and give one view across sites? If not, a manual routine may be enough for now.
Respondent tips: Be Nice, Ask For Reviews, Train Your Team, Respond!
Respondents grouped their best-practice tips into four themes. Be Nice: put a good work ethic, great service and empathy first, since bad business cannot be fixed by reputation tactics alone; also keep an eye on what appears for your brand name and prioritise review sites showing star ratings in branded search. Ask For Reviews: ask in person while a customer is waiting to complete a task, so the request uses your time not theirs; identify cheerleader customers most likely to leave a positive review and make the process simple and completable in under a minute; stay proactive so a bad review does not stand out. Train Your Team: consider linking bonuses or performance reviews to authentic reviews, provide training, handouts, posters, emails and texts, and have processes for flagging policy violations and responding appropriately — including HIPAA-aware replies and follow-up by phone or email to win back unhappy customers. Respond!: reply to all reviews, positive and negative; pause before answering negative reviews and respond professionally rather than emotionally; acknowledge the author so they feel heard; respond promptly, move detail to a private conversation, and pursue removal of fake reviews. Use this as a checklist: assign one owner to monitor and reply, ask happy customers promptly, brief staff, review your site list quarterly, flag suspected fakes quickly, and track time against the 17% benchmark.
| Finding | Detail |
|---|---|
| Very important reputation | 87% |
| Average time on reputation management | 17% of working week |
| Plan to spend more time | 76% |
| Use reputation software | 44% |
| Received fake reviews | 58% |
2018 survey of 255 respondents; percentages as reported.
Frequently asked questions
How important is a positive reputation?
In this 2018 survey of 255 marketers, SMBs and enterprise employees, 87% called a positive reputation very important and every respondent rated it important. The top benefits were customer trust, converting searchers into leads, and stronger local search rankings.
How much time do marketers spend on reputation management, and what limits them?
Respondents averaged 17% of their working week on reputation management, with 69% spending 1-20%. Time was the leading barrier to doing more (50%), followed by budget. 76% planned to spend more time in the next 12 months and 77% planned to make it a priority.
What are the most difficult reputation management tasks?
The hardest task was identifying and removing fake reviews. Other difficult tasks were encouraging customers to leave reviews, educating staff, finding relevant review sites, and getting an overview across sites. 58% had received fake reviews, more often negative than positive.
Do marketers use reputation management software, and why not?
44% used reputation management software, mainly to monitor reviews, and a further 11% planned to use it. Non-users most often cited lack of resources; 37% were discouraged by ROI concerns. SMBs had the lowest current use at 26%.
Which review sites matter most?
Google, Facebook and Yelp were the clear top three, followed by TripAdvisor and Yellow Pages, with a further 40 review sites named beyond the top sites. Respondents were advised to check where their own customers and competitors are active, including industry-specific sites, rather than relying only on the big three.