Skip to content

November 2019 Local Algorithm Update: Reading the Bedlam Data

In early November 2019, local search practitioners noticed something unusual: local rankings were moving more than they had in recent memory.

The volatility was tracked by Local RankFlux and later nicknamed the Bedlam Update. This guide explains what the tracker measured, how to read the movement data, and what to check when local rankings swing.

What the November 2019 volatility looked like

Local RankFlux began reporting higher-than-usual ranking fluctuations from Saturday 2 November 2019. Daily volatility normally sat within a score of 2.2–2.8, but the tracker recorded a peak of 4.71 on Wednesday 6 November — nearly double the usual daily score. The movement appeared across industries, which suggested a possible change to the local algorithm rather than a sector-specific event.

The tracker compared daily ranking positions against the previous day and produced a score based on fluctuations across different ranking groupings. Data was split across 26 industries, with an overall daily score. For the analysis below, the focus was on how volatile businesses were across the top 20 local ranking positions.

How to read the movement data

The data distinguishes between two views: all businesses, and only businesses that saw a movement. That distinction matters. On a volatile day, a larger share of businesses move, so the average change across all businesses can look different from the average change among businesses that moved at all.

Take 1 November, which the analysis treated as a baseline for a 'normal' day. Among businesses that moved, the typical gain was 3.16 places and the typical loss was 1.98 places. By the peak day of Wednesday 6 November, gains had stretched to 4.00 places on average and losses to 2.86. In relative terms, upward movement grew by 27% and downward movement by 44% against that baseline.

The table below shows the average change across all businesses by date. It is a dated snapshot from the 2019 analysis, not a live ranking signal.

Average local ranking changes by date (all businesses)

The following table records the average local ranking change for all businesses across the first eight days of November 2019. Values are reproduced from the original analysis.

Which ranking groupings moved most

When the movements were split by ranking grouping, every grouping saw significant change between the normal day and the most volatile day. Comparing 1 November with 5 November, average ranking movements increased by:

  • Positions 1–3: 41%
  • Positions 4–6: 40%
  • Positions 7–10: 43%
  • Positions 11–15: 41%
  • Positions 16–20: 60%

The largest proportional increase appeared in positions 16–20. The analysis noted that some businesses may have moved both up and down over the week, and that longer-period changes were not explored in that dataset.

Theories around the Bedlam Update

Google did not officially confirm a local update at the time. Discussion spread through the local search community, with Barry Schwartz reporting on the volatility and threads appearing on the Local Search Forum and r/bigseo. According to the source's account, Joy Hawkins coined the name 'Bedlam Update'.

Two explanations circulated. The 'Swapasaurus GMB' theory held that position #1 stayed relatively stable while positions #2 and #3 moved more. A separate line of discussion suggested that local pack flux might reflect which sites Google deems relevant. One marketer who contacted the source publisher believed an experiment had 'gone wrong', pointing to listings without reviews displacing established businesses; the source noted that a single marketer's experience is not proof of a theory. Joy Hawkins separately suggested the idea of a mistake.

Local RankFlux stayed volatile over the weekend of 9–10 November, reaching 4.65. Practitioners continued to debate whether the flux reflected an error and whether affected businesses would return to their previous positions.

What to check when local rankings swing

If you see unusual local ranking movement, use this checklist to separate signal from noise:

  1. Confirm the date range. Compare the same days of the week and check whether the movement is a one-day spike or a sustained shift.
  2. Separate 'all businesses' from 'businesses that moved'. A high average change among movers can coexist with many businesses staying still.
  3. Look at the local pack separately. Positions 1–3 can behave differently from positions 4–20.
  4. Check for new entrants. A rise in businesses entering the top 20 can indicate a broader reshuffle rather than a single listing's change.
  5. Record your own baseline. Keep a dated snapshot of your rankings so you can compare future volatility against your own normal.
  6. Treat theories as theories. Community explanations are useful context, not confirmed causes.

Frequently asked questions

What was the Bedlam Update?

The Bedlam Update is the nickname given to the period of unusual local ranking volatility tracked in early November 2019. Local RankFlux recorded a peak daily score of 4.71 on 6 November, compared with a usual range of 2.2–2.8. The name was coined by Joy Hawkins.

Did Google confirm a local algorithm update?

At the time of the original analysis, there was no official confirmation from Google of a local update. The volatility was discussed across the local search community, and several theories were proposed, but none were confirmed causes.

What did Local RankFlux measure?

Local RankFlux tracked daily ranking movements across more than 14,000 keywords to measure volatility and identify suspected algorithm updates. It compared data with the previous day and created a score based on fluctuations across different ranking groupings, split across 26 industries.

Why does the data separate 'all businesses' from 'businesses with movements'?

On a volatile day, more businesses move, so the average change across all businesses can look different from the average change among businesses that moved at all. Separating the two views helps distinguish a broad reshuffle from a small number of large jumps.

Average local ranking changes by date (all businesses)
DateAverage Change
01-Nov1.25
02-Nov1.60
03-Nov1.59
04-Nov1.69
05-Nov2.31
06-Nov2.41
07-Nov1.41
08-Nov1.69

Dated snapshot from the November 2019 analysis; not a current ranking signal.