Local Services Ads Click Study: Where Local Clicks Go
When Google shows Local Services ads above a local search result, the page changes shape.
This study put five San Francisco service-area searches in front of 5,500 testers, half of whom saw Local Services ads and half of whom did not, and asked each person to pick the result they would choose and explain why. The findings below describe how clicks divided across Local Services ads, PPC, the map, the local pack and organic results, and which signals pulled people toward each block. The data is a dated reference from the original study period; treat the percentages as a snapshot of that test, not a live benchmark.
How the test worked
Testers were recruited through Amazon Mechanical Turk and split evenly between two versions of the same local results page: one with Local Services ads present and one without. Every search was based in San Francisco and covered one of five service-area business types — garage door contractors, house painters, locksmiths, plumbers and towing companies. Each tester picked the single result they would click if they were hiring that type of business, then chose a reason from a fixed list. Because the same underlying searches were shown with and without Local Services ads, the differences in click share point to the effect of the ad block itself rather than to a different set of businesses. The study is a controlled comparison of one city and five trades, so read the numbers as directional evidence for how local searchers behave, not as a forecast for any specific market.
Where the clicks landed
The table below is the core result of the study. It reports the share of overall clicks each SERP slot received, first when Local Services ads were present and then when they were absent. The Local Services ad rows only apply to the version of the page that carried the ads, which is why the no-ads column shows a dash for those rows. Read the totals at the bottom of each block to compare whole result types rather than individual positions.
What the numbers show
Several patterns stand out. Local Services ads took 13.8% of clicks when they appeared, but they did not simply replace PPC: top PPC fell from 14.1% to 11.1%, a smaller drop than the ad block's own share. Organic results remained the largest single destination in both versions, though their share slipped from 50.8% to 43.9% when Local Services ads were on the page — a drop of 6.8%. The local pack held second place overall, followed by top PPC, and the local pack's top position was the single most-clicked slot after organic position one. Paid results as a whole — Local Services ads plus top PPC — accounted for 25.3% of clicks when the ad block was present, against 14.6% for top PPC alone when it was absent. The ad block also pulled attention upward: when Local Services ads were present, 55.8% of clicks landed before the organic results, compared with 48.7% on pages without them. Looking at concentration above the fold, 81.2% of people clicked above organic position two when Local Services ads were shown, against 76.1% when they were not.
The most-clicked slots, ranked
Ranking individual slots by click share makes the hierarchy concrete. Organic position one leads in both versions, at 25.5% with Local Services ads and 27.4% without. Local pack position one follows at 16.1% and 17.3%, then local pack position two at 10.4% and 12.0%, then top PPC position one at 8.5% and 10.5%. Local Services ad position one drew 7.4% when the block was present. Position one dominates within every block: the first Local Services ad drew more than double the clicks of positions two or three, the top PPC result drew around triple the clicks of the next two positions and roughly a hundred times the clicks of bottom-of-page PPC ads. The local pack was spread a little more evenly, helped by standout listing features, but its first position still led clearly. Across all five test pages, Yelp held the top organic spot.
Why people clicked where they did
Testers chose from a fixed list of reasons, and the ranking of those reasons is the most actionable part of the study. The top five reasons were: review rating in the local pack (15.44%), a link to a list of businesses in the organic results (14.52%), the link content of an organic result (14.00%), choosing an organic result because it was not an advert (11.98%), and the position of a PPC result on the page (6.05%). Review signals dominated overall: review numbers and ratings together motivated 23.2% of all clicks, and position on the page was cited for 17.5%. Directories played a major role — a link to a list of businesses was a key reason for 14.52% of overall clicks, while 3.18% of testers chose other organic results specifically because they were not links to directories. That directory reliance carries a warning: a separate Local Citations Trust Report found that 68% of consumers would stop using a local business if they found incorrect information in online directories, so accuracy across listings matters beyond a business's own site.
Local Services ads: star ratings lead
Review rating was the dominant reason testers clicked a Local Services ad, and clicks appeared to rise when high or comparatively high star ratings were shown. The clearest illustration came from the towing test: the ad in position one carried a 3.6-star rating and drew 5.8% of overall clicks, while the 4.5-star ad in position three drew 7.9%. Position alone did not win the click when the rating gap was visible. A practical consequence follows from where those ratings come from: Local Services ad ratings are drawn from Google My Business listings and from the Local Services ad platform itself, not from a business's reviews across the wider web. Building positive Google reviews therefore serves both the ad block and the local pack, while reviews collected only inside the ad platform do not feed back into the main listing.
PPC: prominence is the pull
For paid search results, the most common reason testers gave was the result's prominent position on the page. When Local Services ads appeared, PPC clicks fell from 14.1% to 11.1% — a drop, but not a one-for-one transfer, since the ad block took share from several areas at once. Paid results overall took 25.3% of clicks when Local Services ads were present. The study also noted that bottom-of-page PPC ads received only a tiny fraction of clicks, so the value of paid placement was concentrated at the top of the page. The specialist commentary added two caveats worth keeping in view: paid share would likely be higher on mobile, and in four of the five categories studied, Google Assistant voice results would have been entirely paid.
Local pack: ratings and review volume
Local pack clicks were led by review rating, followed by the number of reviews a business had. This combination was the single biggest motivator of any click across the whole study. Position was not decisive on its own: in one test the local pack business in position two, with a 5-star rating, outperformed the 4.3-star business in position one. In another, positions one and two both held 4.9 stars while position three held a perfect 5, yet the business in position two won on click-through — likely helped by a positive review snippet shown in its listing.
Map and organic: context and content
Map clicks were a small slice of the total — 2.0% with Local Services ads and 2.3% without — and testers who used the map were swayed more by the area it covered and how results were distributed across it than by the map's prominent position. Organic clicks were spread across several motivations. A large share went to results that promised a list of businesses rather than a single supplier — useful for searchers still comparing options. Roughly a third of organic clicks were attributed to the titles and descriptions shown in the result, and about a quarter were chosen because the searcher judged organic results more worthy than paid ones. Directory links featured heavily in the organic results across the tests, which helps explain why list-style results drew so much attention.
Worked example: the towing search
The towing companies search is a compact illustration of how the signals interact. The first Local Services ad had a lower star rating (3.6) than the ads in positions two and three. The third ad held the highest star rating and also the highest click rate of the three. In the local pack, all three businesses had fairly low ratings that were close to each other, and the business in position one received fewer clicks than the equivalent position in the other tests. The organic results were mostly business websites rather than directories, with only the first two and the last organic results linking to directories. Read together, the test suggests that when ratings are weak or tightly clustered, searchers lean more on other cues — and that a strong rating in a lower ad position can beat a weaker rating above it.
A practical checklist for local marketers
Use the study's findings as a prioritisation aid rather than a guarantee. Work through these checks in order:
- Audit your Google review rating and volume first. Review signals were the largest single driver of clicks in both the local pack and Local Services ads, so this is the highest-leverage fix.
- Confirm where your Local Services ad rating is sourced. Ratings come from Google My Business and the ad platform, so reviews collected only in one place will not lift the other.
- Treat position as a supporting factor, not the whole story. Prominent placement helped PPC and organic results, but a visible rating gap could override position in the ad block and the local pack.
- Check whether directory-style results are capturing your search traffic. List-style organic results drew a large share of clicks, so make sure your business information is accurate wherever those lists appear.
- Write descriptive titles and descriptions for organic results. About a third of organic clicks were attributed to the result's content.
- Do not ignore bottom-of-page PPC. It drew a negligible share of clicks in this test, so concentrate paid budget where the page actually gets seen.
Methodology and limits
The study used 5,500 testers on Amazon Mechanical Turk, split evenly between pages with and without Local Services ads. All searches were San Francisco service-area business queries across five trades. Testers chose one result and one reason from a fixed list. The design gives a clean comparison of the ad block's effect, but it is a single-city, single-period snapshot: search layouts, ad formats and consumer familiarity with Local Services ads have changed since the data was collected, so verify current conditions before applying the percentages to a live campaign. The original study also drew on commentary from service-area business and Local Services ads specialist Tom Waddington, whose observations informed the interpretation above.
Frequently asked questions
Do Local Services ads take clicks away from organic results?
In this study, organic results still received the largest share of clicks in both versions of the page, but their share fell from 50.8% to 43.9% when Local Services ads were present — a drop of 6.8%. The ad block also coincided with a smaller drop in top PPC clicks. The pattern suggests the ads draw attention from several areas at once rather than replacing one specific result type.
What is the single biggest reason people click a local result?
Review signals. Review rating in the local pack was the top individual reason at 15.44% of clicks, and review numbers and ratings together motivated 23.2% of all clicks across the study. Position on the page was cited for 17.5% of clicks.
Where do Local Services ad ratings come from?
Local Services ad ratings are drawn from Google My Business listings and from the Local Services ad platform itself, not from a business's reviews across the wider web. Reviews collected only inside the ad platform do not feed back into the main Google listing, so building Google My Business reviews supports both placements.
Can a lower Local Services ad position still win the click?
Yes, when the rating gap is visible. In the towing test, the ad in position one had a 3.6-star rating and received 5.8% of overall clicks, while the 4.5-star ad in position three received 7.9%. The study treats review rating as the dominant driver, with position as a supporting factor.
| SERP Result | Percentage of Overall SERP Clicks When Local Services Ads Are Present | Percentage of Overall SERP Clicks When Local Services Ads Are Not Present |
|---|---|---|
| Local Services Ad 1 | 7.4% | - |
| Local Services Ad 2 | 3.4% | - |
| Local Services Ad 3 | 3.0% | - |
| TOTAL Local Services Ads | 13.8% | - |
| PPC Top 1 | 8.5% | 10.5% |
| PPC Top 2 | 2.6% | 3.6% |
| TOTAL PPC Top | 11.1% | 14.1% |
| TOTAL Map | 2.0% | 2.3% |
| Local Pack 1 | 16.1% | 17.3% |
| Local Pack 2 | 10.4% | 12.0% |
| Local Pack 3 | 2.3% | 2.9% |
| TOTAL Local Pack | 28.8% | 32.3% |
| Organic 1 | 25.5% | 27.4% |
| Organic 2 | 4.0% | 5.7% |
| Organic 3 | 5.1% | 5.9% |
| Organic 4 | 2.9% | 3.3% |
| Organic 5 | 2.6% | 2.7% |
| Organic 6 | 1.0% | 1.5% |
| Organic 7 | 0.7% | 0.9% |
| Organic 8 | 0.7% | 1.6% |
| Organic 9 | 0.6% | 0.8% |
| Organic 10 | 0.8% | 0.9% |
| TOTAL Organic | 43.9% | 50.8% |
| PPC Bottom 1 | 0.1% | 0.2% |
| PPC Bottom 2 | 0% | 0.1% |
| PPC Bottom 3 | 0.1% | 0.1% |
| TOTAL PPC Bottom | 0.3% | 0.4% |
Dated reference from the original study period. Percentages are shares of overall clicks across five San Francisco service-area searches; the no-ads column shows a dash where Local Services ads were not present.