Local SEO Industry Survey 2016
The 2016 local SEO industry survey captured how search professionals described their businesses, priced their work and viewed the year ahead.
This guide summarises the reported findings, explains how to read the averages and medians, and shows how to use the dated benchmarks as a reference point rather than a current price list.
What the 2016 survey covered
Now in its fifth year, the survey studied business practices, pricing, services, attitudes and growth expectations across the local search industry. It was promoted to local SEO professionals during November and December 2016 and drew 868 respondents. It asked 20 questions split into two broad areas: the shape and outlook of SEO businesses, and the services and tasks those businesses delivered. Where useful, the report also set 2016 figures beside earlier results from 2013 and 2015 to show direction of travel, and invited a few industry experts to comment on the answers.
The questions ranged from company type and headcount to revenue, personal earnings, lead generation, conversion rates, pricing, retainer levels, growth expectations, service demand, outsourcing and time-consuming tasks. Because respondents came from local and regional agencies, national and international agencies, freelance SEOs, in-house teams and web design businesses, the results describe a mixed market rather than a single type of firm. The report also noted a planned follow-up: five additional reports breaking the results down by business type.
Headline findings at a glance
The report's own summary highlighted several benchmarks. On average, SEOs engaged in local optimisation reported earnings of $70,000 per year. The average local business customer paid $1,358 per month. 87% of SEOs reported a minimum monthly retainer of $500 or less. 86% definitely expected to grow their business over the next 12 months. Only 33% said 2017 was going to be a great year, compared with 47% in 2015. 39% felt SEO would be harder or much harder in 2017, against 20% who expected it to be easier. 41% believed social media was a powerful marketing channel for local businesses.
These are reported survey figures from the 2016 study. They are useful for understanding how respondents described the market at that time, but they are not a forecast of current rates or conditions.
Business profiles, team size and specialisation
Respondents were asked which description best matched their company; the report notes that "Other" was not an option in previous surveys. 35% identified as local or regional digital marketing agencies, 19% as national or international agencies, 18% as freelance SEOs, 13% as in-house SEOs and 11% as web designers. The report noted a slight rise in freelance participation and a longer-term increase in in-house SEOs between 2013 and 2016, from 7% to 13%. It also recorded a drop in businesses identifying as web designers, from 16% to 11%, which it suggested may reflect design firms adding other digital marketing services.
On team size, 79% said their company had one to five professional SEOs, 16% had six to 20, and only 5% had 21 or more. The report's analysis describes the majority as having between two and five SEOs, consistent with the large share of local agencies, freelancers and web designers in the sample.
On specialisation, 60% of SEOs served a variety of different industries, down from 67% in 2013. 24% served two to three vertical industries, up from 20% in 2013, and 16% served one vertical, the same as 2015. The report read this as a trend toward greater specialisation.
Revenue, earnings and client load
Median company revenue was approximately $150,000. 21% of respondents reported company revenue above $1 million, while 15% reported less than $30,000. The report described an average yearly revenue of $372,000, with a top-range revenue of $1 million, and noted that the largest group of respondents worked for regional and national agencies. This year's survey also included an "I don't know" answer for SEOs not privy to their company's revenue information.
On personal earnings, the average yearly income was $70,000 and the median was $45,000 to $60,000 per annum. 12% reported a six-figure salary, while 20% earned less than $30,000 per year. The report noted that the median income of $45,000 to $60,000 is higher than median individual incomes in the US, Canada and the UK. Respondents could decline to disclose earnings and were removed from the analysis.
Each SEO managed an average of 12 clients. 60% managed one to 10 clients and 23% managed 21 or more. The average client count had fallen from 14 in 2015, which the report linked to growing complexity and competition in local SEO. The report also notes that a 31+ option was not available in 2013.
Lead generation and conversion
Word of mouth was the most commonly cited effective channel for attracting new business at 77%, followed by SEO at 53%. Local business groups were cited by 25%, PPC by 22% and meet-ups or workshops by 16%. Respondents could select their top three answers. The report observed that SEO was the only digital channel in the top three, and the only one of the top three that grew, while word of mouth, local business groups and meet-ups fell in impact.
The median number of new leads proactively contacted each month was six to 10, up from two to five in 2015. 59% of SEOs proactively contacted fewer than 10 new leads per month. 25% contacted no new leads per month, 34% contacted one to 10, and 4% contacted 30 to 50.
The median success rate for converting leads into clients was 30%, unchanged from 2015; in 2013 the median close rate was 40%. 35% reported a conversion rate of 20% or less, while 25% reported 70% or more.
Pricing and retainer benchmarks
The average local business customer paid $1,358 per month, broadly in line with 2015. The median income per customer was $500 to $1,000 per month. 60% of SEOs received less than $1,000 per month from clients, down from 70% in 2013, while 40% received more than $1,000, up from 30% in 2013. The report also flagged a 3% rise over 2015 in the number of clients paying under $100 per month, and noted that 34% of clients paid less than $500 per month.
The minimum monthly retainer question was new in 2016. The median retainer was $300 to $500 per month. 87% reported a minimum monthly retainer of $500 or less, and only 14% received more than $1,500 per month from a client. The report's analysis described a $500-or-less monthly retainer as seeming very low given the time needed to execute an SEO campaign successfully.
These figures describe reported pricing in the 2016 survey. They should not be treated as current market rates without fresh evidence.
Growth expectations and outlook
86% of SEOs definitely expected to grow their business over the next 12 months, down from 93% in 2013. 13% said maybe, a 3% increase over 2015, and only 1% did not expect growth. The report described confidence as softer than in previous years but the general outlook as still positive, with excellent potential for growth.
On hiring, 67% of SEO agencies planned to recruit more staff in 2017, compared with 70% in 2013. 20% had no plans to recruit and 5% were not certain; "Not sure yet" was a new answer option. The report noted a 14% drop in those stating they would definitely be recruiting, and set out a pattern alongside the other results: 40% of agencies earned less than $100,000, clients per SEO fell from 14 to 12, conversion fell from 40% to 30%, and there was a 7% drop in agencies expecting to grow.
On the year ahead, 33% expected a great year, 46% expected a good but hard-working year and 3% expected it to be more difficult. The report observed that despite 86% expecting growth, sentiment was less positive than in recent years. On difficulty, 39% felt SEO would be harder or much harder in 2017 and 20% felt it would be easier; this question was new to the 2016 survey. The report noted that 41% of respondents felt the difficulty of performing SEO tasks would be the same as the previous year.
Services in demand and outsourcing
On-site SEO was the most in-demand service at 64%, followed by web design or development at 50%, Google My Business optimisation at 47% and PPC at 42%. Respondents could select as many answers as applied. The report noted that Google My Business services had increased by 4% over 2015, PPC had gone up slightly by 4%, and demand for social media marketing services had increased by 2% over the previous year.
On outsourcing, 56% outsourced less than 10% of their workload, 22% outsourced more than 25%, and 9% outsourced more than 50%. The report noted that outsourcing levels remained relatively low, and suggested that with 67% of agencies and consultants planning to recruit more staff in 2017, there may be more focus on keeping SEO work in-house to retain control over quality.
Social media and task responsibilities
41% of SEOs believed social media was a powerful marketing channel for local businesses, up 7% from 2015. 49% believed it worked for some local businesses. The report noted that fewer SEOs thought social media was over-hyped, down from 9% in 2013, and that only 1% believed social media does not work for local businesses.
On task responsibilities, respondents could select more than one answer. On-site optimisation, reporting and analytics, and SEO audits were the most commonly tackled tasks. Self-marketing and new business development were less commonly handled, with respondents favouring existing client work. Only 33% were responsible for review marketing. The report cited its own review study finding that seven out of ten consumers will leave a review if asked by the business, and recommended making review requests part of client management.
Most time-consuming tasks
Link building, citations and reporting or analytics were named as the most time-consuming tasks. Link building has consistently appeared at the top of this list across the survey's history, and its reported time burden rose in 2016. The report linked that rise to links being cited as a more crucial factor in both organic and local ranking than ever before. Citations remained time-consuming but dropped in the 2016 results, which the report linked to a reduced impact of citations in local ranking factors and better outsourcing options for citation building. Reporting and analytics were also described as time-consuming and often confusing for both SEOs and their clients.
How to use these dated benchmarks
Treat the 2016 figures as a historical reference point, not a current price list. Before using any benchmark in a proposal or planning session, check whether it still reflects your market, your service scope and your client mix. The checklist below can help.
- Confirm the survey year and the respondent group before quoting a figure.
- Distinguish averages from medians: a small number of high earners can pull an average above the typical respondent.
- Match the benchmark to the service scope. A retainer for on-site SEO, citations and reporting may not compare directly with a narrower or broader package.
- Check whether the figure is a company-level or individual-level measure.
- Note that respondents could select multiple answers on service-demand and channel questions, so percentages do not sum to 100.
- Refresh any pricing or conversion benchmark with current evidence before presenting it to a client.
Worked example: comparing a hypothetical agency
Suppose a small agency reports a minimum monthly retainer of $750 and an average client payment of $1,200. Against the 2016 survey, the retainer sits above the reported median of $300 to $500 and above the $500-or-less band that covered 87% of respondents. The average client payment sits below the reported $1,358 average but within the $500 to $1,000 median band's upper edge. The agency could use those comparisons to ask whether its pricing reflects a narrower service scope, a different client size, or a deliberate premium position. The figures do not prove the agency is over- or under-priced; they simply provide a dated reference point for a pricing conversation.
Frequently asked questions
How many people took part in the 2016 local SEO industry survey?
The survey drew 868 respondents and was promoted to local SEO professionals during November and December 2016. It asked 20 questions covering business profile, pricing, services and outlook.
What was the average local SEO client payment in 2016?
The reported average was $1,358 per month per local business customer. The median was $500 to $1,000 per month. These are 2016 survey figures and should not be treated as current rates.
Why do the survey's averages and medians differ so much?
Averages are pulled upward by a small number of high earners or high-value clients. Medians show the middle of the distribution and are often a better guide to the typical respondent. The survey reports both, so readers can see the spread rather than a single headline number.
Which tasks did SEOs find most time-consuming in 2016?
Link building, citations and reporting or analytics were the most time-consuming tasks. Link building has consistently appeared at the top of this list across the survey's history.