Skip to content

79% of US Consumers Believe They've Read a Fake Review in the Last Year

The 2017 Local Consumer Review Survey, an annual study of US consumer attitudes to online reviews, reported that most respondents believed they had encountered a fake review within the previous year.

The findings also revealed a confidence gap: many of the same respondents admitted they could not reliably tell genuine reviews from fabricated ones. This page summarises those reported findings and explains why they matter for anyone who relies on local business reviews. The figures below are drawn from that published survey report and are presented as its findings, not as new research.

Key findings from the survey

The survey, part of the annual Local Consumer Review Survey, asked US consumers about their experiences with online reviews on platforms such as Google My Business, Yelp and Facebook. As reported in the published survey, three findings stand out:

  • 79% of respondents believed they had read a fake review in the last year.
  • 84% said they "can't always" spot a fake review.
  • A quarter of respondents said they had read a lot of fake reviews in the past year.

These figures suggest that fake reviews are not isolated incidents but a widespread experience. The gap between encountering fake reviews and being able to identify them is central to the problem: consumers may be exposed to misleading content without realising it.

What counts as a fake review?

The survey defined fake reviews broadly. They include reviews written by the business itself or by people connected to it, paid-for reviews, and reviews left by ex-employees or competitors that do not accurately reflect the customer experience. In each case, the review is intended to manipulate the average star rating — either to boost or to damage a business's reputation.

This definition matters because it goes beyond the stereotype of a competitor leaving a one-star review. A business asking staff to leave positive reviews is equally a source of fake content, and the effect on consumer trust is the same.

Why fake reviews matter for trust

The survey results point to a tension. Consumers increasingly say they trust online reviews as much as personal recommendations, yet a large majority are not confident they can distinguish real from fake. When the average star rating is one of the most important factors in a review profile, that uncertainty can undermine the value of the rating itself.

For businesses, the risk runs in two directions. A business whose rating is artificially lowered by fake negative reviews may lose custom. A business that benefits from fake positive reviews may gain short-term advantage but contributes to a wider erosion of trust in review platforms. The survey report noted that review sites have not always treated fake reviews as a priority, and that removing them can be complex for business owners.

A practical checklist for reading reviews

The survey does not offer a foolproof method for spotting fake reviews, but its findings suggest a cautious approach. When evaluating a business's reviews, consider:

  • Look beyond the star average. Read a sample of recent reviews in full rather than relying on the headline rating.
  • Check for patterns. A sudden cluster of extremely positive or negative reviews, especially with similar wording, may warrant scepticism.
  • Consider the reviewer's history. On platforms that show reviewer profiles, a history of reviews across many unrelated businesses can be a signal.
  • Weigh specificity. Reviews that describe a particular experience in detail are generally more useful than generic praise or complaint.
  • Remember the confidence gap. Since most consumers admit they cannot always spot a fake review, treat any single review as one data point rather than a definitive verdict.

Frequently asked questions

What percentage of US consumers believe they have read a fake review?

In the 2017 Local Consumer Review Survey, 79% of US consumers said they believed they had read a fake review in the last year.

Can consumers reliably spot a fake review?

No. In the same survey, 84% of respondents admitted they "can't always" spot a fake review, even though most believed they had encountered one.

What types of reviews were considered fake in the survey?

The survey defined fake reviews as those left by the business itself or its connections, paid-for reviews, and reviews from ex-employees or competitors that do not accurately reflect the business experience.

Why do fake reviews matter for local businesses?

Fake reviews can artificially raise or lower a business's average star rating, which is a key factor consumers use when choosing a local business. Widespread fake reviews can also erode trust in review platforms generally.