Brand Beacon Report 2024: What Separates Multi-location High Performers
The Brand Beacon Report 2024 turns a survey of 200 marketing decision-makers at multi-location and franchise brands in the USA, UK and Canada into a practical benchmark.
It shows how the report defines its segments, what the High Performers did differently, and how to read the channel investment and impact scores without confusing the two. All figures are a dated reference from that survey period, not a current measurement of the market.
How the benchmark is built
The survey covered 200 marketing decision-makers at multi-location and franchise businesses across the USA, UK and Canada, with screening to keep respondents within the target criteria. Two different segmentations run through the report, and they answer different questions. Performance groups compare brands by how their 2023 marketing performed against expectations. Size groups compare brands by location count. A brand can sit in the Big Brands size group and still be an Average Performer, because the performance split is independent of scale. The research partner for the original study is not stated here; if you need that detail, refer to the report's own methodology section. The report's own definitions are reproduced in the legal directory table below. Read them before comparing any percentage, since 'High Performers' is a self-reported performance label, not an audited ranking.
Segment definitions used throughout
The table below is the report's own glossary. Use it as the control map: performance labels (High/Average Performers) and size labels (Big Brands, Regional Challengers, Local Players) are separate axes, so a finding about Big Brands is not automatically a finding about High Performers.
Headline findings at a glance
Five numbers frame the rest of the report. 94% of High Performers had a dedicated local marketing strategy, against 60% of Average Performers. High Performers were 15% more likely to focus on customer retention and satisfaction. 88% of multi-location marketers were already using generative AI somewhere in the organisation. 77% felt optimistic about 2024 economic conditions, and 81% said they were likely to open new locations in 2024.
Social media, email marketing, paid advertising and video were the most common local tactics across all business sizes.
2023 performance and team capability
Only 4% of respondents said their marketing performance fell below expectations in 2023, and almost two-thirds said it exceeded them. On capability, the top five challenges rated 'Very Good' or 'Good' were consistent brand standards, understanding local area requirements, consistency of reputation, internal communication, and understanding marketing ownership. The weakest area was managing adoption of initiatives and streamlining external communications, where 23% rated themselves 'Fair' to 'Poor'. That gap between internal communication confidence and downstream execution is worth checking in your own organisation.
Strategy and technology adoption
86% of multi-location brands had a dedicated local marketing strategy. Almost half (45%) used a hybrid model combining central HQ marketing with branch or location-level activity. 98% said they used technology to support local strategies.
The High Performers pulled ahead on both counts: 94% had a dedicated local strategy, and 56% used marketing technology 'to a great extent' versus 22% of Average Performers. 36% of High Performers used generative AI 'to a great extent', against 13% of Average Performers. If your team rates its local SEO knowledge as 'Fair' or 'Poor', that is a signal to check training and tool fit before adding more channels.
Where the channel money goes
The top five channels by investment across all brands are shown in the channel investment table below. Social media leads at 51%, with paid social, SEO and TV tied at 36%, and local SEO at 35%. PPC sat at the bottom of the list, below several traditional channels.
Among High Performers, 95% invested a medium-high amount in social media and just 1% invested nothing. Local SEO was the third-highest area of investment for High Performers, with 76% making medium-high investments. PPC was the least-invested channel for that group.
Objectives and 2024 priorities
High Performers weighted their business outcomes fairly evenly. 67% focused on customer satisfaction, 15% more than Average Performers, and they were 15% more likely to focus on retention. Average Performers leaned harder on acquisition (68%) and revenue growth (80%).
For 2024, 39% of High Performers prioritised customer satisfaction, 38% prioritised increasing locations, and 35% prioritised AI and automation. Average Performers put customer acquisition first at 63%, followed by brand awareness at 50% and efficiency at 47%. The pattern suggests a difference in emphasis rather than a single lever.
Local tactics that separate the groups
High Performers were 25% more likely to use video (63% vs 38%) and 16% more likely to use reputation management (46% vs 30%). Average Performers were 13% more likely to rely on outreach (59% vs 46%). Local rankings optimisation, reputation management and citations were the visibility-focused tactics where High Performers led.
A practical test: pick one or two locations and run a video or reputation pilot before scaling. The report's own example uses a home-improvement search to show how category labels, profile completeness and review consistency can affect whether a brand appears for a local query.
How findings shift by business size
The top three objectives and top three 2024 priorities by size group are reproduced in the two tables below. Big Brands were the closest to the High Performers on strategy maturity, with 92% holding a dedicated local strategy. Regional Challengers showed the biggest gaps: 27% rated their teams' local SEO understanding as 'Fair' or 'Poor', and they were the least likely to have a local SEO strategy in place. Local Players were closer to the High Performers on understanding, at 90% 'Good' or 'Very Good'.
Regional Challengers also stood out on challenges: 35% cited increasing competition, and 32% saw updating their tech stack as a big challenge. Big Brands cited rising labour costs (42%) and emerging technology as top concerns. Local Players cited rising material costs (39%).
Generative AI, ROI and the 2024 outlook
88% of multi-location businesses were already using generative AI, and 28% used it 'to a great extent'. Of those investing, 64% said the ROI had exceeded expectations and 98% said it had met or exceeded them. The biggest opportunity areas named were data analysis (36%), SEO (24%) and forecasting and prediction (23%).
On the economy, 77% felt optimistic about 2024 and only 10% pessimistic. 81% said they were likely to open new locations that year.
How to read the investment and impact scores
The report scores channels on a 0-10 scale. High investment or impact is worth 10, medium 6, low 3, and no investment 0. Because only brands that invest in a channel can rate its impact, the two scores are not directly comparable and should not be subtracted from each other as if they were the same measure.
Worked example from the report: for High Performers on social media, high impact (10) times 64 respondents equals 640; medium impact (6) times 49 equals 294; low impact (3) times 10 equals 30. The sum is 964 across 123 respondents, giving an impact score of 7.8/10. Use the same arithmetic if you want to reproduce the scoring for your own channel set.
Selected reported scores: High Performers saw SEO at 7.0 investment vs 7.3 impact, and PPC at 5.9 investment vs 6.6 impact. Local Players saw social media impact at 7.6/10. Regional Challengers saw social media impact at 8/10. Big Brands saw paid social impact at 7.5/10.
A decision checklist for your own brand
Use these questions to turn the benchmark into a diagnosis rather than a scorecard. 1. Strategy: do we have a documented local marketing strategy that location teams can act on, or only a central plan? 2. Knowledge: can our team explain how local SEO differs from traditional SEO, and where our weakest locations sit? 3. Technology: which tools are actually used to a great extent, and where is adoption shallow? 4. Objectives: are we weighting acquisition so heavily that retention and satisfaction are under-resourced? 5. Tactics: are video, reputation management, local rankings and citations covered, or are we over-reliant on outreach? 6. Measurement: are we comparing investment scores with impact scores as if they were the same scale? If the answer to question 6 is yes, revisit the scoring method before drawing conclusions. If you plan to share findings or charts from the report, check the original publisher's terms for credit requirements. Questions about the research can go to the contact address given in the report's methodology section.
| Term | Definition |
|---|---|
| High Performers | Brands who said their marketing performance 'exceeded' expectations in 2023 |
| Average Performers | Brands who said their marketing performance 'met' or 'fell short' of expectations in 2023 |
| Big Brands | Brands with 101+ locations |
| Regional Challengers | Brands with 51-100 locations |
| Local Players | Brands with 11-50 locations |
Self-reported performance label and location count, from a 2024 survey of 200 respondents. Not an audited ranking.
| Rank | Channel | Share |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Social Media | 51% |
| 2= | Paid Social | 36% |
| 2= | SEO | 36% |
| 2= | TV | 36% |
| 5 | Local SEO | 35% |
Dated 2024 survey reference. Check current channel conditions before acting.
| Challenge | Share |
|---|---|
| Consistent brand standards | 85% |
| Understanding local area requirements | 84% |
| Consistency of reputation | 82% |
| Communicating internally | 82% |
| Understanding marketing ownership | 80% |
Self-rated capability, 2024 survey. Dated reference.
| Rank | High Performers | Big Brands | Regional Challengers | Local Players |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Revenue growth (70%) | Revenue growth (75%) | Revenue growth (70%) | Revenue growth (67%) |
| 2. | Customer satisfaction (67%) | Customer satisfaction (69%) | Brand awareness (62%) | Brand awareness (65%) |
| 3. | Brand awareness (66%) | Brand awareness (68%) Customer retention (68%) | Customer acquisition (54%) Customer retention (54%) | Customer satisfaction (63%) Customer acquisition (63%) |
Dated 2024 survey reference. Ties shown as reported.
| Rank | High Performers | Big Brands | Regional Challengers | Local Players |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Increase efficiency (46%) | Increase efficiency (49%) | Grow brand awareness (51%) | Increase efficiency (47%) |
| 2. | Improve customer retention (45%) | Increase AI and automation (49%) | Increase efficiency (41%) | Grow brand awareness (46%) |
| 3. | Improve customer satisfaction (39%) | Improve customer satisfaction (44%) | Improve customer satisfaction (41%) | Increase customer acquisition (40%) Improve customer satisfaction (40%) Increase business locations (40%) |
Dated 2024 survey reference. Ties shown as reported.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Big Brand automatically a High Performer?
No. The two groups are defined on different axes. High and Average Performers are split by whether 2023 marketing performance exceeded, met or fell short of expectations. Big Brands, Regional Challengers and Local Players are split by location count. Both performance groups contain businesses of all sizes, so a large location count does not by itself place a brand in the High Performers group.
Can I compare a channel's investment score with its impact score directly?
Not as a like-for-like difference. Only respondents who said they invest in a channel were asked to rate its impact, so the two questions have different respondent bases. The report uses the same 0-10 weighting for both, but the scores describe different populations. Use them to compare channels within the same measure, not to subtract one from the other.
How current are these figures?
They are a dated reference from the Brand Beacon Report 2024 survey of 200 marketing decision-makers in the USA, UK and Canada. They describe the period covered by the report, not present-day market conditions. Check current data before using any figure in a budget or board decision.
What should a Regional Challenger check first?
The report flags three areas where Regional Challengers trailed: local SEO knowledge, having a dedicated local strategy, and updating the tech stack. A sensible first step is to confirm whether a documented local strategy exists and whether the team can explain the difference between traditional and local SEO. Those two checks are prerequisites for getting value from any tooling you add.
| 1. Social Media | 51% |
|---|---|
| 2=Paid Social | 36% |
| 2=SEO | 36% |
| 2=TV | 36% |
| 5. Local SEO | 35% |
| Consistent brand standards | 85% |
|---|---|
| Understanding local area requirements | 84% |
| Consistency of reputation | 82% |
| Communicating internally | 82% |
| Understanding marketing ownership | 80% |
| High Performers | Big Brands | Regional Challengers | Local Players | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Revenue growth (70%) | Revenue growth (75%) | Revenue growth (70%) | Revenue growth (67%) |
| 2. | Customer satisfaction (67%) | Customer satisfaction (69%) | Brand awareness (62%) | Brand awareness (65%) |
| 3. | Brand awareness (66%) | Brand awareness (68%) Customer retention (68%) | Customer acquisition (54%) Customer retention (54%) | Customer satisfaction (63%) Customer acquisition (63%) |
| 1. | Increase efficiency (46%) | Increase efficiency (49%) | Grow brand awareness (51%) | Increase efficiency (47%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2. | Improve customer retention (45%) | Increase AI and automation (49%) | Increase efficiency (41%) | Grow brand awareness (46%) |
| 3. | Improve customer satisfaction (39%) | Improve customer satisfaction (44%) | Improve customer satisfaction (41%) | Increase customer acquisition (40%) Improve customer satisfaction (40%) Increase business locations (40%) |