Skip to content

Local Consumer Review Survey 2024: What US Shoppers Read, Trust and Write

Reviews shape local choices long before a customer walks through the door.

This guide distils the 2024 findings on where people look, which signals they trust, how they respond to business replies, and when they are willing to leave feedback themselves. Use it as a practical checklist for reputation work across search, maps, social and local news.

People check reviews often — and in more than one place

The 2024 Local Consumer Review Survey was conducted using a representative panel of 1,141 US consumers via SurveyMonkey. Reviews are now a routine part of choosing a local business. Three quarters of respondents read them always or regularly, while only a small minority never read them. People also rarely rely on a single source: 77% checked at least two review platforms and 41% checked three or more. For a business, that means a strong profile on one site is not enough. Information, ratings and replies need to be consistent wherever customers look.

A useful starting checklist is to audit your presence across your main review platform, maps, social channels and any industry-specific directories. Check that names, opening hours, services and contact details match, then look for gaps in recent reviews or unanswered feedback.

Google leads, but social and AI sources are growing

Google remained the most-used review site, used by 81% of consumers, although that share fell from 87% a year earlier. Apple Maps and Trustpilot moved against the general downward trend. Facebook and Yelp both declined, and Tripadvisor and the Better Business Bureau also fell since 2022.

Beyond dedicated review sites, social platforms matter. Instagram was used by 34% and TikTok by 23% as alternative review sources. Local news rose by eight percentage points, and almost one in ten respondents used ChatGPT or similar generative AI tools for review information. Monitor comments and mentions on social channels as well as formal review profiles, because customers may encounter praise or complaints there first.

Within Google's own review interface, filtering tools are widely valued. 96% of consumers found the 'search reviews' function useful in some way, and 47% rated 'sort by newest' as highly useful — a sign that recency guides which businesses people shortlist. The feature consumers were most likely to find not useful at all was a 'highlighted' review, at 15%, suggesting readers prefer to judge relevance themselves rather than be steered. Similar sort and keyword-filter tools appear on platforms such as Yelp and Tripadvisor, so a steady stream of recent, specific reviews helps wherever customers filter.

What builds confidence: detail, recency and a credible rating

Written descriptions of positive experiences were the strongest reassurance, influencing 69% of consumers. Reviews from named users became more persuasive, rising to 48% from 40% in 2023. That shift suggests readers are looking for accountability and detail rather than treating every rating at face value.

Star ratings still matter, but context matters more. Most consumers expected an average between 4.0 and 5.0 stars, and 59% expected between 20 and 99 reviews before trusting that average. At the same time, fewer consumers ruled out businesses below three stars than in 2023, which may reflect readers checking the underlying comments when a score looks unusually low or high. Recency is another key signal: 27% expected reviews no older than two weeks, up from 25% in 2023.

Practical implication: aim for a steady flow of detailed, recent reviews rather than a one-off campaign. Encourage customers to mention specific services, staff or outcomes, because those details help future readers judge whether the business fits their needs.

Respond to every review, promptly and in a balanced way

Replying to reviews is not optional for most customers. 88% said they would use a business that responds to all of its reviews, compared with 47% for one that responds to none. Responding only to praise or only to complaints can look selective, so a balanced approach is safer.

Speed also matters. 93% expected a response, 87% expected one within two weeks, and 34% expected a reply within two to three days. Build a simple workflow: assign an owner, review new feedback daily or several times a week, draft replies for positive and negative comments, and escalate any issue that needs an offline follow-up.

In a blind test, 58% preferred an AI-generated response to a human-written one. The lesson is not to automate without review, but to use drafting tools carefully while keeping the tone personal, accurate and specific to the customer's experience.

Ask for reviews at the right moment — without incentives

73% of consumers had written a review in the past year. Positive-only reviewers outnumbered negative-only reviewers, at 38% compared with 10%. Prompting works: 69% recalled writing after a brand prompt, up from 60% in 2023, and 19% said they always leave a review when asked.

Email was the preferred prompt method at 32%, followed by in-person requests at 28% and social media at 27%. Timing should fit the experience. Food and drink businesses were expected to ask within two to three days, with 24% expecting a same-day prompt. Healthcare prompts were expected within three days to a week by 40%, while 11% did not want a real estate review prompt at all.

A respectful request routine is therefore: ask once, offer a choice of platforms, keep the link simple, match timing to the industry, and stop after one reminder. Incentives are a poor shortcut: recall of incentives offered in exchange for reviews rose across every type between 2023 and 2024 — discounts from 26% to 45% (+19), gift or service from 18% to 33% (+15), cash from 12% to 23% (+11), loyalty points or reward scheme from 15% to 24% (+9), and competition or prize draw entry from 17% to 25% (+8). Most review platforms prohibit incentivised reviews and may remove profiles or label them accordingly. Rewards also skew both whether a review is written and what it says, which weakens trust in the whole system — a caution worth treating as a policy rule for any review programme.

A practical reputation checklist

Treat reputation as an ongoing operating process, not a periodic task. Keep profiles accurate across platforms, seek detailed and recent reviews, reply to positive and negative feedback within days, monitor social and local-news mentions, and make review requests easy and well timed. The strongest long-term advantage comes from memorable customer experiences that give people a genuine reason to write.

Review signals at a glance
Signal2024 findingAction
Platforms checked77% used at least two; 41% used three or moreMaintain consistent profiles across platforms
Leading platformGoogle: 81%Prioritise Google profile accuracy and recent reviews
Expected ratingMost expected 4.0 to 5.0 starsAim for at least 4.0 and read low-score context
Expected review count59% expected 20 to 99 reviewsBuild a steady review flow
Response expectation93% expected a reply; 34% within two to three daysAssign review monitoring and reply ownership
Preferred request methodEmail 32%; in person 28%; social media 27%Offer choice and keep the request simple
Incentive recall 2023 to 2024Discount 26% to 45%; gift/service 18% to 33%; cash 12% to 23%; loyalty 15% to 24%; competition 17% to 25%Do not incentivise reviews; most platforms prohibit it

Survey of 1,141 US consumers conducted for the 2024 edition.

Frequently asked questions

How often do consumers read online reviews?

In this 2024 survey of 1,141 US consumers, 75% said they always or regularly read online reviews during business research, and only 3% said they never do. That habit was broadly stable compared with 2023.

Which review platform do consumers use most?

Google was still the leading review platform at 81%, down from 87% in 2023. Apple Maps and Trustpilot were the exceptions to a general decline among listed sites, rising to 16% and 10% respectively.

How many reviews and what rating do consumers expect?

Most consumers expected 20 to 99 reviews before trusting an average star rating, and most expected an average between 4.0 and 5.0 stars. Recency also mattered: 27% expected reviews as fresh as two weeks.

Do review responses affect whether consumers choose a business?

88% said they would use a business that replies to all reviews, compared with 47% for a business that replies to none. 93% expected a response, and 34% expected one within two to three days.

How and when should businesses ask for reviews?

Email was the most preferred request method at 32%, followed by in-person at 28% and social media at 27%. Timing varied by industry: food and drink prompts were expected fastest, while healthcare, trades and real estate allowed a longer window.

20232024YoY Increase
Discount26%45%19%
Gift or service18%33%15%
Cash12%23%11%
Loyalty points or reward scheme15%24%9%
Competition or prize draw entry17%25%8%